Likkutei Torah · Parshas Shemini Atzeres · Maamar 1
ביום השמיני עצרת תהיה לכם
“On the Eighth Day, There Shall Be an Atzeres for You”
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
A created being can move its Creator only because G‑d bound Himself, by an oath above reason, to the love hidden in every Jew; the festivals and daily Torah study draw that power down, and on Shemini Atzeres the encompassing light of Sukkos is gathered inward to empower every mitzvah of the year.
The maamar in brief
The maamar asks why study is “great because it leads to action,” and what “His left hand is under my head” means. It answers through Micah’s verse. “Truth to Yaakov” is G‑d’s own view, in which the world is nothing before Him, revealed even at the lowest “heel”; we “concede” to it in Hodu, Modim and Hallel. From this truth comes “kindness to Avraham”: mitzvos that draw kindness from above. Their power comes from “the oath to our fathers”: the fathers are the natural love for G‑d inherited by every Jew, never lost even by one who is “cut off,” and G‑d’s oath, by which He bound Himself beyond His own wisdom and will, empowers it. The mitzvos reach G‑d’s own delight, above all the World to Come; teshuvah reaches a deeper delight still, the king’s joy at a son returning from afar. That is the “left hand” of the Ten Days of Teshuvah, and the “right hand” is Sukkos’ embracing light. Torah study gives the same power daily. On Shemini Atzeres, through contemplation and the joy of Torah, this encompassing light is gathered into the soul.
Outline
- Truth to YaakovThe questions; the two “knowledges,” from below and from above; conceding to G‑d’s truth in Hodu, Modim and Hallel; truth, which is Torah, flowing into the mitzvos as “kindness to Avraham.”¶1–5
- The oath to the fathersHow a creature can arouse its Creator: the inherited natural love, present even in one liable to kares, and G‑d’s oath, which binds Him above wisdom and will, drawn from “the days of old.”¶6–8
- The delight in the mitzvos“Asher kiddeshanu”: the mitzvos are G‑d’s will, rooted in His delight, and reveal a delight greater than all the World to Come; the delight of Shabbos.¶9
- Teshuvah, the left hand and the rightThe king’s deeper delight in a son returning from afar; the Ten Days of Teshuvah and Yom Kippur as “His left hand under my head”; Sukkos as the right hand’s encompassing embrace that strengthens the natural love.¶10–11
- Torah study every daySpoken Torah forms an encompassing light for the soul, like a sukkah; why Gemara must be studied even beyond practice; Torah brings peace to the far and to the near.¶12–14
- Study, action and Shemini AtzeresThe Talmud’s debate resolved: study gives action its power. The eighth day is Binah, contemplation and the joy of Simchas Torah, when the encompassing light is gathered inward.¶15
- SummaryThe maamar’s own brief summary of its five sections and of Shemini Atzeres, adding why the prayer for rain begins on that day.¶16–20
Key concepts
- Two knowledgesב׳ דעות
- The view from below, in which the world is real and the spiritual seems like nothing, and the view from above, in which the world is nothing before G‑d. They correspond to the lower and higher unities.
- Arousal from below and arousal from aboveאתערותא דלתתא ואתערותא דלעילא
- The principle that a human deed below draws a Divine response from above; the maamar asks where this power comes from.
- Natural loveאהבה טבעית
- The hidden love for G‑d inherited from the Patriarchs, present in every Jewish soul and shown in readiness for self-sacrifice; it is “our fathers” in Micah’s verse.
- The oathשבועה
- G‑d’s binding commitment, as it were against His own wisdom and will, drawn from the level above the chain of descent; it gives the natural love the power to arouse G‑d’s love.
- Supernal delightעונג העליון
- G‑d’s own pleasure, the root of His will; the mitzvos reveal it, and teshuvah reaches its inner core.
- Encompassing and inner lightמקיף ופנימי
- Light that surrounds and cannot be grasped, like the sukkah’s shade, versus light absorbed within; Shemini Atzeres turns the first into the second.
- Contemplationבינה / התבוננות
- The eighth level counting upward; reflection through which a person comes to see himself as nothing before G‑d.
For children · ages 9–13
The promise to our fathers
The big idea
Every Jew has a love for G‑d that can never be lost, and G‑d promised our fathers to answer it; on Shemini Atzeres we take the light of Sukkos inside us for the whole year.
How can a person, whom G‑d created, move G‑d Himself? The maamar answers with a verse: “Give truth to Yaakov, kindness to Avraham, as You swore to our fathers.” “Truth to Yaakov” is how G‑d sees things: before Him the whole world is as nothing. We agree to this truth when we say Hodu, Modim and Hallel. From this truth comes “kindness to Avraham”: the mitzvos, which draw G‑d’s kindness into the world. Their power comes from “the oath to our fathers.” Every Jew inherits from the Avos a natural love for G‑d that is never lost, and G‑d bound Himself to that love with an oath, a promise deeper than any reason. When we do a mitzvah, we reach G‑d’s own delight. When we do teshuvah, returning to G‑d, He has an even deeper joy, like a king whose son comes home from far away. Learning Torah every day, out loud, gives the mitzvos their strength. On Shemini Atzeres, through the joy of Torah, the light that surrounded us on Sukkos comes inside us.
The mashal
A king is glad when his son does what he asks. But when a son who has been far away comes back home, the king’s joy is even deeper. So G‑d delights in our mitzvos, and has a deeper joy still when we do teshuvah and come back to Him.
Questions for the Shabbos table
- Why can the love for G‑d that every Jew inherits never be lost?
- What does it mean that before G‑d the whole world is “as nothing”?
- When could you learn a little Torah out loud each day this week?
Explanation © likuteitorah.com, CC BY-NC 4.0: retold for children from our translation and explanation, with AI assistance; not yet reviewed by a human editor.
The Rebbe’s maamarim on this maamar · 2
With the same ד״ה
These 2 maamarim of the Rebbe open with the same words as this one (5720–5722): where each is printed, and the full text free at Lahak.
Truth to Yaakov ¶1–5
“On the eighth day, there shall be an atzeres (assembly) for you.” Now, it is written, “His left hand is under my head, and his right hand embraces me.” [We need] to understand what “under my head” means.
The maamar opens with the Torah’s verse on Shemini Atzeres, the eighth day that follows the seven days of Sukkos. It pairs it with a verse from the Song of Songs, which Chassidus reads as the embrace between G‑d and the Jewish people, and asks what it means that the left hand is “under my head.”
¶11 Hold this question about "under my head": paragraph 11 answers it.
הנה ארז״ל [אמרו רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] יפה שעה4 אחת בתשובה ומע״ט [ומעשים טובים] בעוה״ז מכל חיי העוה״ב [העולם הבא].5 וכבר נתבאר פעמים רבות במ״א.6
Now, our Sages, of blessed memory, said: “One hour of teshuvah (return) and good deeds in this world is finer than all the life of the World to Come.” This has already been explained many times elsewhere.
The Mishnah in Pirkei Avos says that one hour of teshuvah and good deeds here is worth more than the whole of the World to Come. In Torah Ohr, Chayei Sarah, the Alter Rebbe explains it this way: the mitzvos are rooted in G‑d’s own will, higher than the “radiance of the Shechinah” that souls enjoy in Gan Eden; this maamar will show that both mitzvos and teshuvah reach a delight in G‑d that no reward in the World to Come can equal.
¶9 Why one hour here outweighs the World to Come: paragraph 9 explains.
The opening sets out the verse of the festival, a verse from the Song of Songs whose phrase “under my head” needs explaining, and the Mishnah about teshuvah and good deeds that the maamar will build on.
The Kehot notes record that another transcript of this maamar exists, that the Mitteler Rebbe based a discourse on it, and that the Tzemach Tzedek’s Or HaTorah prints abridgments, glosses and an explanation of it.
TermsAtzeresOlam HaBaOlam HaZehTeshuvah
- Atzeres עצרת
- Olam HaBa עולם הבא
- Olam HaZeh עולם הזה
- Teshuvah תשובה
Marei mekomos
- 1ביום השמיני עצרת · הנחה אחרת בסה״מ תקס״ג ח״ב ע׳ תשעב. הדרוש ביום השמע״צ במאמרי אדה״א שמע״צ ע׳ א׳שיג מיוסד על מאמר זה. קיצורים והגהות נדפסו באוה״ת שמע״צ ע׳ א׳תשצד. ביאור שם ע׳ א׳תשצח. קיצורים ע׳ א׳תתכ. כמה ענינים מהמאמר נתבארו בד״ה ביום השמיני שלח תשמ״א (סה״מ מלוקט ח״ב ע׳ קלד ואילך).
- 2ביום השמיני עצרת · Numbers 29:35
- 3שמאלו תחת לראשי · Song of Songs 2:6
- 4יפה שעה בתשובה ומע״ט כו׳ · אבות פ״ד, מי״ז.
- 5יפה שעה אחת בתשובה ומע״ט בעוה״ז מכל חיי העוה״ב · Pirkei Avot 4:17
- 6וכבר נתבאר פעמים רבות במ״א · ראה תו״א טז, א ואילך. וראה לקמן במפתח כ״ק אדמו״ר ערך יפה שעה אחת.
2וכעת יובן בהקדים מארז״ל [מאמר רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה.1 והקושיא מפורסמת מאחר שעיקר מה שתלמוד גדול הוא מחמת שמביא לידי מעשה א״כ אדרבה מזה הטעם עצמו הרי המעשה גדול.
And now it will be understood by first introducing the saying of our Sages, of blessed memory: “Study is great, for it leads to action.” The well-known question is: since the main reason study is great is that it leads to action, then, on the contrary, for this very reason action is greater.
The Talmud concludes that study is great because it leads to action. The classic difficulty: if study’s value lies in bringing action, then action, the goal, should be the greater of the two.
¶15 Hold this question of study versus action: paragraph 15 resolves it.
אך הנה צריך להבין מהות ענין המעשה כי רמ״ח פקודין אינון רמ״ח2 אברים דמלכא
However, one needs to understand the essential nature of action, for “the 248 commandments are the 248 limbs of the King.”
To answer, the maamar first asks what a mitzvah deed really is. The Tikkunei Zohar calls the 248 positive commandments the “248 limbs of the King,” as though each mitzvah were an organ of G‑d.
וצריך להבין מהו ענין ולשון אברים הלא אין לו דמות הגוף3 כו׳ וכתיב כי לא מחשבותי45 וכו׳ ולא דרכיכם וכו׳. כן גבהו מחשבותי וכו׳.
And one needs to understand what is meant by the term “limbs”: surely He has no bodily form, etc.! And it is written, “For My thoughts are not [your thoughts], etc., nor are your ways [My ways], etc.,” [and] “so are My thoughts higher, etc.”
G‑d has no body, as the Yigdal hymn and the Rambam teach, and Isaiah says His thoughts and ways are as far above ours as the heavens are above the earth. So the word “limbs” cannot be meant literally, and needs explaining.
אבל הענין הוא דכתיב תתן אמת ליעקב6 חסד לאברהם אשר נשבעת לאבותינו מימי קדם.
But the explanation is that it is written, “You will give truth to Yaakov, kindness to Avraham, as You swore to our fathers from the days of old.”
The answer will come through Micah’s closing verse: truth given to Yaakov, kindness to Avraham, and an oath sworn to the fathers from days of old. Each phrase will be unpacked in turn.
ולהבין מהו האמת שהנביא משבח שניתן ליעקב מדת אמת7 (ועמ״ש מזה באגה״ק [באגרת הקודש] בד״ה וזורע צדקה שכר אמת8).
And [we need] to understand what this truth is that the prophet praises, [saying] that the attribute of truth was given to Yaakov. (See also what is written on this in Iggeres HaKodesh, in the letter beginning “And one who sows charity, a reward of truth.”)
The question is what “truth” means here, and why the prophet praises G‑d for giving it to Yaakov, who is himself the attribute of truth; the Kehot note shows that the Tzemach Tzedek understood the question this way. In Iggeres HaKodesh, letter 6, the Alter Rebbe raises the same question and begins his answer from the fact that before G‑d even the highest worlds are as nothing, and that He is present equally above and below.
הנה כתיב כי אל דעות ה׳ פי׳ שכולל ב׳ דיעות
Now, it is written, “For Havayah is a G‑d of knowledges (de’os),” meaning that He includes two [kinds of] knowledge.
Hannah’s prayer calls Havayah “a G‑d of de’os,” knowledge in the plural. The Alter Rebbe reads this as two ways of knowing reality: one looking from below upward, the other from above downward.
כי ממטה למעלה לפי מה שנראה לעיני בשר העולם הגשמי נראה ליש ודבר והרוחניות שלמעלה הוא בחי׳ אין ומה שלמעלה מעלה הוא בחי׳ אין יותר לפי שאינו מושג יותר.910
For from below to above, according to what is seen by eyes of flesh, the physical world appears as something existing and real (yesh), while the spiritual realm above is the level of ayin (nothing), and what is higher still is even more the level of ayin, because it is even less graspable.
From our viewpoint the physical world is solid “something” (yesh), while spiritual realms seem like “nothing” (ayin) because we cannot grasp them. The higher a level, the less graspable, so the more it seems to be nothing.
The paragraph raises the question of study versus action and of the mitzvos as the King’s “limbs,” and begins the answer with Micah’s verse about truth for Yaakov, starting from the first of the two “knowledges”: the view from below.
The two de’os anticipate the higher and lower unities (yichuda ila’ah and yichuda tata’ah) named explicitly in paragraph 5, the subject of Tanya’s second part, Sha’ar HaYichud VehaEmunah.
TermsChosamo shel HaKadosh Baruch Hu emes248 limbs of the KingZeriahTzedakah+2
- Chosamo shel HaKadosh Baruch Hu emes חותמו של הקב״ה אמת
- 248 limbs of the King רמ״ח אברים דמלכא
- Zeriah זריעה
- Tzedakah צדקה
- Yesh and ayin יש ואין
- Chesed חסד
Marei mekomos
- 1גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה · Kiddushin 40b:8–9
- 2רמ״ח פקודין אינון רמ״ח אברין דמלכא · Tikkunei Zohar, Tikkun 30 · 74a:8
- 3אין לו דמות הגוף · פיוט ”יגדל”. וראה רמב״ם הל׳ יסוה״ת פ״א.
- 4כי לא מחשבותי גו׳ כן גבהו מחשבותי גו׳ · Isaiah 55:8–9
- 5
- 6תתן אמת ליעקב · Micah 7:20
- 7מהו האמת שהנביא משבח שניתן ליעקב מדת אמת · באוה״ת נ״ך כרך א ע׳ תקצה מבאר ”דהקושיא שהרי יעקב עצמו הוא אמת וא״כ מהו תתן אמת ליעקב” ע״ש.
- 8
- 9כי א-ל דעות ה׳ · I Samuel 2:3
- 10
As it is written, “And wisdom (Chochmah) is found from ayin (nothing).” All this is relative to us, who dwell below.
Job’s verse, plainly “wisdom, from where (me’ayin) shall it be found?”, is read as “wisdom is found from ayin”: even Chochmah, the highest intellect, is “nothing” to us because it is beyond our grasp. But all of this, the Alter Rebbe adds, is only our perspective as creatures below.
אבל לגבי קוב״ה [קודשא בריך הוא] דכולא קמיה כלא חשיב2 הוא היפך שמלמעלה למטה הוא בחי׳ אין וכל מה שמשתלשל ויורד מטה מטה הוא יותר בחי׳ אין וכלא חשיב ממש כו׳.
But in relation to the Holy One, blessed be He, before whom everything is considered as nothing, it is the reverse: from above to below, [what is below] is the level of ayin, and whatever evolves and descends lower and lower is all the more the level of ayin, and truly considered as nothing, etc.
From G‑d’s side the direction reverses, as the Zohar teaches that “before Him everything is considered as nothing.” The higher, closer to Him, is the more real; the further the chain of descent goes down, the more it is “nothing,” and the physical world, lowest of all, is the most null before Him.
The paragraph completes the two “knowledges”: from below, the spiritual seems like nothing; from above, it is the lower worlds that are nothing before G‑d.
This is the contrast between the lower unity, in which creation is a yesh that must nullify itself, and the higher unity, in which nothing besides G‑d exists at all.
Marei mekomos
- 1והחכמה מאין תמצא · Job 28:12
- 2דכולא קמי׳ כלא חשיב · Zohar I, 11b
And this is why [the Sages] instituted that at the beginning of Pesukei deZimrah [the Verses of Praise] we say, “Give thanks (hodu) to Havayah, etc.,” and likewise at the end of the Shemoneh Esreh we say, “We give thanks (modim) to You”;
The prayers are built on this: the morning’s Pesukei deZimrah (the Verses of Praise before the main prayers) opens with “Hodu” (give thanks), and the Amidah closes with “Modim” (we give thanks). Both use the word hodaah.
כי לשון הודא׳ [הודאה] הוא כמו למשל האדם המודה לחבירו שמתחלה הי׳ [היה] נחלק עליו והיה לו סברא אחרת ואח״כ מודה שהאמת עם חבירו.
for the term hodaah (thanks; also, acknowledgment) is, by way of analogy, like a person who concedes (modeh) to his fellow: at first he disagreed with him and held another view, and afterwards he concedes that the truth is with his fellow.
Hodaah means not only thanks but conceding: like a person who held another view and then admits that his fellow was right. In prayer, a person concedes that G‑d’s view of reality is the true one, even against how things look to him.
The paragraph shows that the prayers Hodu and Modim express “conceding”: giving up our view of reality in favour of the truth as G‑d sees it.
Marei mekomos
- 1הודו לה׳ · I Chronicles 16:8
5וכך ע״י שיתבונן האדם שהאמת הוא דכולא קמיה כלא חשיב ומה שנראה העולם ליש ודבר הוא בערכנו מלובשים בגוף גשמי ורואים בעיני בשר גשמיים אבל האמת הוא להפך ממה שנראה לעיני בשר אזי יודה על האמת.
So too, when a person contemplates that the truth is that “before Him everything is considered as nothing,” and that the world’s appearing as something existing and real is relative to us, who are clothed in a physical body and see with physical eyes of flesh, but the truth is the opposite of what appears to eyes of flesh, then he will concede (yodeh) to the truth.
When a person contemplates that the world seems solid only because we see with physical eyes, while in truth all is nothing before G‑d, he “concedes” to the truth. This is the inner meaning of hodaah.
וז״ש [וזהו שכתוב] בהלל ואמת ה׳ לעולם עולם הוא מלשון העלם וצמצום שיהיה נראה לעיני בשר מזרח ומערב כו׳
The Hallel verse says “the truth of Havayah is le’olam,” plainly “forever.” The Alter Rebbe reads olam, “world,” as related to he’elem, concealment: the world is the place where G‑d is hidden and things appear as separate places and directions, and the verse speaks of His truth reaching into it.
ובכל זמן שתקנו לומר הלל1 הוא זמן התגלות אמת ה׳ שמלמעלה פג, בלמטה שהוא להיות מה שלמטה נקרא אין ולמעלה נקרא בחי׳ יש. וכמ״ש להנחיל אוהבי יש.2
and at every time at which [the Sages] instituted the saying of Hallel, it is a time of the revelation of “the truth of Havayah” [as it is] from above to below, which is that what is below is called ayin and what is above is called the level of yesh (something). As it is written, “To cause those who love Me to inherit yesh.”
So at the times when Hallel is said, the truth of Havayah, the view from above, is revealed even within the concealing world: what is below is seen as ayin and what is above as the true yesh. Proverbs’ “to cause those who love Me to inherit yesh” calls the Divine the true “something.”
(כי הרי ב׳ בחי׳ דעות הנ״ל הן בחי׳ יחודא עילאה שהוא שם הוי׳ ויחודא תתאה שמבחי׳ שם אלקים ואדנות המצמצם ומפריד להוות בחי׳ יש וכמ״ש סד״ה כי תשמע בקול3 והנה ההלל הוא להמשיך ולהאיר במל׳ שהוא שם אדנות. כמ״ש הרמ״ז [הרב משה זכות] פ׳ אמור) (תחלת דצ״ו)4
(For the two levels of knowledge mentioned above are the level of the higher unity (yichuda ila’ah), which is the Name Havayah, and the lower unity (yichuda tata’ah), which comes from the level of the Names Elokim and Adnus (Ado-nai), which contract and separate so as to bring into being the level of yesh; as is written at the end of the discourse beginning “If you will listen to the voice.” Now, Hallel is to draw down and shine [light] into Malchus, which is the Name Adnus, as the Ramaz writes on Parshas Emor) (beginning of folio 96).
The two “knowledges” are the higher unity, expressed by the Name Havayah, and the lower unity, expressed by the Names Elokim and Ado-nai, which conceal G‑d so that creatures feel like separate beings; in Likkutei Torah, Re’eh (the discourse “If you will listen”), the Alter Rebbe explains that the Name Elokim contracts and separates so that there is a yesh whose purpose is to be nullified. Hallel draws light into Malchus, the Name Ado-nai: the Ramaz (R. Moshe Zacuto, a seventeenth-century Kabbalist who annotated the Zohar) notes that Ado-nai and Hallel have the same numerical value, 65.
והארה זו היינו המשכה וגילוי שם הוי׳ בחי׳ יחודא עילאה וכמ״ש מזה סד״ה בכ״ה בכסלו.5
And this illumination is the drawing down and revelation of the Name Havayah, the level of the higher unity; as is written on this at the end of the discourse beginning “On the twenty-fifth of Kislev.”
This light brought into Malchus is the Name Havayah revealed, the higher unity, in which the world is nothing before G‑d. The Torah Ohr discourse for Chanukah (25 Kislev) treats this at greater length.
גם הוא כענין ועתה יגדל נא כח6 אדני. ועיין בפע״ח [בפרי עץ חיים] שער ר״ח [ראש חודש] פ״ב [פרק ב׳] ולכן עי״ז נמשך גילוי ואמת ה׳ לעולם
It is also like the matter of “And now, let the power of Ado-nai be great.” And see Pri Etz Chaim, Sha’ar Rosh Chodesh, chapter 2. And therefore, through this there is drawn down the revelation of “And the truth of Havayah is le’olam.”
Moshe’s plea “let the power of Ado-nai be great” is read the same way: to make Malchus, the Name Ado-nai, great with added light; the text also points to the Arizal’s Pri Etz Chaim (Sha’ar Rosh Chodesh, chapter 2). Through this the truth of Havayah becomes revealed “le’olam,” in the world itself.
ולכן אומרים אח״כ הודו לה׳ בחי׳ הודאה אליו ית׳ שלא כאשר נראה לעיני בשר שלנו וזהו תתן אמת ליעקב7 כי יעקב הוא בחי׳8 יוד עקב
And therefore we say afterwards, “Give thanks to Havayah”: the level of acknowledgment to Him, may He be blessed, [that the truth is] not as it appears to our eyes of flesh. And this is “You will give truth to Yaakov,” for Yaakov is the level of yud akev (a yud [and] a heel):
That is why “Give thanks to Havayah” comes next in Hallel (Psalm 118, which opens with these words, follows Psalm 117): we acknowledge that reality is not as our eyes see it. The name Yaakov is read as yud and akev (heel), the yud of G‑d’s Name reaching down to the heel; in Torah Ohr, Shemos, the Alter Rebbe uses the same reading for the mitzvos, which descend from G‑d’s will into physical things.
דהיינו יו״ד הוא בחי׳ צמצום שירד ונתפשט בעקב וסוף המדרגות שנתגשמו ואעפ״כ [ואף על פי כן] הקב״ה נותן אמת שיתגלה גם שם אמת ה׳ וכו׳ כנ״ל (ועמ״ש מענין תתן אמת ליעקב בביאור ע״פ אלה מסעי9 גבי ויכתוב משה)
that is, the yud is the level of tzimtzum, which descended and spread into the heel (akev) and end of the levels, which have become physical; and nevertheless the Holy One, blessed be He, gives truth, that there too “the truth of Havayah” be revealed, etc., as mentioned above. (See also what is written on the matter of “You will give truth to Yaakov” in the explanation on the verse “These are the journeys,” regarding “And Moshe wrote.”)
The yud, the smallest letter, stands for tzimtzum; it descends to the “heel,” the lowest levels that have become physical. “You will give truth to Yaakov” means that G‑d’s truth is revealed even there; in Likkutei Torah, Masei, to which the text refers, the Alter Rebbe explains this truth as a flow of good that never stops and never changes.
ומזה נמשך להיות חסד לאברהם כו׳ פי׳ חסד הוא המשכת המצות שכללותן הוא הצדקה וחסד
And from this is drawn down [the level of] “kindness to Avraham,” etc. Meaning: kindness is the drawing down of the mitzvos, which as a whole are charity and kindness;
From this “truth” comes the next phrase of Micah’s verse, “kindness to Avraham.” Kindness here means the drawing down of the mitzvos, all of which are summed up in charity and kindness.
ונמשך ונתלבש בחי׳ אמת ה׳ במעשה המצות שיהיה להם כח ועוז להיות באתערותא דלתתא תלוי אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא] שע״י מעשה הצדקה וחסד תחתון יתעורר כח חסד עליון וכן עד״ז בכל המצות
and the level of “the truth of Havayah” is drawn down and clothed in the performance of the mitzvos, so that they have the strength and power for the arousal from above to depend on the arousal from below: that through the deed of charity and kindness below, the power of the supernal kindness is aroused; and so too, in the same way, with all the mitzvos.
Because the truth of Havayah is clothed in the mitzvos, a human act of kindness below has the power to arouse the supernal kindness above: the arousal from below brings the arousal from above, and so with every mitzvah.
(כי אמת היינו תורה1011 וזהו כי באור פניך12 נתת לנו תורת חיים אשר בחי׳ הארת פנים זהו אמת כמ״ש באד״ר [באדרא רבא])13 (דל״ג ב׳)
(For truth is Torah, and this is “For by the light of Your countenance You gave us a Torah of life,” for the level of the shining of the countenance is truth, as is written in the Idra Rabba) (folio 33b).
Truth is identified with Torah, as the Jerusalem Talmud teaches. The prayer Sim Shalom speaks of the Torah given “by the light of Your countenance,” and the Idra Rabba (the Zohar’s account of the “Great Assembly” of R. Shimon bar Yochai) links the shining countenance with truth; the print gives folio 33b, and the Kehot note locates the passage at Zohar 3:133b.
והתורה היא הנותן כח להיו׳ [להיות] באתעדל״ת [באתערותא דלתתא] שע״י המצות אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא] כמ״ש לקמן א״כ מבחי׳ תתן אמת ליעקב נמשך בחי׳ וחסד לאברהם וזהו ענין חסד של אמת חסד דקשוט ע״ש באד״ר [באדרא רבא].
And the Torah is what gives the power for there to be, through the arousal from below by means of the mitzvos, an arousal from above, as will be written below. Thus, from the level of “You will give truth to Yaakov” is drawn down the level of “and kindness to Avraham”; and this is the meaning of “kindness of truth,” chesed dikshot (true kindness); see there in the Idra Rabba.
So it is Torah, “truth,” that gives the mitzvos, “kindness,” their power to draw down a response from above; this will be developed later in the maamar. This is “kindness of truth”: the Idra Rabba calls the kindness of the Ancient One (Atik) chesed dikshot, “true kindness,” kindness for the life of the soul rather than of the body.
¶12 How Torah empowers the mitzvos is explained in paragraph 12.
וזהו כל ארחות1415 ה׳ חסד ואמת וע׳ שם (דקכ״ט א׳) ועמ״ש בד״ה ואתחנן גבי אתה החלות ובענין ברכת המצות עיין שם:1617
And this is “All the paths of Havayah are kindness and truth”; see there (folio 129a). See also what is written in the discourse beginning “And I pleaded,” regarding “You have begun,” and on the subject of the blessing over the mitzvos; see there.
The psalm says “all the paths of Havayah are kindness and truth,” putting the two together; the Idra Rabba (Zohar 3:129a), to which the text refers, quotes this verse of the 613 paths of the Torah that branch out from one path of light. The text also refers to the discourse “And I pleaded” (Va’eschanan) on the blessing said over the mitzvos.
The paragraph explains “You will give truth to Yaakov” as G‑d’s truth, the view from above, revealed even in the lowest world, and shows how this truth, which is Torah, flows into the mitzvos (“kindness to Avraham”) and gives them power to arouse G‑d’s kindness from above.
The Ramaz’s link of Hallel to Malchus rests on gematria: Ado-nai and הלל both equal 65. In the terms of Tanya, the higher unity (Havayah) shining into the lower unity (Elokim/Ado-nai) is what allows a finite deed to become a vessel for Infinite light.
TermsChosamo shel HaKadosh Baruch Hu emesHoda’ahOz vesushiyahHearas panim+17
- Chosamo shel HaKadosh Baruch Hu emes חותמו של הקב״ה אמת
- Hoda’ah הודאה
- Oz vesushiyah עוז ותושיה
- Hearas panim הארת פנים
- Yichuda tata’ah יחודא תתאה
- Chesed olam חסד עולם
- Yichuda ila’ah יחודא עילאה
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Tzedakah צדקה
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Hisbonenus התבוננות
- Yichud יחוד
- Tzimtzum צמצום
- Berachah ברכה
- Yesh and ayin יש ואין
- Elokim אלקים
- Chesed חסד
Marei mekomos
- 1ובכל זמן שתקנו לומר הלל · ראה דרך מצותיך קמח, א.
- 2להנחיל אוהבי יש · Proverbs 8:21
- 3סד״ה כי תשמע בקול · לעיל פ׳ ראה כג, ד.
- 4כמ״ש הרמ״ז פ׳ אמור (תחלת דצ״ו) · ”שכן ההלל סודו להאיר במ׳ סוד אדנ״י גימט׳ הלל וז״ש אתעטרת סיהרא שאז היא שלימה ומולכת באדנות שלה בכח התלת דרגין שעליה יה״ו”.
- 5סד״ה בכ״ה בכסלו · בתו״א פ׳ מקץ.
- 6ועתה יגדל נא כח אד׳ · Numbers 14:17
- 7
- 8יעקב הוא בחי׳ י׳ עקב · ראה קה״י ערך ישראל.
- 9בביאור ע״פ אלה מסעי · לעיל פ׳ מסעי צג, ג.
- 10כי אמת היינו תורה · Eikhah Rabbah 2:13
- 11כי אמת היינו תורה · Jerusalem Talmud Rosh Hashanah 3:8:2
- 12כי באור פניך · ברכת שים שלום.
- 13כמ״ש באד״ר · Zohar III, 133b
- 14כל ארחות ה׳ חסד ואמת · Psalms 25:10
- 15כל ארחות ה׳ חסד ואמת · Zohar, Idra Rabba 6:25–7:37
- 16ואמת ה׳ לעולם · תהלים (קיז, ב).
- 17ואמת ה׳ לעולם · Psalms 117:2
The oath to the fathers ¶6–8
6ב אך להבין מאין הכח הזה להיות אתערותא דלעילא תלוי באתעדל״ת [באתערותא דלתתא].
2. But [we need] to understand: from where does this power come, for the arousal from above to depend on the arousal from below?
A new question: from where does a human deed get the power to make G‑d’s response from above depend on it?
ואיך יש יחוס ושייכות לנברא שהוא מחודש מאין ליש לעורר חסד עליון של הבורא ית׳ שמו הלא אין ערוך אליו ולית מחשבה תפיסא ביה1 כלל.2
And how does a created being, which is brought into being anew from nothing to something, have any relation or connection [such as] to arouse the supernal kindness of the Creator, blessed be His Name? Surely there is no comparison to Him, and no thought can grasp Him at all!
A creature is brought into being from nothing, and G‑d is beyond all comparison; the Tikkunei Zohar says no thought can grasp Him. What connection could such a creature have to its Creator, that its deed should “arouse” His kindness?
הנה זה ביאר הכתוב אח״כ דכתיב אשר נשבעת לאבותינו3 פי׳ לאבותינו הוא אהב׳ [אהבה] הטבעית המסותרת בלב כל אחד ואחד מישראל בכח וגם בפועל ממש במס״נ [במסירות נפש] על קדה״ש [קידוש השם]
Now, the verse explains this afterwards, as it is written, “As You swore to our fathers.” Meaning: “our fathers” is the natural love hidden in the heart of each and every Jew, in potential, and also truly in actuality, in self-sacrifice (mesirus nefesh) for the sanctification of G‑d’s Name.
The answer is in the next words of the verse, “as You swore to our fathers.” The “fathers” within each Jew is the natural love for G‑d in every Jewish heart: hidden as a potential, yet truly active when a Jew gives his life for the sanctification of G‑d’s Name.
שאהבה זו נקרא בשם אב שממנה התולדה לעשות מצות ומעשים טובים
This love is called by the name “father,” for from it comes the offspring: the doing of mitzvos and good deeds;
This love is called a “father” because it gives birth to “offspring”: mitzvos and good deeds.
for all the mitzvos are in order to cleave to Him, may He be blessed. And this love is also an inheritance to us from our fathers.
The mitzvos are the way to cleave to G‑d, which is what this love desires. It is also literally an inheritance from the Patriarchs, as Tanya chapter 18 explains.
The paragraph asks how a creature can arouse the Creator and begins the answer: “our fathers” is the hidden natural love for G‑d in every Jew, inherited from the Patriarchs, which gives birth to the mitzvos.
Tanya chapter 18 explains this inherited love as the soul’s Chochmah, in which the Infinite Light is clothed, which is why it can come out as self-sacrifice even in a simple person.
TermsChesed olamDeveikusMesirus nefeshEin aroch+6
- Chesed olam חסד עולם
- Deveikus דביקות
- Mesirus nefesh מסירות נפש
- Ein aroch אין ערוך
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Yesh me’ayin יש מאין
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Yesh and ayin יש ואין
- Chesed חסד
Also Torah and mitzvos
Marei mekomos
- 1לית מחשבה תפיסא בי׳ · ראה ת״ז בהקדמה (ד״ה פתח אליהו).
- 2ולית מחשבה תפיסא ביה כלל · Tikkunei Zohar 17a:10–12
- 3אשר נשבעת לאבותינו · Micah 7:20
- 4וגם אהבה זו היא ירושה לנו מאבותינו · ראה תניא פרק יח.
- 5
7ובאהבה זו נמשך לנו הכח והעוז להיות תלוי1 אתערותא דלעילא באתעדל״ת [באתערותא דלתתא] ועי״ז ניתן הכח להמשיך ע״י מעשה המצות
And through this love there is drawn down to us the strength and power for the arousal from above to depend on the arousal from below; and through this the power is given to draw down [light] through the performance of the mitzvos:
The hidden natural love is what gives a Jew’s deeds the power to call forth a response from above; through it, physical mitzvos can draw down Divine light. A Kehot note cites the Rebbe (Likkutei Sichos, vol. 19) quoting a discourse: the whole rule that an arousal from below brings one from above holds only because “so it arose in His will.” Later the paragraph says that even one “cut off” keeps the bond of the Patriarchs, for “zechus avos lo tamah,” the merit of the fathers has not ended. This is pointed, since in the Gemara (Shabbos 55a) Shmuel holds that it did end, and the Sages dispute from when. The proof is the Gemara’s “although he does not see, his mazal sees” (Megillah 3a): Daniel’s companions saw nothing of his vision yet were seized with terror, because their mazal, a higher part of the soul, saw it. The maamar takes this mazal as the soul’s root above, which stays bound to G‑d even when the person feels nothing.
שע״י מצות מעשיות כמו ציצית של צמר תחתון מעורר ציצית עליונים וכן ע״י תפילין תחתונים מעורר תפילין עליונים.
that through practical mitzvos, such as tzitzis of wool below, one arouses the supernal tzitzis, and likewise through tefillin below one arouses the supernal tefillin.
Each physical mitzvah has a counterpart on high: wool tzitzis here stir the “supernal tzitzis,” and tefillin worn below stir the “supernal tefillin,” spiritual levels that these mitzvos correspond to.
משא״כ אחד מעו״ג [מעובדי גלולים] אע״פ [אף על פי] שיתלבש בציצית ויניח תפילין לא ימשיך ולא יעורר כלום (ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה הבאים ישרש)2
This is not so with an idolater: even if he wraps himself in tzitzis and puts on tefillin, he will draw down nothing and arouse nothing. (See also what is written on this in the discourse beginning “Habaim yashresh” [“In days to come, he will take root”].)
The same physical act done by an idolater does not have this effect; the next words give the reason: the power of the deed comes from the inherited love bound up with the commandment. In Torah Ohr, Shemos (“Habaim yashresh”), the Alter Rebbe compares the mitzvos to seeds: tefillin and tzitzis bring about a revelation of G‑dliness only when a Jew puts them on, as a seed sprouts only in fertile ground.
לפי שכל אחד ואחד מישראל יש לו בנפשו אהבה הטבעית הזאת ואפילו חייבי כריתות דכתיב בהם ונכרתה הנפש ההיא מלפני אני3 ה׳ כו׳
For each and every Jew has this natural love in his soul, even those liable to kares (excision), of whom it is written, “That soul shall be cut off from before Me; I am Havayah,” etc.:
This love is present in every Jewish soul, even in one who has incurred kares, the Torah’s penalty of being “cut off” from before G‑d.
שנכרתה הנפש ההיא משרשה4 ואין אהבה טבעית זו מתגלה בנפשו מ״מ בשרשה למעלה נשאר בה בחי׳ אהבה טבעית אלא שאינה שורה ומתגלה בנפשם למטה כי הכרת תכרת וגו׳.5 רק הוא בהעלם אצלו
[meaning] that that soul has been cut off from its root, and this natural love is not revealed in his soul; nevertheless, in its root above the level of natural love remains in it, only it does not rest and become revealed in their souls below, for “it shall surely be cut off,” etc.; rather, it is hidden within him.
Being “cut off” means that the soul below is severed from its root, so the love no longer shows in the person. Yet in the root above, the love remains; it simply does not rest in the soul here, but is hidden in him.
ויש לו בחי׳ לאבותינו וזכות אבות לא תמה6789 כי אע״ג [אף על גב] דאיהו לא חזי10 מזליה חזי פי׳ מזליה הוא שרש נשמתו למעלה בחינת אין שהוא מזל לישראל11 כו׳. כמ״ש במ״א ע״פ האזינו השמים.
And he has the level of “our fathers,” and “the merit of the fathers has not ended”; for “even though he does not see, his mazal sees.” Meaning: his mazal is the root of his soul above, the level of ayin, which is the mazal of Israel (ayin mazal l’Yisrael; plainly, “Israel has no mazal”), etc., as is written elsewhere on the verse “Listen, O heavens.”
So even such a person still has “our fathers” within him, and the Patriarchs’ merit has not run out: the Talmud records a dispute about this, and the Midrash concludes that it has not, as a Kehot note shows. The Talmud’s phrase “his mazal sees” is read as the soul’s root above, which is “ayin,” beyond grasp; the Talmud’s “ein mazal l’Yisrael,” plainly “Israel has no mazal,” is read as “ayin is Israel’s mazal.”
The paragraph explains that the inherited love is what empowers the mitzvos to arouse their counterparts above, and that this love is never lost, even in one who has been “cut off,” because it remains in the soul’s root.
Reading “ein mazal l’Yisrael” as “ayin is the mazal of Israel” identifies the soul’s root with the level of ayin, the Divine “nothing” above grasp that appeared in paragraphs 2 and 3. In the Gemara (Shabbos 156a), Rabbi Yochanan and Rav teach “ein mazal l’Yisrael,” that Israel is not ruled by the stars, as G‑d told Avraham to step out of his astrology. The maamar rereads the same words so that Israel’s mazal is ayin itself.
TermsOz vesushiyahAhavah mesuteresMazalAvos+4
- Oz vesushiyah עוז ותושיה
- Ahavah mesuteres אהבה מסותרת
- Mazal מזל
- Avos אבות
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
Marei mekomos
- 1הכח והעוז להיות תלוי אתעדל״ע באתעדל״ת · בלקו״ש חי״ט ע׳ 159 הערה 16 מציין לד״ה אדון עולם תש״ג ע׳ 14 ”אשר כללות הענין מה שבאתעדל״ת אתעדל״ע הוא רק לפי שכן עלה ברצונו ית׳” ע״ש בלקו״ש בהערה 14 בארוכה.
- 2בד״ה הבאים ישרש · תו״א נג, ג ואילך. וראה במ״מ לשם.
- 3ונכרתה הנפש ההיא מלפני אני ה׳ · Leviticus 22:3
- 4שנכרתה הנפש ההיא משרשה · מובא באוה״ת נ״ך כרך ב ע׳ א׳מ.
- 5הכרת תכרת גו׳ · Numbers 15:31
- 6וזכות אבות לא תמה · Zohar I, 168a
- 7וזכות אבות לא תמה · Shabbat 55a:11–12
- 8וזכות אבות לא תמה · Vayikra Rabbah 36:6
- 9וזכות אבות לא תמה · Jerusalem Talmud Sanhedrin 10:1:14
- 10אע״ג דאיהו לא חזי · Megillah 3a:14
- 11אין . . מזל לישראל · Shabbat 156a:12–13
8וע״ז אמר הפסוק כי אבי ואמי עזבוני1 וה׳ יאספני ר״ל [רוצה לומר] אפי׳ [אפילו] מי שאבד ממנו בחי׳ אב ואם שבו
And of this the verse says, “For my father and my mother have forsaken me, but Havayah will gather me in.” That is to say: even one from whom the level of father and mother within him has been lost,
The psalm “my father and my mother have forsaken me, but Havayah will gather me in” is read about such a person: “father and mother” are the inner love for G‑d, which he has lost.
דהיינו שנתחייב כרת ונאבד בחי׳ אהבה טבעית שבו מלהיות שורה ומתגלה בנפשו מ״מ וה׳ יאספני הוא ע״י בחי׳ שרשו למעלה שיפול גם עליו בחי׳ לאבותינו
that is, who has become liable to kares, and the level of natural love within him has been lost from resting and being revealed in his soul, nevertheless, “Havayah will gather me in”: this is through the level of his root above, that the level of “our fathers” will fall upon him too.
Even if his sins have hidden that love completely, Havayah “gathers him in” through the soul’s root above, where the love of “our fathers” still rests on him.
אך כיצד נמשך כח ועוז לאהבה טבעית זו לעורר את האהבה העליונה מפרש הכתוב אשר נשבעת לאבותינו נשבעת לשון נפעל
But how are strength and power drawn to this natural love, to arouse the supernal love? The verse explains: “As You swore (nishbata) to our fathers.” Nishbata is in the passive (nif’al) form,
The next question: how does a natural human love gain the power to arouse G‑d’s love? The answer lies in the word nishbata, “You swore,” which in Hebrew is a passive (nif’al) form.
וכן כל לשון שבועה מדבר בלשון נפעל כלומר שהתקשר א״ע [את עצמו] בשבועה כמ״ש או השבע פג, גשבועה2 כו׳
and likewise every term of oath is expressed in the passive form, meaning that one has bound oneself by an oath, as it is written, “Or swears an oath,” etc.
Swearing is always in the passive form in Hebrew, because an oath is binding oneself: the one who swears becomes bound. The Torah’s phrase “or swears an oath to bind a bond upon himself” shows this.
והענין כי צריך להבין ענין שבועה זו3 מה טבעה ולמה היה צריך הקב״ה לישבע ואיך שייך אצלו ית׳ לשון שבועה
The explanation: one needs to understand this oath, what its nature is, why the Holy One, blessed be He, needed to swear, and how the term “oath” applies to Him, may He be blessed.
But why would G‑d need to swear, and how can binding by an oath apply to Him at all?
אלא הענין הוא עד״מ כאדם הנשבע לחבירו שהוא כדי שלא ישנה אפילו אם יגרום איזה דבר שיצטרך לשנות שאם היה גלוי וידוע לפניו שאין שום ענין הגורם השינוי לא היה צריך לשבועתו.
Rather, the explanation is, by way of analogy, like a person who swears to his fellow: this is so that he will not change even if something should come about that would require him to change; for if it were revealed and known before him that nothing would cause a change, he would not need his oath.
A person swears so that he will keep his word even if something later would make him want to change. If he knew nothing would ever arise to change his mind, he would not need an oath.
כך הוא עד״מ בשבועתו של הקב״ה לאברהם בברית בין הבתרים לזרעך נתתי את הארץ4 כו׳
So it is, by way of analogy, with the oath of the Holy One, blessed be He, to Avraham at the Covenant between the Parts, “To your seed I have given the land,” etc.:
G‑d’s oath to Avraham at the Covenant between the Parts, promising the land to his descendants, is understood the same way.
דהיינו אפי׳ [אפילו] אם יגרום החטא שלא יעכב מה שע״פ הדעת והחכמה לא יושג שיותן להם את הארץ אעפ״כ [אף על פי כן] מחמת השבועה הוא עושה נגד חכמתו ורצונו5 כביכול (ועמ״ש מזה ע״פ אתם נצבים כו׳ לעברך בברית6 כו׳)
that is, even if sin should cause [it], it will not hold [it] back; though according to reason and wisdom it would not be attained that the land be given to them, nevertheless, because of the oath, He acts against His wisdom and will, as it were. (See also what is written on this on the verse “You are standing … to pass into the covenant,” etc.)
Even if the people sin, so that by reason they would not deserve the land, the oath binds G‑d, as it were, to give it anyway, against His own wisdom and even His will. A Kehot note quotes the Rebbe’s explanation that “and will” means: even if the revealed will itself changed, He would act against it.
וזהו עצמו ענין השבועה דהיינו מה שהבטיח נגד חכמתו ורצונו
And this itself is the essence of the oath: that He promised against His wisdom and will;
This, the Alter Rebbe says, is the very meaning of the oath: a promise made against G‑d’s own wisdom and will.
והיינו שלא יהיה כסדר השתלשלות המדרגות וירידה ממדרגה למדרגה ע״פ בחי׳ רצון וחכמה אלא שיהיה אור א״ס ב״ה בעצמו ובכבודו מתפשט ומאיר בגילוי רב למעלה מן הרצון והחכמה
that is, that it not be according to the order of the chain of descending levels (hishtalshelus), the descent from level to level according to the level of will and wisdom, but rather that the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, in His very Self and glory, spread forth and shine in great revelation, above will and wisdom.
That is, it does not follow the orderly chain of descent, in which G‑d relates to the world level by level through will and wisdom. Instead, the Infinite Light itself, “in His very Self and glory,” shines openly beyond will and wisdom.
והארה והמשכה זו נמשכה מימי קדם קדמונו של עולם דהיינו מבחי׳ סובב כל עלמין למעלה מבחי׳ ממכ״ע [ממלא כל עלמין] שהוא בחי׳ השתלשלות וירידת המדרגות והוא בחי׳ כשעלה ברצונו וכו׳ שתוק כך עלה במחשבה7 כו׳ שהוא בחי׳ מחשבה הקדומה כו׳.
And this illumination and drawing down was drawn from “the days of old,” [from] the Primordial One of the world: that is, from the level of the light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin), above the level of the light that fills all worlds (memalei kol almin), which is the level of hishtalshelus and the descent of the levels. And this is the level of “When it arose in His will,” etc., “Be silent! So it arose in thought,” etc., which is the level of the primordial thought, etc.
This comes from “the days of old,” the Primordial One who precedes the world: sovev kol almin, the light beyond the ordered worlds, rather than memalei kol almin, the light that enters them in measured steps. It is the “primordial thought,” the level of “so it arose in thought,” which no reason precedes.
ומאחר שהארה והמשכה זו נמשכה לאבותינו מאור א״ס ב״ה בעצמו ובכבודו לכן יש להם כח ועוז להיות באתעדל״ת [באתערותא דלתתא] תלוי אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא]
And since this illumination and drawing down was drawn to our fathers from the Infinite Light, blessed be He, in His very Self and glory, therefore they have strength and power for the arousal from above to depend on the arousal from below.
Because the Patriarchs received this light from G‑d’s very Self, their descendants’ deeds below can draw a response from above. The creature-Creator gap asked about in paragraph 6 is bridged by a bond above all reason.
(וע׳ בזח״ג [בזהר חלק ג]) (דקל״ד ע״ב) בענין אשר נשבעת8 כו׳ (ודק״ל ע״א) בענין בי נשבעתי9 ובפ׳ אחרי10 (דס״ו ב׳) ובהרמ״ז [ובהרב משה זכות] ר״פ שמיני.
(See Zohar, vol. 3) (folio 134b), on the subject of “As You swore,” etc., (and folio 130a) on the subject of “By Myself I have sworn,” and in Parshas Acharei (folio 66b), and in the Ramaz at the beginning of Parshas Shemini.
The text points to passages in the Zohar on “as You swore” and “By Myself I have sworn,” and to the Ramaz’s commentary at the start of Parshas Shemini. In the Idra Rabba (Zohar 3:134b), the fathers are said to have trusted in the “breath” of the Ancient One’s mouth, which spreads in every direction, and this is “as You swore to our fathers.”
וברבות (פ׳ אמור פכ״ט) ד״א [דבר אחר] בחודש השביעי רבי ברכיה היה קרי ליה ירחא דשבועתיה11 שבו נשבע הקב״ה לאברהם אבינו הה״ד [הדא הוא דכתיב] ויאמר בי נשבעתי נאום12 ה׳ מה היה צריך לשבועה כו׳ יעו״ש [יעויין שם] התירוץ והוא כדרך שנתבאר.
And in the Midrash Rabbah (Parshas Emor, section 29): “Another explanation: ‘In the seventh month.’ Rabbi Berachiah would call it ‘the month of His oath,’ for in it the Holy One, blessed be He, swore to Avraham our father, as it is written, ‘And He said: By Myself I have sworn, says Havayah.’ Why did He need an oath?” etc. See there for the answer; it is along the lines that have been explained.
The Midrash (Vayikra Rabbah 29:9) calls Tishrei “the month of His oath,” because the oath to Avraham after the Akeidah was sworn then, and asks why G‑d needed an oath. Its answer: Avraham asked that when his children sin, G‑d remember the binding of Yitzchak and turn from judgment to mercy; the oath holds even when judgment would otherwise prevail, along the lines the maamar has given.
והנה חודש השביעי תשרי מאיר בו תיקון השביעי מי״ג ת״ד [תיקוני דיקנא] שהוא תיקון ואמת שמשם שבועות אמת ועיין בזח״א [בזהר חלק א] (מקץ דר״ד ב׳13 וירא קי״ב ב׳). וברע״מ [וברעיא מהימנא] (פ׳ יתרו דצ״א ב׳)14
Now, in the seventh month, Tishrei, there shines the seventh of the thirteen tikkunim (adornments) of the beard, which is the tikkun “and truth,” from which come oaths of truth. See Zohar, vol. 1 (Mikeitz, folio 204b; Vayeira, 112b). And in the Raaya Mehemna (Parshas Yisro, folio 91b).
In the Kabbalah, the thirteen tikkunim (adornments) of the “beard” correspond to the thirteen attributes of mercy; “and truth” is the seventh, so the seventh month shines with that attribute, the source of true oaths. The Zohar passages cited expound “and by His Name you shall swear,” and the Raaya Mehemna (a section of the Zohar on the mitzvos) treats the mitzvah of swearing truthfully by His Name.
ובפי׳ אשר נשבעת י״ל [יש לומר] ע״ד מ״ש לקמן בפי׳ אשר קדשנו כו׳
And the meaning of “asher nishbata” (as You swore) can be explained along the lines of what is written below on the meaning of “asher kiddeshanu” (who has sanctified us), etc.
The word asher in “asher nishbata” will be explained later together with “asher kiddeshanu,” as a term of delight.
¶9 The meaning of "asher" is explained in paragraph 9.
והנה מימי קדם י״ל [יש לומר] ג״כ ז׳ תיקונין דגלגלתא ועמ״ש בענין אם יהיו חטאיכם כשנים כשלג ילבינו15 כו׳ כצמר יהיו ומ״ש ע״פ הנותן שלג כצמר16 ועמ״ש סד״ה ציון במשפט תפדה:17
Now, “the days of old” can also be explained as the seven tikkunim of the Gulgalta (the Skull). See also what is written on the subject of “If your sins be like scarlet, they shall be white as snow, etc., … they shall be as wool,” and what is written on the verse “He gives snow like wool,” and see also what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “Zion shall be redeemed with justice.”
“The days of old” can also mean the seven tikkunim of the Gulgalta, the “skull,” a very high level above the world’s order. The text also points to its explanations of two verses on snow and wool, and to the discourse on “Zion shall be redeemed with justice.”
The paragraph shows that even the “cut off” retain the love at their root, and explains the power of this love through G‑d’s oath: a commitment above wisdom and will, drawn from the Infinite Light itself, which is why our deeds can arouse a response above.
The oath is placed at sovev kol almin and the “primordial thought,” above hishtalshelus; this is why the link between the arousal from below and the response from above does not depend on the worthiness measured by reason. The Kehot note’s quotation of the Rebbe adds that the oath overrides even a change in the revealed will. The maamar then ties the oath to Tishrei. Kabbalah describes the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy as thirteen tikkunim, “adornments,” of the supernal “beard,” a figure for channels of Divine mercy, and in the Ari’s count of Moshe’s attributes the seventh is “ve’emes,” “and truth.” So the seventh month draws on the seventh tikkun, the source of a true oath, which is why the Midrash the maamar cites calls Tishrei “the month of His oath.”
TermsKadmono shel olamOz vesushiyahMachshavah hakedumahBris veTorah+12
- Kadmono shel olam קדמונו של עולם
- Oz vesushiyah עוז ותושיה
- Machshavah hakedumah מחשבה הקדומה
- Bris veTorah ברית ותורה
- Ahavah mesuteres אהבה מסותרת
- Gulgalta of Arich Anpin גלגלתא
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Memalei kol almin ממלא כל עלמין
- Daas דעת
- Sovev kol almin סובב כל עלמין
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
- Ratzon רצון
Marei mekomos
- 1כי אבי ואמי עזבוני · Psalms 27:10
- 2או השבע שבועה · Numbers 30:3
- 3צריך להבין ענין שבועה זו · ראה סה״מ אתהלך לאזניא ע׳ רה. סה״מ תרל״ד ע׳ רצ.
- 4לזרעך נתתי את הארץ · Genesis 15:18
- 5נגד חכמתו ורצונו · ”וי״ל שהכוונה בזה שמוסיף ”ורצונו” היא, דפעולת השבועה היא לא רק שע״י השכל לא יהי׳ שינוי בהרצון, אלא שגם אם יהי׳ שינוי גם בהרצון (שבגילוי) יעשה נגד רצונו” — ד״ה יו״ט של ר״ה תשל״ג (נ׳ בסה״מ מלוקט ח״ג ע׳ רצה הערה 28).
- 6אתם נצבים כו׳ לעברך בברית · Deuteronomy 29:9–11
- 7שתוק כך עלה במחשבה · Menachot 29b:5
- 8(דקל״ד ע״ב) בענין אשר נשבעת · Zohar, Idra Rabba 21:157–23:166
- 9(ודק״ל ע״א) בענין בי נשבעתי · Zohar, Idra Rabba 8:50–9:63
- 10בי נשבעתי ובפ׳ אחרי · Zohar, Achrei Mot 29:182–31:193
- 11ד״א בחודש השביעי רבי ברכיה היה קרי ליה ירחא דשבועתיה · Vayikra Rabbah 29:9
- 12בי נשבעתי נאום ה׳ · Genesis 22:16
- 13ועיין בזח״א (מקץ דר״ד ב׳ · Zohar, Miketz 15:261–269
- 14וברע״מ (פ׳ יחרו דצ״א ב׳) · Zohar, Yitro 32:528–33:537
- 15
- 16הנותן שלג כצמר · Psalms 147:16
- 17ציון במשפט תפדה · Isaiah 1:27
The delight in the mitzvos ¶9
3. And this is [the meaning of] “asher kiddeshanu bemitzvosav” (who has sanctified us with His commandments), etc. Meaning: asher is from the term “be’oshri” (in my happiness), “for the daughters have called me happy (ishruni),” etc., “Ashrei (happy are) those who dwell,” etc.,
Section 3 turns to the blessing said before a mitzvah, “asher kiddeshanu bemitzvosav.” The word asher (“who”) is read as related to osher, happiness or praise, as in Leah’s “the daughters have called me happy” and the psalm’s “Ashrei.”
¶8 This is the explanation of "asher" promised in paragraph 8.
שהוא לשון שבח והלל כלומר שיש דבר טוב ויפה מאד עד להלל ולשבח על הטוב ההוא שאין לו קץ ותכלית
which is a term of praise and acclaim; that is to say, there is something so good and very beautiful that one praises and acclaims that goodness, which has no end or limit.
Asher, in this sense, is praise for a good so great that it has no end. The blessing thus hints at something infinitely good reached through the mitzvos.
והוא בחי׳ עונג העליון בגילוי אור א״ס ב״ה בעצמו ובכבודו על ידי מצותיו שהם בחי׳ רצון העליון
And this is the level of the supernal delight, in the revelation of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, in His very Self and glory, through His mitzvos, which are the level of the supernal will.
That infinite good is the supernal delight: G‑d’s own pleasure, in which the Infinite Light itself is revealed. It is reached through the mitzvos because they are His will.
כמו מבשרי אחזה5 שהנפש היא ז׳ מדות וג׳ שכליים ולמעלה מהם הוא הרצון העליון המנהיג את החכמה והבינה והדעת שלו כך המצות נקרא רצון העליון שלמעלה מן החכמה
As in “From my flesh I shall perceive”: the soul is seven middos (emotive attributes) and three intellectual [faculties], and above them is the higher will, which directs its Chochmah, Binah and Daas; so too the mitzvos are called the supernal will, which is above Chochmah.
Job’s “from my flesh I shall perceive” teaches that the human soul mirrors the Divine. In the soul, the will stands above the intellect and emotions and directs them; so G‑d’s will, the mitzvos, stands above His wisdom.
והוא בחי׳ כתר תר״ך עמודי אור6 כי תרי״ג מצות דאורייתא וז׳ דרבנן הם תר״ך
And this is the level of Keser [whose letters total 620]: the 620 pillars of light; for the 613 mitzvos of the Torah and the seven of the Rabbis are 620.
This will is Keser, the “crown” above intellect, described in Kabbalah as 620 “pillars of light” (the numerical value of keser is 620); the Kehot note traces this to Rabbi Moshe Cordovero’s Pardes Rimonim (Sha’ar (Gate) 8, chapter 3). The number matches the 613 Torah commandments plus the 7 Rabbinic ones, and in Likkutei Torah, Bechukosai, the Alter Rebbe explains that the 248 positive commandments are the vessels, the “limbs,” that receive this light of Keser.
והם עד״מ כמו העמודים שראשם האחד הוא על הגג והב׳ הוא על הקרקע ובהם וע״י מתחבר הגג עם הקרקע והיו לאחדים.
And they are, by way of analogy, like pillars, one end of which is on the roof and the other on the ground, and in them and through them the roof is joined with the ground and they become one.
A pillar joins roof and ground, making the building one. So the mitzvos join the highest level, G‑d’s will, with the physical world below.
כך עד״מ המצות הם פנימיות רצון העליון שהוא למעלה מבחינת חכמה
So, by way of analogy, the mitzvos are the inner dimension of the supernal will, which is above the level of Chochmah.
The mitzvos are the inner core of the supernal will, which stands above Chochmah.
ובחי׳ חכמה ג״כ חכים ולא בחכמה ידיעא78 ורצון העליון הוא יותר נעלה שהוא נמשך מבחינת אשר שהוא תענוג העליון (ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה והנה מנורת זהב9)10
And the level of Chochmah, too, is “wise, but not with a known wisdom,” and the supernal will is loftier still, for it is drawn from the level of asher, which is the supernal delight. (See also what is written on this in the discourse beginning “And behold, a menorah of gold.”)
Even G‑d’s Chochmah is beyond our knowing: Eliyahu’s prayer in the Tikkunei Zohar says He is “wise, but not with a known wisdom.” The will is higher still, because it comes from delight, the level called asher: a person wants what he takes pleasure in, so delight is the root of will. In Likkutei Torah, Beha’aloscha (“And behold, a menorah of gold”), the Alter Rebbe explains that G‑d’s will, clothed in the mitzvos, is the vessel for this supernal delight.
ומתפשט ויורד בסתר המדרגות ממדרגה למדרגה עד שמתלבש במעשה המצות הגשמיים במעשה התחתונים מצות ומע״ט [ומעשים טובים].
And it spreads and descends in the hiddenness of the levels, from level to level, until it is clothed in the performance of the physical mitzvos, in the deeds of the lower beings: mitzvos and good deeds.
This will descends through all the hidden levels until it is clothed in physical mitzvos done by people in this world.
וזהו וצונו לשון התקשרות וצוותא להתעטף בציצית כלומר בציצית העליונים. וכן עד״ז כל המצות להיות תלוי אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא] באתעדל״ת [באתערותא דלתתא] שלנו משא״כ בעובדי כוכבים כו׳ כנ״ל
And this is “vetzivanu” (and has commanded us), a term of connection and companionship (tzavta): “to wrap ourselves in tzitzis,” that is to say, in the supernal tzitzis. And so too, in the same way, all the mitzvos: that the arousal from above depend on our arousal from below; which is not so with star-worshippers, etc., as mentioned above.
The blessing continues “vetzivanu,” read as tzavta, companionship or connection: by wrapping in tzitzis, a Jew connects with the “supernal tzitzis.” Through all the mitzvos, the response from above depends on our deed below; as said earlier, this is not so for idolaters.
והיינו מפני גילוי עונג העליון ושמחה העליונה כמשל המלך שביום שמחתו הוא מתגלה לעין כל.
And this is because of the revelation of the supernal delight and the supernal joy, like the analogy of the king who, on the day of his rejoicing, reveals himself to every eye.
The reason is that the mitzvos reveal G‑d’s delight and joy. A king who is usually hidden shows himself to everyone on the day of his celebration.
כך כביכול ע״י עונג העליון ושמחה העליונה מתגלה אור א״ס ב״ה ומתפשט עד למטה ליתן כח זה בתחתונים מה שלא היה יכולת באדם בלאו הכי
So, as it were, through the supernal delight and the supernal joy, the Infinite Light, blessed be He, is revealed and spreads down below, to give this power to the lower beings, which a person would not have been able [to have] otherwise.
So too G‑d’s joy in the mitzvos causes the Infinite Light to reveal itself all the way down, giving human beings a power they could never have on their own: to draw G‑d’s light by their deeds.
(See also what is written on this in the discourse beginning “To My mare among the chariots,” regarding “For over all the glory there shall be a canopy,” “like a bridegroom coming out of his canopy”;
The text refers to the discourse “To My mare among the chariots” (Likkutei Torah, Shir HaShirim), on the canopy over all glory and the bridegroom coming out of his canopy. There the light drawn down by the mitzvos is described as encompassing, a “shade” rather than open light, beyond the grasp of creatures.
ועמ״ש בד״ה שוש אשיש14 מענין זה איך שע״י גילוי עונג העליון והשמחה הנמשך ממנו הוא גורם שיהיה נמשך מבחינת סוכ״ע אל בחי׳ ממכ״ע [ממלא כל עלמין] ושם נתבאר הטעם כי השמחה הוא הגורם ענוה ושפלות שהוא ענין המשכה זו כו׳ ע״ש) וזהו יפה שעה אחת בתשובה ומעשים טובים בעולם הזה מכל חיי העולם הבא15
and see what is written in the discourse beginning “I will greatly rejoice” on this matter: how the revelation of the supernal delight, and the joy drawn from it, causes [light] to be drawn from the level of sovev kol almin to the level of memalei kol almin; and there the reason is explained, that joy is what brings about humility and lowliness, which is the matter of this drawing down, etc.; see there.) And this is “One hour of teshuvah and good deeds in this world is finer than all the life of the World to Come.”
A second discourse, on “I will greatly rejoice,” shows how revealed delight and joy draw light from sovev kol almin into memalei kol almin, because joy brings humility, a lowering of oneself, which is itself a drawing down. Now the Mishnah can be explained: one hour of good deeds here is finer than all the World to Come.
¶1 This explains the saying about one hour of teshuvah from paragraph 1.
כי ענין עוה״ב [עולם הבא] ידוע שיש ג״ע [גן עדן] עליון וג״ע [וגן עדן] תחתון בחי׳ ג״ע [גן עדן] תחתון הוא שנהנין הנשמות מזיו והתפשטות ההארה ב״ה
For the matter of the World to Come is known: there is a higher Gan Eden and a lower Gan Eden. The level of the lower Gan Eden is that the souls take pleasure in the radiance and spreading forth of the illumination, blessed be He.
The World to Come, as the soul experiences it, is Gan Eden, the Garden of Eden, in a lower and a higher level. In the lower, souls enjoy the radiance of G‑d’s light.
והגם שהוא תענוג עד אין קץ ונפלא מאד לכן אמרו רז״ל [רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] בגמרא על אלישע אחר מוטב דלידייניה וליתי לעלמא דאתי16 שכדאי כל יסורי גיהנם להצילו בנפשו שתתענג מזיו כבוד ה׳ לפי שהתענוג הוא נפלא עד אין קץ כו׳
And although it is a delight without end and exceedingly wondrous, which is why our Sages, of blessed memory, said in the Gemara concerning Elisha Acher [“the Other”], “Better that he be judged and come to the World to Come,” for all the sufferings of Gehinnom are worthwhile to save his soul, so that it may delight in the radiance of the glory of G‑d, since the delight is wondrous without end, etc.,
That delight is without end, as the Talmud’s story of Elisha ben Avuyah, called Acher (“the Other”) after he left the path, shows: it was better that he be punished and then enter the World to Come, because all of Gehinnom’s suffering is worth that delight.
ואח״כ ע״י נהר דינור מתעלים בעילוי אחר עילוי עד אין קץ ותכלית כו׳ אך כ״ז [כל זה] הוא על ידי בחינת צמצום ביו״ד נברא עוה״ב [עולם הבא]17 כו׳ לפי ערך השגת הנבראים כו׳
and afterwards, through the river of fire (nehar dinur), they ascend from elevation to elevation without end or limit, etc., nevertheless all this is through the level of tzimtzum: “with the yud the World to Come was created,” etc., according to the measure of the created beings’ comprehension, etc.
Souls rise ever higher, passing through the “river of fire” (nehar dinur) that purifies them between levels. Yet all this is limited by tzimtzum: the Sages say the World to Come was created with the letter yud, the smallest letter, so it is measured to what creatures can grasp.
משא״כ על ידי מע״ט [מעשים טובים] שהם המצות נמשך עונג העליון שהוא גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה בעצמו ובכבודו שאינו לפי ערך השגת הנבראים
This is not so through good deeds, which are the mitzvos: through them is drawn the supernal delight, which is the revelation of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, in His very Self and glory, which is not according to the measure of the created beings’ comprehension.
The mitzvos, by contrast, draw G‑d’s own delight, the Infinite Light itself, which is not measured to any creature’s grasp.
ואין הנבראים יכולים לקבל העונג הגדול הזה אלא העונג הוא לפניו ית׳ כביכול שעשועי המלך בעצמותו (עמ״ש סד״ה לסוסתי ברכבי הנ״ל ובד״ה מנורת זהב) וזהו יותר מכל חיי העולם הבא שהעונג ניתן להנות בו בני אדם נשמות הנבראים.
And created beings cannot receive this great delight; rather, the delight is before Him, may He be blessed, as it were: the delights of the King in His very essence. (See what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “To My mare among the chariots,” mentioned above, and in the discourse beginning “A menorah of gold.”) And this is more than all the life of the World to Come, where the delight is given for human beings, the souls of created beings, to take pleasure in.
No created being can take in that delight; it is G‑d’s own, like a king’s private delight within himself. This is why one hour of mitzvos is greater than all the World to Come: there, the pleasure is given to creatures to enjoy; here, it is G‑d’s own.
ובזה יובן ענין שבת דכתיב וקראת לשבת18 עונג כלומר שתמשיך בחי׳ עונג העליון להיות שורה ומתגלה ביום השבת
And with this the matter of Shabbos will be understood, as it is written, “And you shall call the Shabbos a delight”: that is to say, that you draw down the level of the supernal delight to rest and be revealed on the day of Shabbos.
Shabbos is called “a delight” because on it we draw down this supernal delight, so that it rests and is revealed on that day.
חי׳ אז תתענג על19 ה׳ למעלה מבחי׳ הוי׳ שהיו״ד הוא הצמצום שבו נברא עוה״ב [עולם הבא] תענוג הנשמות כנ״ל והנה כל זה הוא ענין מצות ומעשים טובים שהם יותר טובים מכל חיי עוה״ב [עולם הבא]:20
Then “you will delight al (in, above) Havayah”: above the level of Havayah, whose yud is the tzimtzum with which the World to Come, the delight of the souls, was created, as mentioned above. And all this is the matter of mitzvos and good deeds, which are better than all the life of the World to Come.
Isaiah’s promise “then you will delight al Havayah,” plainly “in Havayah,” is read with al as “above”: a delight higher than the Name itself, because the yud of that Name is the tzimtzum through which the World to Come was made. The paragraph closes: all this explains why mitzvos and good deeds are better than all the World to Come.
The paragraph explains the blessing over the mitzvos: they are G‑d’s will, rooted in His delight, and through them His own infinite delight is revealed below. This is why an hour of good deeds here surpasses all the World to Come, where souls enjoy only a light measured to their grasp.
Keser is identified with the 620 pillars of light (keser = 620). The contrast between the lower Gan Eden, the “radiance” measured by the yud, and the mitzvos, which reach G‑d’s own delight, sets up the contrast with teshuvah in the next section. (Before “then you will delight” the print has an unclear abbreviation, חי׳, which is left untranslated.)
TermsSha’ashu’imTaryach amudei orSupernal WillTaanug+32
- Sha’ashu’im שעשועים explained hereHere mitzvos draw supernal delight, Or Ein Sof Himself; creatures cannot receive it; it stays before Him, the King’s delight in Himself, surpassing the World to Come.
ואין הנבראים יכולים לקבל העונג הגדול הזה אלא העונג הוא לפניו ית׳ כביכול שעשועי המלך בעצמותו
- Taryach amudei or תר״ך עמודי אור explained hereAs pillars with one end on the roof and one on the ground, the 620 mitzvos, inner supernal Will above Chochmah, join the two, drawing supernal delight into physical deeds.
והם עד״מ כמו העמודים שראשם האחד הוא על הגג והב׳ הוא על הקרקע
- Supernal Will רצון העליון explained hereAs in the soul, made of seven middos and three intellects, the will stands above them and leads its Chochmah, Binah and Daas, so the mitzvos are called the Supernal Will, above Chochmah: Keser, 620 “pillars of light” (613 and the seven rabbinic mitzvos) joining roof to floor. It is drawn from the supernal delight and descends level by level until it is clothed in the physical deed.
כך המצות נקרא רצון העליון שלמעלה מן החכמה והוא בחי׳ כתר תר״ך עמודי אור
- Taanug תענוג explained hereThe supernal delight reveals Or Ein Sof itself through the mitzvos, which are the Supernal Will. It is not measured to what creatures grasp but is the King’s delight in Himself, more than all the life of the World to Come; on Shabbos (“call the Shabbos a delight”) it is drawn to rest and be revealed.
והוא בחי׳ עונג העליון בגילוי אור א״ס ב״ה בעצמו ובכבודו על ידי מצותיו
- Beyud nivra olam haba ביו״ד נברא העוה״ב
- Chuppah חופה
- Divrei sofrim דברי סופרים
- Anavah ענוה
- Olam HaBa עולם הבא
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Gan Eden גן עדן
- Ziv haShechinah זיו השכינה
- Simchah שמחה
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Memalei kol almin ממלא כל עלמין
- Hasagah השגה
- Olam HaZeh עולם הזה
- Teshuvah תשובה
- Tzimtzum צמצום
- Daas דעת
- Atzmus u’mahus עצמות ומהות
- Binah בינה
- Shabbos שבת
- Keser כתר
- Sovev kol almin סובב כל עלמין
- Pnimiyus פנימיות
- Ratzon רצון
- Middos מדות
Also NeshamahHislabshusHavayahOr Ein SofTorah and mitzvosChochmahHaalaah vehamshachahTorah
Marei mekomos
- 1אשר מלשון באשרי · בת״ז (ת״ל עד, רע״ב). ובריש (תט״ל). [כ]. ראה באוה״ת נ״ך כרך ב ע׳ תתקיא שמציין לכאן.
- 2אשר מלשון באשרי · Tikkunei Zohar 74b:2
- 3באשרי כי אשרוני בנות · Genesis 30:13
- 4אשרי יושבי · Psalms 84:5
- 5מבשרי אחזה · Job 19:26
- 6תר״ך עמודי אור · פרדס ש״ח, פ״ג. ע״ל בחקותי (מז, ב). וש״נ. [כ].
- 7חכים ולא בחכמה ידיעא · ת״ז בהקדמה.
- 8חכים ולא בחכמה ידיעא · Tikkunei Zohar 17a
- 9
- 10בד״ה והנה מנורת זהב · לעיל פ׳ בהעלותך לד, ב.
- 11בד״ה לסוסתי · לקמן שה״ש יב, ב.
- 12כי על כל כבוד חופה · Isaiah 4:5
- 13כחתן יוצא מחופתו · Psalms 19:6
- 14שוש אשיש · Isaiah 61:10
- 15יפה שעה אחת בתשובה ומעשים טובים בעולם הזה מכל חיי העולם הבא · Pirkei Avot 4:17
- 16מוטב דלידייניה וליתי לעלמא דאתי · Chagigah 15b:3
- 17ביו״ד נברא עוה״ב · Menachot 29b:13–14
- 18
- 19אז תתענג על ה׳ · Isaiah 58:14
- 20
Teshuvah, the left hand and the right ¶10–11
10ד וכדי להבין ענין תשובה שיפה מכל חיי עוה״ב [עולם הבא] שהרי על שניהם אומר יפה שעה אחת בתשובה ומעשים טובים כו׳ הנה עד״מ יש שני מיני תענוגים לפני המלך. האחד בעשיית המצות.
4. And in order to understand the matter of teshuvah, which is finer than all the life of the World to Come, for concerning both of them it says, “One hour of teshuvah and good deeds,” etc.: by way of analogy, there are two kinds of delight before the king. The first is in the carrying out of his commands.
Section 4 turns to teshuvah, since the Mishnah praises both teshuvah and good deeds. An analogy: a king has two kinds of delight. The first is when his commands are carried out, which corresponds to the mitzvos just discussed.
The paragraph opens the discussion of teshuvah with the parable of the king’s two delights, the first being the carrying out of his commands.
11והב׳ כשרואה את בנו שבא מארץ מרחק שיש זמן רב אשר לא ראהו וכראות המלך את הבן נתמלא חדוה ותענוג
And the second is when he sees his son who has come from a distant land, whom he has not seen for a long time; and when the king sees the son, he is filled with joy and delight.
The king’s second delight: seeing a son who has returned from a far land after a long absence. The joy of reunion is a different and deeper delight than the pleasure of obedience. Further on, the maamar cites Shlomo’s “I said, I will become wise, but it is far from me,” the verse with which the Midrash (Bamidbar Rabbah 19:3) opens the statute of the red heifer, and says that teshuvah reveals this “far” level. It then quotes Rabbi Abahu (Berachos 34b), who learns from “peace, peace to the far and to the near” that where baalei teshuvah stand the completely righteous cannot stand, since the far one is named first. The maamar explains that the two kinds of peace are two “places,” and that the baal teshuvah reaches the higher one.
וכן בנמשל אע״פ [אף על פי] שנתרחק האדם בחטאיו אעפ״כ [אף על פי כן] מ״מ ע״י תשובה נתקרב למקורו ושרשו
So too in the analogue: although a person has become distant through his sins, nevertheless, through teshuvah he is brought near to his source and root.
In the analogy, a person distanced by sin who returns in teshuvah is drawn back to his source and root.
ואפילו בחייבי כריתות כתיב כי אבי ואמי עזבוני1 וה׳ יאספני שהוא ע״י בחי׳ שרש נשמתו למעלה בחי׳ מזל כו׳ כנ״ל וע״י תשובה במס״נ [במסירות נפש] הוא משיג עד בחינת המזל אין כנ״ל כמ״ש במ״א
And even concerning those liable to kares it is written, “For my father and my mother have forsaken me, but Havayah will gather me in,” which is through the level of the root of his soul above, the level of mazal, etc., as mentioned above; and through teshuvah with self-sacrifice (mesirus nefesh) he reaches as high as the level of the mazal, ayin, as mentioned above and as is written elsewhere.
This holds even for one liable to kares: Havayah “gathers in” such a person through the root of his soul above, his mazal, as explained in paragraph 7. Teshuvah with self-sacrifice reaches all the way to that root, the level of ayin.
וזהו שלום שלום לרחוק ולקרוב2 שיש ב׳ בחי׳ בשלום אחד הוא גילוי תענוג העליון לרחוק הוא בעל תשובה כאשר בא מארץ מרחק כי מרחוק ה׳ נראה לי3 כו׳
And this is “Peace, peace, to the far and to the near”: there are two levels in peace. One is the revelation of the supernal delight “to the far,” that is, the baal teshuvah [one who returns], when he comes from a distant land, for “From afar Havayah appeared to me,” etc.
Isaiah’s “peace, peace, to the far and to the near” names two kinds of peace. The first, “to the far,” is the delight G‑d takes in the baal teshuvah, one who returns from far away, as Jeremiah says, “from afar Havayah appeared to me”: G‑d reveals Himself precisely to the one who was far.
והב׳ הוא לקרוב ע״י מצות המלך כו׳ כנ״ל (וע׳ מענין לרחוק בזח״א [בזהר חלק א]) (ד״ו ע״א)4 לרחוק כד״א [כמה דאת אמר] מרחוק5 ה׳ נראה לי כו׳
And the second is “to the near,” through the king’s commands, etc., as mentioned above. (See on the matter of “to the far” in Zohar, vol. 1) (folio 6a): “‘To the far,’ as it is said, ‘From afar Havayah appeared to me,’” etc.;
The second peace, “to the near,” is the delight in those who keep the King’s commands, the mitzvos. The Zohar (1:6a) reads the doubled “peace” as two kinds of peace, and explains “to the far” with the same verse from Jeremiah.
וע״ש במק״מ [במקדש מלך] ובהרמ״ז [ובהרב משה זכות]6 ועמ״ש בד״ה החלצו מאתכם7 בענין שלום בפמליא של מעלה ובפמליא של מטה והיינו ענין ב׳ בחי׳ שלום דלרחוק ולקרוב
and see there in the Mikdash Melech and in the Ramaz. See also what is written in the discourse beginning “Arm from among yourselves” on the matter of peace in the household above and in the household below; and this is the matter of the two levels of peace, “to the far and to the near.”
The Zohar’s commentators, the Mikdash Melech (by R. Shalom Buzaglo) and the Ramaz, discuss that passage. A discourse in Likkutei Torah on Mattos links these two kinds of peace to the Talmud’s “peace in the household above and the household below”: there Chochmah and Binah, opposites, become one through a light from above both.
וזהו ג״כ ענין ב׳ בחינות שלום שבפסוק או יחזיק במעוזי יעשה שלום לי שלום יעשה לי8 (בישעיה סי׳ כ״ז ה׳)
And this is also the matter of the two levels of peace in the verse, “Or let him take hold of My strength, [that] he may make peace with Me; peace he shall make with Me” (Isaiah, chapter 27, [verse] 5).
Isaiah’s verse repeats “peace”: “he may make peace with Me; peace he shall make with Me.” The doubling is read as the same two kinds of peace.
ועיין מזה ברבות נשא פי״ג גבי ולזבח השלמים שבקרבן נתנאל בן צוער. שני שלומות שלום למעלה ושלום למטה9 ובזח״ג [ובזהר חלק ג] (במדבר קי״ח א׳).
And see on this in the Midrash Rabbah, Naso, section 13, regarding “and for the peace-offering” in the offering of Nesanel ben Tzuar: two [kinds of] peace, peace above and peace below. And in Zohar, vol. 3 (Bamidbar, folio 118a).
The Midrash on Naso reads the peace-offering of the prince Nesanel ben Tzuar, two oxen, as the two Torahs, Scripture and Mishnah: whoever keeps them makes two kinds of peace, above and below. The Zohar also discusses this.
And in Parshas Vayikra (folio 20, end of side b), on the verse “For behold, I will save you from afar” (and folios 21a, 54a, 76b, 109a).
The Zohar on Vayikra asks why Jeremiah says “I will save you from afar” rather than “from near,” and reads “afar” as in “from afar Havayah appeared to me.” The text lists further Zohar passages.
And the explanation is: it is written, “I will become wise, but it is far from me”; and see on this in the Midrash Rabbah, Parshas Chukas. And through teshuvah the revelation of this level is drawn down.
King Shlomo said of wisdom, “it is far from me”: there is a level of Divine wisdom that stays “far,” beyond grasp; the Midrash on Chukas discusses this verse. Teshuvah draws down the revelation of this “far” level.
וזהו ענין שלום לרחוק שיהיה קרוב ועמ״ש סד״ה כי המצוה הזאת15 בענין ולא רחוקה היא ועמ״ש לקמן סד״ה ביום השמע״צ [השמיני עצרת] גבי מאת הוי׳ היתה זאת.
And this is the matter of “peace to the far,” that it become near. See also what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “For this commandment,” on the matter of “It is not far”; and see what is written below, at the end of the discourse beginning “On the day of Shemini Atzeres,” regarding “This has come from Havayah.”
“Peace to the far” means that this distant level becomes near. The text refers to the end of the discourse “For this commandment” (Likkutei Torah, Nitzavim), which explains “it is not far” as: not far even in the distance of comprehension, so that no one should say the level is too high to reach; and to the second maamar on Shemini Atzeres.
וזהו ענין במקום שבעלי תשובה עומדים אין צדיקים גמורים יכולים לעמוד כי יש ב׳ בחינות מקום דהיינו בחי׳ פמליא של מעלה ופמליא של מטה הנ״ל הן ב׳ בחינות מקום.
And this is the matter of “In the place where baalei teshuvah stand, the perfectly righteous (tzaddikim gemurim) cannot stand”: for there are two levels of “place,” namely, the level of the household above and the household below mentioned above; these are the two levels of place.
The Talmud says that baalei teshuvah stand in a “place” where even perfect tzaddikim cannot stand. The two kinds of “place” are the two households, above and below, just mentioned.
והוא מ״ש בזח״ב [בזהר חלק ב׳] (ויקהל דר״ז ע״א)16 בענין ברוך כבוד1718 ה׳ ממקומו וכתיב הנה מקום אתי19 אתר דלא אתגליא.
And this is what is written in Zohar, vol. 2 (Vayakhel, folio 207a), on the matter of “Blessed be the glory of Havayah from His place,” and it is written, “Behold, there is a place with Me”: a place that is not revealed.
The Zohar speaks of the “place” from which G‑d’s glory is blessed in Ezekiel’s vision, and of G‑d’s words to Moshe, “Behold, there is a place with Me”: a hidden, unrevealed place.
ובחינה זו הוא ע״י התשובה פד, אשהרי גבי הנה מקום אתי נאמר י״ג מדות הרחמים שהוא בחינת תשובה כו׳
And this level is through teshuvah; for regarding “Behold, there is a place with Me,” the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy were said, which are the level of teshuvah, etc.
That hidden place is reached through teshuvah, since right after “there is a place with Me” G‑d revealed to Moshe the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy, which are connected with teshuvah and forgiveness.
וזהו בחינת יום כפור שבכל עשרת ימי תשובה הוא כמתקרב לפני המלך ופורש מארץ מרחק
And this is the level of Yom Kippur: for throughout the Ten Days of Teshuvah one is like someone drawing near before the King and departing from a distant land,
Yom Kippur is the climax of this. During the Ten Days of Teshuvah a person is like the son drawing near to the King after being in a distant land.
דהיינו ממחשבותיו שבכל השנה שהיה נמשך אחר עוה״ז ותענוגיו
that is, from his thoughts of the whole year, when he was drawn after this world and its pleasures.
The “distant land” is the year’s thoughts, spent chasing this world and its pleasures.
ובעשי״ת [ובעשרת ימי תשובה] אומרים אבינו מלכנו שרוצים להתקרב אליו ית׳ עד שביוכ״פ [שביום כפור / שביום הכפורים] לפני ה׳ תטהרו למעלה מבחי׳ הוי׳ והיו״ד שבו נברא עוה״ב [עולם הבא] מחמת התענוג הגדול כביכול שעשועי המלך שראה את בנו שבא אליו מארץ מרחק.
And in the Ten Days of Teshuvah we say “Avinu Malkeinu” (our Father, our King), for we want to draw near to Him, may He be blessed, until on Yom Kippur, “before Havayah you shall be purified”: above the level of Havayah and the yud with which the World to Come was created, because of the great delight, as it were, the delight of the King who has seen his son come to him from a distant land.
In these days we say “Avinu Malkeinu,” our Father, our King, expressing the wish to come close, until on Yom Kippur we are purified “before Havayah,” read as “above the level of Havayah,” above even the yud through which the World to Come was made. This comes from the King’s great delight in the returning son.
וכך כתיב ובמרחקים יזכרוני20 כו׳ (זכריה יו״ד ט׳) וזהו שמאלו תחת לראשי פי׳ שע״י שמאל דוחה21 שבכל עשרת ימי תשובה דהיינו שהיה דוחה את עצמו להיותו בעיניו בבחינת רחוק מה׳ מאד.
And so it is written, “And in far places they will remember Me,” etc. (Zechariah 10:9). And this is “His left hand is under my head.” Meaning: through the “left [hand] that pushes away” during all the Ten Days of Teshuvah, that is, he would push himself away, being in his own eyes very far from G‑d.
Zechariah’s “in far places they will remember Me” fits the same theme. Now the opening verse is explained: the “left hand,” which in the Talmud’s phrase “pushes away,” is the person’s own sense, during the Ten Days, of being very far from G‑d.
¶1 This answers the question from paragraph 1 about "under my head."
וע״ז תיקנו כל הוידוים חטאנו אשמנו כו׳ וכל מה שהפה יכול לדבר ולספר בגנותו אומרים על עצמם הוא הגורם להיות קירוב בתשובה מחמת מרירות נפשו כדכתיב ויצעקו אל22 ה׳ בצר להם כו׳.
And for this all the confessions were instituted, “We have sinned, we have been guilty,” etc.; and all that the mouth can speak and tell to one’s discredit they say about themselves. This is what brings about the drawing near through teshuvah, because of the bitterness of his soul, as it is written, “And they cried out to Havayah in their distress,” etc.
That is why the confessions list every possible sin. Speaking of one’s failings brings bitterness of soul, and that bitterness brings closeness through teshuvah, as the psalm says, they cried out to Havayah in their distress.
וזהו מכל חטאתיכם לפני הוי׳ תטהרו שעל ידי התשובה מתגלה עונג העליון שהוא בחינת ראשי.
And this is “From all your sins, before Havayah you shall be purified”: through teshuvah the supernal delight is revealed, which is the level of “my head.”
Through teshuvah the supernal delight is revealed. This delight is “my head” in the verse: so “His left hand is under my head” means that the left hand, the distance a person feels, leads to the revelation of this “head.”
ולכן יוכ״פ [יום כפור / יום הכפורים] אין בו לא אכילה ושתיה23 כו׳ (והנה ב׳ בחי׳ תענוג הנ״ל הן כענין או״י [אור ישר] ואו״ח [ואור חוזר] בחי׳ אברהם ויצחק היינו חסד וגבורה שבתענוג ועמ״ש ע״פ עלי באר בענין מעין גנים וענין באר מים חיים24
And therefore on Yom Kippur there is no eating or drinking, etc. (Now, the two levels of delight mentioned above are like direct light and returning light (or yashar and or chozer), the levels of Avraham and Yitzchak, that is, Chesed and Gevurah within delight. See also what is written on the verse “Spring up, O well,” on the matter of “a fountain of gardens” and the matter of “a well of living waters.”
Because Yom Kippur reaches this level above bodily life, there is no eating or drinking on it. The two delights, in mitzvos and in teshuvah, are compared to direct light and returning light, and to Avraham (Chesed) and Yitzchak (Gevurah).
ויובן יותר ע״ד שנתבאר בד״ה שוש אשיש הנ״ל בענין השופר שהוא גילוי פנימיות עונג העליון שלמעלה מבחי׳ עונג העליון שממשיכים בכל השנה ע״י התורה והמצות שאמר ונעשה רצוני
And it will be understood further along the lines of what was explained in the discourse beginning “I will greatly rejoice,” mentioned above, on the matter of the shofar, which is the revelation of the inner dimension of the supernal delight, which is above the level of the supernal delight that is drawn down all year through Torah and mitzvos, [the delight] that “He spoke, and My will was done.”
The discourse on “I will greatly rejoice” explained that the shofar reveals the innermost delight, higher than the delight drawn all year through Torah and mitzvos, the delight of “My will was done.”
וגילוי פנימיות עונג העליון ההוא נמשך דוקא ע״י בכייה והתעוררות רחמים שזהו ענין התקיעות גנוחי גנח ילולי יליל25 כו׳ ע״ש באריכות שנתבאר הטעם לפי שע״י הבכיה ממשיכים י״ג מדה״ר [מדות הרחמים] שהן הן פנימיות עונג העליון
And the revelation of that inner dimension of the supernal delight is drawn down specifically through weeping and the arousal of compassion, which is the matter of the blasts, “groaning, groaning, wailing, wailing,” etc. See there at length, where the reason is explained: that through the weeping one draws down the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy, which are themselves the inner dimension of the supernal delight.
That innermost delight is drawn down specifically through weeping, which the shofar’s sounds resemble, as the Talmud describes them as groaning and wailing. Weeping draws down the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy, which are the inner core of G‑d’s delight.
ולפמש״כ [ולפי מה שכתוב] יובן הטעם יותר כי הנה הבכייה והתעורורת רחמים זהו בחי׳ תשובה ממעמקים קראתיך2627 והתשובה הוא ענין לרחוק שנעשה קרוב28 והעונג מזה למעלה הוא עד״מ תענוג המלך כשבא אליו בנו מארץ מרחק מאד. שהוא בחי׳ פנימיות התענוג יותר מהעונג שבמצות המלך מה שאמר ונעשה רצונו.29
And according to what has been written [here], the reason will be understood further: for weeping and the arousal of compassion are the level of teshuvah, “Out of the depths I have called You”; and teshuvah is the matter of the far becoming near. And the delight from this above is, by way of analogy, the delight of the king when his son comes to him from a very distant land, which is the level of the inner dimension of delight, more than the delight in the king’s commands, [the delight] that “He spoke, and His will was done.”
Now the reason is clearer: weeping and compassion are teshuvah, “out of the depths I called You,” the far becoming near. Its delight above is the delight of the king whose son returns from very far, a more inward delight than the one in obeyed commands.
ועמ״ש בד״ה אתם נצבים בענין ושקל בפלס הרים וגבעות במאזנים30.
See also what is written in the discourse beginning “You are standing,” on the matter of “and weighed the mountains with a scale and the hills with a balance.”
The text also points to a discourse on “You are standing,” on G‑d weighing the mountains and hills on a scale.
וענין תענוג זה י״ל [יש לומר] שזהו בחי׳ אשר נשבעת לאבותינו כי אשר בחי׳ תענוג כנ״ל בענין אשר קדשנו במצותיו אלא כי אשר קב״ו [קדשנו במצותיו וצונו] זהו התענוג הנמשך ע״י המצות ובחי׳ אשר נשבעת הוא בי״ג מדות הרחמים דמיכה שהוא הנמשך ע״י התשובה והוא הפנימיות התענוג כנ״ל
And this delight, it can be said, is the level of “asher nishbata (as You swore) to our fathers”; for asher is the level of delight, as mentioned above regarding “asher kiddeshanu bemitzvosav.” But “asher kiddeshanu bemitzvosav” is the delight drawn down through the mitzvos, while the level of “asher nishbata” is in the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy of Micah, which is what is drawn down through teshuvah, and it is the inner dimension of delight, as mentioned above.
This innermost delight may be what “asher nishbata,” the oath to the fathers, refers to. Both “asher kiddeshanu” and “asher nishbata” use asher, delight: the first is the delight in mitzvos; the second, drawn by teshuvah, is the inner core of delight, in the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy found in Micah just before “You will give truth to Yaakov.”
וזהו שמאלו תחת לראשי ראשי היינו פנימיות התענוג
And this is “His left hand is under my head”: “my head” is the inner dimension of delight.
This inner core of delight is “my head” in “His left hand is under my head.”
וכענין בשעה שישראל עונין אמן יהא שמיה רבא מברך הקב״ה מנענע בראשו31 שזהו המשכה מבחי׳ שמיה רבא שמו הגדול ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה אני הוי׳ אלקיכם אשר הוצאתי אתכם מארץ מצרים גם לראשי אותיות ישראל לי ראש.
It is like the matter of “When Israel respond, ‘Amen, yehei shmei rabba mevarach’ [May His great Name be blessed], the Holy One, blessed be He, nods His head”: this is a drawing down from the level of “shmei rabba,” His great Name. See also what is written on this in the discourse beginning “I am Havayah your G‑d who brought you out of the land of Egypt.” Also, lerashi (my head) has the letters of Yisrael (Israel), [and of] li rosh (a head for Me).
The Talmud says that when Israel answer “Amen, yehei shmei rabba,” G‑d, as it were, nods His head; the nodding is drawn from “His great Name,” a level above. In Likkutei Torah, Sh’lach, the Alter Rebbe explains that G‑d’s “head” is His supernal will, the nodding is its drawing down below, and Israel, whose letters are those of li rosh, “a head for Me” (and of lerashi, “my head”), are those who draw it.
ועמ״ש ע״פ מאמר הזח״ג [הזהר חלק ג] קרח) (קע״ח ב׳)32 בענין ועבד הלוי הוא33 אלמלא דינא לא אשתכח בעלמא34 כו׳ ע״ש מענין שמאלו
See also what is written on the saying of the Zohar, vol. 3, Korach) (folio 178b) on the matter of “And the Levite shall perform [the service]”: “Were judgment not found in the world,” etc.; see there on the matter of “His left hand.”
The Zohar on Korach, on the Levites’ service from the side of the left, says that were there no judgment in the world, people would not know the supernal faith or toil in Torah, and the mitzvos would not be kept. That passage shows the positive role of the “left hand,” Gevurah.
(וע׳ עוד מענין שמאלו תחת לראשי35 בזח״ב [בזהר חלק ב׳] קל״ח ב׳ קנ״ד ב׳. ח״ג [חלק ג׳] קמ״ח ב׳ ועוד בח״א [בחלק א׳] קי״ב א׳ קל״ו א׳. ח״ב [חלק ב׳] ד״ל ע״ב קי״ד א׳ רל״ח ב׳ ח״ג [חלק ג׳] נ״ד ב׳ נ״ה א׳ קי״ח ב׳ קי״ט ב׳ ק״כ ע״ב)
(See further on the matter of “His left hand is under my head” in Zohar, vol. 2, 138b, 154b; vol. 3, 148b; and further in vol. 1, 112a, 136a; vol. 2, folio 30b, 114a, 238b; vol. 3, 54b, 55a, 118b, 119b, 120b.)
The text lists many more Zohar passages on “His left hand is under my head” for further study.
והנה בחי׳ גילוי עונג זה הוא בחי׳ שמחה ישמח ה׳ במעשיו וישמח ישראל בעושיו36 כי שמחה היא התגלות העונג והוא בחי׳ סוכות זמן שמחתנו
Now, the level of the revelation of this delight is the level of joy, “Havayah will rejoice in His works” and “Israel will rejoice in its Maker”; for joy is the revelation of delight. And this is the level of Sukkos, “the season of our rejoicing.”
The revelation of this delight is joy: G‑d rejoices in His works and Israel in its Maker. Joy is delight revealed, and so it belongs to Sukkos, “the season of our rejoicing.”
ואזי מתגלה עונג העליון גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה להיות חופף עלינו כל ימי הסוכות והוא בחי׳ וימינו תחבקני כמשל החובק את חבירו מאחוריו
And then the supernal delight is revealed, the revelation of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, to hover over us all the days of Sukkos. And this is the level of “and his right hand embraces me,” like the analogy of one who embraces his fellow from behind.
On Sukkos, G‑d’s delight, the Infinite Light, hovers over us, as the sukkah covers us. This is the “right hand that embraces me,” like one who hugs a friend from behind.
כך וימינו תחבקני שאפילו בחי׳ אחוריים שהוא בחי׳ חיצוניות האדם שנמשך אחר עוה״ז שנקרא אחוריים ובחי׳ עורף וכמ״ש כי פנו אלי עורף37 כו׳ עכ״ז [עם כל זה] הוא מקיפו וסובבו להיות מהפך חשוכא לנהורא כו׳ ולבטל רצונו נגד רצון ה׳
So too, “and his right hand embraces me”: even the level of the back, which is the level of a person’s outer dimension (chitzoniyus), which is drawn after this world and is called “the back” and the level of “the nape,” as it is written, “For they have turned to Me the nape,” etc., nevertheless He encompasses and surrounds him, so as to turn darkness into light, etc., and to nullify his will before the will of G‑d.
So G‑d’s embrace reaches even the “back,” a person’s outer dimension, still drawn after this world, called “the back” and “the nape,” as in Jeremiah’s “they turned to Me the nape and not the face.” Even so, He surrounds that outer part too, to turn its darkness into light and bring a person’s will to yield to G‑d’s will.
והיינו מפני כי ימינו של הקב״ה הוא גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה בעצמו ובכבודו
And this is because the right hand of the Holy One, blessed be He, is the revelation of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, in His very Self and glory;
This is because G‑d’s “right hand” is the revelation of the Infinite Light itself.
הוא הנותן כח ועוז להיות באתערותא דלתתא שעי״ז יהיה אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא] וכמ״ש וירא ישראל את היד הגדולה38 וגו׳
it is what gives strength and power for there to be, through the arousal from below, an arousal from above. As it is written, “And Israel saw the great hand,” etc.
It is what gives our deeds below their power to draw a response from above, as at the Sea, when “Israel saw the great hand.”
(See also what is written on the matter of “the great hand,” etc., in the discourse beginning “In the section of the libations,” and what is written on the verse “Your hand is on the nape of your enemies.”
The text refers to other discourses on “the great hand” and on “your hand on the nape of your enemies.” In the discourse “In the section of the libations” (Likkutei Torah, Sh’lach), “the great hand” is explained as G‑d’s expansion without end, His humility, by which the Name Havayah acts even in “Egypt,” the realm of limits.
וזהו ג״כ ואני נתתי לך שכם אחד41 לעשות מבחינת שכם שהוא לשון כתף ואחוריים כמו על שכם שניהם42 להיות נהפך לבחי׳ אחד כמו לעבדו שכם אחד43 וכמ״ש במ״א)
And this is also “And I have given you one shechem (portion)”: to make, from the level of shechem, which means shoulder and back, as in “upon the shoulder (shechem) of both of them,” [that it be] turned into the level of one, as in “to serve Him with one shoulder (shechem echad),” as is written elsewhere.)
It adds that Yaakov’s gift to Yosef of “one shechem” uses a word for shoulder or back: the back is turned into oneness, as in Zephaniah’s “to serve Him with one shoulder.”
אך גילוי זה עלינו הוא בבחי׳ מקיף למעלה מעלה מבחינת השגת הנבראים. וזהו ה׳ צלך על יד ימינך בבחי׳ צל ומקיף והוא למעלה מעלה מעל יד ימינך
But this revelation upon us is in the manner of an encompassing light (makif), far above the level of the comprehension of created beings. And this is “Havayah is your shade upon your right hand”: in the manner of shade and an encompassing light; and it is far above, over “your right hand.”
But the revelation of Sukkos is an encompassing light (makif), too high for creatures to grasp inwardly. The psalm “Havayah is your shade upon your right hand” fits this: shade is an encompassing presence, and it is “upon,” above, your right hand.
פי׳ יד ימינך היינו האהבה הטבעית שבאדם ואהבה העליונה שורה על האהבה הטבעית זו בבחי׳ מקיף שאינה יכולה להתלבש בבחינת אהבה טבעית זו של האדם שאין אהבה הטבעית יכולה להגבילה.
Meaning: “your right hand” is the natural love in a person; and the supernal love rests upon this natural love in the manner of an encompassing light, for it cannot be clothed within this natural love of the person, since the natural love cannot contain it.
“Your right hand” is a person’s natural love for G‑d. G‑d’s love rests on it as a surrounding light, because a limited human love cannot contain it.
אך מ״מ פעולת המקיף ליתן כח ועוז באהבה טבעית שבנפש האדם (ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה ביום השמיני44 שילח)
Nevertheless, the effect of the encompassing light is to give strength and power to the natural love in a person’s soul (see also what is written on this in the discourse beginning “On the eighth day he sent away”),
Yet the surrounding light still acts: it strengthens the natural love in the soul. The text refers to the discourse “On the eighth day he sent away the people.”
שיהיה אתערותא דלעילא תלוי באתערותא דלתתא בכל השנה. וזהו פעולת חג הסוכות על כל השנה בכללה:4546474849505152
so that the arousal from above will depend on the arousal from below throughout the year. And this is the effect of the festival of Sukkos on the entire year as a whole.
This strengthening lets our deeds draw down a response from above all year round. That is what Sukkos gives to the whole year.
This long section explains teshuvah through the parable of the returning son: it reaches the innermost delight, revealed on Yom Kippur through the “left hand” of feeling far, and then on Sukkos as the “right hand’s” encompassing embrace, which empowers the natural love, and so our deeds, for the whole year.
The two delights correspond to direct and returning light, Chesed and Gevurah; teshuvah reaches the inner core of delight, the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy, which the maamar identifies with “asher nishbata” and the “head.” Sukkos gives this as a makif, an encompassing light, which Shemini Atzeres will draw inward. The “Thirteen Attributes of Micah” are the thirteen phrases of mercy counted in Micah 7:18–20, which opens “Who is a G‑d like You, who bears iniquity and passes over transgression”; they are distinct from the thirteen revealed to Moshe. That passage ends “which You swore to our fathers from days of old,” so the maamar reads the oath of its verse as the inner delight that teshuvah draws down, deeper than the delight of the mitzvos.
TermsShalomSha’ashu’imOr chozerMerirus+38
- Shalom שלום explained hereHere, “peace, peace, to the far and the near”: supernal delight revealed to the ba’al teshuvah, a son returning from afar, and to the near through the King’s commands.
וזהו שלום שלום לרחוק ולקרוב שיש ב׳ בחי׳ בשלום אחד הוא גילוי תענוג העליון לרחוק הוא בעל תשובה
- Sha’ashu’im שעשועים
- Or chozer אור חוזר
- Merirus מרירות
- Oz vesushiyah עוז ותושיה
- Mayim chaim מים חיים
- Ahavah mesuteres אהבה מסותרת
- Baal teshuvah בעל תשובה
- Thirteen Attributes of Mercy י״ג מדות הרחמים
- Mazal מזל
- Olam HaBa עולם הבא
- Yaakov and Yisrael יעקב וישראל
- Korbanos קרבנות
- Richuk makom ריחוק מקום
- Panim and achor פנים ואחור
- Mesirus nefesh מסירות נפש
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Chitzoniyus חיצוניות
- Simchah שמחה
- Tzaddik צדיק
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Gevurah גבורה
- Hasagah השגה
- Olam HaZeh עולם הזה
- Teshuvah תשובה
- Berachah ברכה
- Taanug תענוג
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Osiyos אותיות
- Chesed חסד
- Pnimiyus פנימיות
- Hiskallelus התכללות
- Ratzon רצון
- Middos מדות
Also NeshamahHislabshusBittulHavayahOr Ein SofTorah and mitzvosHaalaah vehamshachahTorah
Marei mekomos
- 1כי אבי ואמי עזבוני · Psalms 27:10
- 2שלום שלום לרחוק ולקרוב · Isaiah 57:19
- 3מרחוק ה׳ נראה לי · Jeremiah 31:3
- 4בזח״א (ד״ו ע״א) · נעתק באוה״ת ויקרא כרך ב ע׳ תרסא.
- 5לרחוק כד״א מרחוק ה׳ נראה לי · Zohar, Introduction 12:84–92
- 6וע״ש במק״מ ובהרמ״ז · מבואר ונתבאר באוה״ת ויקרא כרך ב ע׳ תרסד.
- 7בד״ה החלצו מאתכם · לעיל מטות פו, ב.
- 8או יחזיק במעוזי יעשה שלום לי שלום יעשה לי · Isaiah 27:5
- 9שני שלומות שלום למעלה ושלום למטה · Bamidbar Rabbah 13:16
- 10כי הנני מושיעך מרחוק · Jeremiah 46:27
- 11כי הנני מושיעך מרחוק · Zohar, Vayikra 49:342–51:352
- 12אחכמה והיא רחוקה ממני · Ecclesiastes 7:23
- 13אחכמה והיא רחוקה ממני · Bamidbar Rabbah 19:3
- 14רבות פ׳ חקת · פי״ט, ג.
- 15סד״ה כי המצוה הזאת · ראה לעיל מה, ג. ובסה״מ תקס״ה ח״ב ע׳ תתעט.
- 16בזח״ב (ויקהל דר״ז ע״א) · ראה ספר החקירה עז, א. נזכר לעיל פ׳ בחקותי מז, ב. נא, ג.
- 17ברוך כבוד ה׳ ממקומו · יחזקאל (ג, יג).
- 18ברוך כבוד ה׳ ממקומו וכתיב הנה מקום אתי אתר דלא אתגליא · Zohar, Vayakhel 18:238–246
- 19הנה מקום אתי · Exodus 33:21
- 20
- 21שמאל דוחה · Sotah 47a:6–7
- 22ויצעקו אל בצר להם · Psalms 107:6
- 23יוכ״פ אין בו לא אכילה ושתיה · Yoma 73b:14–15
- 24
- 25גנוחי גנח ילולי יליל · Rosh Hashanah 33b:10
- 26ממעמקים קראתיך · Psalms 136:1
- 27ממעמקים קראתיך · Psalms 130:1
- 28לרחוק שנעשה קרוב · Berakhot 34b:17–18
- 29שאמר ונעשה רצונו · ראה ספרי במדבר טו, ז. כח, ח.
- 30
- 31בשעה שישראל עונין אמן יהא . . הקב״ה מנענע בראשו · Berakhot 3a:14
- 32ע״פ מאמר הזח״ג קרח (קע״ח ב׳) · ראה ביאוה״ז לאדה״א צה, א. ואילך.
- 33
- 34דינא לא אשתכח בעלמא · Zohar, Korach 8:37–41
- 35ועיין עוד מענין שמאלו תחת לראשי · באוה״ת שה״ש כרך א ע׳ רלג מציין: ”ובד״ה ביום השמיני עצרת דרוש השני ושם נסמן מאמרי הזהר המדברים מזה”. וראה שם ע׳ רלח-רמ שמביא מאמרי הזהר הנזכרים ומעתיק לשונם.
- 36ישמח ישראל בעושיו · Psalms 149:2
- 37כי פנו אלי עורף · Jeremiah 2:27
- 38וירא ישראל את היד הגדולה · Exodus 14:31
- 39בד״ה בפ׳ נסכים · לעיל פ׳ שלח מ, ד ואילך.
- 40ידך בעורף אויביך · Genesis 49:8
- 41ואני נתתי לך שכם אחד · Genesis 48:22
- 42על שכם שניהם · Genesis 9:23
- 43לעבדו שכם אחד · Zephaniah 3:9
- 44
- 45במקום שבע״ת עומדים · Berakhot 34b:22–23
- 46לפני ה׳ תטהרו · Leviticus 16:30
- 47בי״ג מדה״ר דמיכה · Micah 7:18
- 48בד״ה אני ה׳ אלקיכם · לעיל פ׳ שלח.
- 49ישמח ה׳ במעשיו · Psalms 104:31
- 50
- 51
- 52
Torah study every day ¶12–14
5. And in a particular way, each day, this is the matter of Torah study; and of this they said, “Study is great, for it leads to action.”
Section 5: what Sukkos gives for the whole year, Torah study gives each day. This returns to the opening question of why “study is great, for it leads to action.”
והענין דכתיב ואשים דברי בפיך ובצל ידי כסיתיך2 שמן התורה נעשה בחינת סוכה בחינת צל שמהבל הדבור נעשה מקיף לנשמה והוא בחי׳ מוצא פי הוי׳
The explanation: it is written, “And I have put My words in your mouth, and in the shade of My hand I have covered you”: from the Torah is made the level of a sukkah, the level of shade; for from the breath of speech an encompassing light (makif) is made for the soul. And this is the level of “what comes out of the mouth of Havayah”;
Isaiah’s verse links G‑d’s words in our mouth with the shade of His hand. Words of Torah spoken aloud form a “sukkah,” a shade: an encompassing light (makif) around the soul, like the sukkah’s covering.
כי לא על הלחם לבדו3 שהוא בחי׳ תורה בעצמה יחיה האדם כי על כל מוצא פי הוי׳ שהוא ע״י מוצאיהם בהבל הפה שמזה נעשה מקיף לנשמה
for “not by bread alone,” which is the level of the Torah itself, “does man live, but by everything that comes out of the mouth of Havayah,” which is through uttering them with the breath of the mouth, from which an encompassing light is made for the soul.
“Not by bread alone does man live”: bread stands for the Torah’s content itself, while “what comes out of the mouth of Havayah” is the Torah as it is uttered. The breath of spoken Torah is what forms the soul’s encompassing light.
(ועמ״ש סד״ה וארשתיך לי4 ובזח״א [ובזהר חלק א]) (בראשית דף ד׳ ע״ב) ע״פ ואשים דברי בפיך5 ובפי׳ הרמ״ז [הרב משה זכות] שם והוא הנותן כח ועוז לאתערותא דלתתא במעשה המצות שיהי׳ [שיהיה] תלוי בזה אתערותא דלעילא.
(See also what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “And I will betroth you to Me,” and in Zohar, vol. 1) (Bereishis, folio 4b), on the verse “And I have put My words in your mouth,” and in the commentary of the Ramaz there. And this is what gives strength and power to the arousal from below in the performance of the mitzvos, so that the arousal from above will depend on it.
The Zohar (1:4b) on “I have put My words in your mouth” teaches that every new insight of Torah a person speaks rises before G‑d and forms a new firmament; the Ramaz comments there. This encompassing light is what empowers our mitzvos to draw a response from above.
¶5 This is the explanation promised in paragraph 5.
וזהו גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה פי׳ שהתלמוד שלומד בהבל הפה שאפילו לומד בענין שאינו צריך למעשה. כגון סדר קדשים וזבחים ומנחות
And this is “Study is great, for it leads to action.” Meaning: the study that one studies with the breath of the mouth, even when one studies a subject that is not needed for practice, such as the order of Kodashim, [the tractates] Zevachim and Menachos;
So “study leads to action” does not mean only that study teaches us what to do: spoken study has value even when the subject has no practical use, such as the laws of sacrifices and meal-offerings in the order of Kodashim, which cannot be practised today.
ואפילו בענינים הנוגעים למעשה יש כמה דברים שאין צריך ללמדם בתוך הגמרא.
and even in matters relevant to practice, there are several things that one need not study within the Gemara,
Even for practical laws, much of the Gemara’s discussion is not needed just to know what to do.
The paragraph applies the idea of Sukkos to daily Torah study: spoken Torah forms an encompassing light for the soul, which gives the mitzvos their power, so study matters even when it has no practical outcome.
The sukkah and the “shade” of Torah both belong to makif, encompassing light; this links the daily study of Torah with the yearly gift of Sukkos described in the previous section.
TermsOz vesushiyahIsarusa dile’eilaIsarusa dilesataOr Makif+5
- Oz vesushiyah עוז ותושיה
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Dibbur elyon דבור עליון
Marei mekomos
- 1גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה · Kiddushin 40b:8–9
- 2ואשים דברי בפיך ובצל ידי כסיתיך · Isaiah 51:16
- 3כי לא על הלחם לבדו · Deuteronomy 8:3
- 4וארשתיך לי · Hosea 2:21
- 5ובזח״א) (בראשית דף ד׳ ע״ב) ע״פ ואשים דברי בפיך · Zohar, Introduction 10:56–11:64
13ובפרט כי כעת יש קיצור דינים בשולחן ערוך והוא ג״כ גילוי רצון העליון הנוגע למעשה אף על פי כן צריך ללמוד הגמרא
especially since now there is a summary of the laws in the Shulchan Aruch, which is also a revelation of the supernal will relevant to practice; nevertheless one must study the Gemara,
Today the practical laws are summarized in the Shulchan Aruch, the code of Jewish law, which also expresses G‑d’s will for practice. Yet one must still study the Gemara.
כי אין הענין בשביל שנוגע למעשה אלא בשביל שמוציא בפה דברי תורה שמזה נעשה מקיף לנשמה להיות נמשך עונג העליון
for the point is not that it is relevant to practice, but that one utters words of Torah with the mouth, from which an encompassing light is made for the soul, so that the supernal delight is drawn down.
The purpose is not only practical knowledge but the speaking of Torah itself, which forms the soul’s encompassing light and draws down G‑d’s delight.
והוא בבחינת התורה כמ״ש ואהיה שעשועים יום יום1 פי׳ יום יום תורה שבכתב ותורה שבעל פה הם בחי׳ שעשועים אצלו ית׳ שהוא בחינת עונג העליון ותענוג הזה נמשך למטה כמ״ש ושעשועי את בני האדם2
And this is in the level of the Torah, as it is written, “And I was [His] delight day [by] day.” Meaning: “day [by] day” is the Written Torah and the Oral Torah, which are the level of delights before Him, may He be blessed, which is the level of the supernal delight; and this delight is drawn down below, as it is written, “And My delights are with the children of men.”
In Proverbs the Torah says, “I was His delight day by day, … and My delights are with the children of men.” The “two days” are the Written and Oral Torah, G‑d’s delight, and that delight comes down to people through their study.
(וזהו ענין שמביא לידי מעשה דר״ל [דרוצה לומר] שנותן כח ועוז במעשה המצות ואתעדל״ת [ואתערותא דלתתא] שיהי׳ [שיהיה] נמשך עי״ז אתערותא דלעילא שהכח לזה נמשך מבחי׳ עונג העליון כנ״ל והוא בחינת התורה שנאמר בה ואהיה שעשועים כו׳.
(And this is the meaning of “that leads to action”: that is to say, that it gives strength and power in the performance of the mitzvos and the arousal from below, so that through it an arousal from above will be drawn down; for the power for this is drawn from the level of the supernal delight, as mentioned above, which is the level of the Torah, of which it is said, “And I was [His] delight,” etc.
This is how study “leads to action”: it gives the mitzvos their power to draw a response from above, since that power comes from G‑d’s delight, which is the Torah.
וגם כי ב׳ בחינות שלום הנ״ל דלרחוק ולקרוב הם נמשכים גם כן על ידי עסק התורה כמאמר רז״ל [רבותינו זכרונם לברכה]) (סנהדרין דצ״ט ע״ב) כל העוסק בתורה משים שלום בפמליא של מעלה ובפמליא3 של מטה שנאמר או יחזיק במעוזי יעשה שלום לי שלום יעשה לי4
And also, the two levels of peace mentioned above, “to the far and to the near,” are also drawn down through engaging in Torah, as in the saying of our Sages, of blessed memory) (Sanhedrin, folio 99b): “Whoever engages in Torah makes peace in the household above and in the household below, as it is said, ‘Or let him take hold of My strength, [that] he may make peace with Me; peace he shall make with Me.’”
Torah study also brings the two kinds of peace, far and near: the Talmud says that one who engages in Torah for its own sake (lishmah, a condition the maamar’s quotation leaves out) makes peace in the household above and the household below, and proves it from Isaiah’s doubled “peace.”
וכנ״ל ג״כ בשם מדרש רבה נשא פי״ג5 וכבר נתבאר ששני בחינות שלום דפמליא של מעלה ושל מטה היינו ענין שלום שלום לרחוק ולקרוב
And as [cited] above also in the name of the Midrash Rabbah, Naso, section 13. And it has already been explained that the two levels of peace, of the household above and [the household] below, are the matter of “Peace, peace, to the far and to the near.”
The Midrash on Naso, cited earlier, teaches the same, and these two peaces are the “far” and the “near” explained earlier.
ויובן זה יותר עם מ״ש ע״פ זאת חקת התורה6 שהוא ענין אותיות החקיקה שלמעלה עדיין מבחינת תורה שבכתב ועל זה נאמר אמרתי אחכמה והיא רחוקה ממני7 כי היא בבחינת חכמה סתימאה.
And this will be understood further with what is written on the verse “This is the statute (chukas) of the Torah”: it is the matter of the engraved letters (chakikah), which are higher still than the level of the Written Torah; and of this it is said, “I said, I will become wise, but it is far from me,” for it is in the level of the hidden wisdom (Chochmah Stima’ah).
The discourse on “This is the statute (chukas) of the Torah” reads chukah as chakikah, engraving: letters engraved above, in a hidden wisdom beyond even the Written Torah. That is the wisdom Shlomo called “far from me.”
The paragraph explains why Gemara must be studied even with a practical code available: spoken Torah draws down G‑d’s delight, empowers the mitzvos, and brings both kinds of peace, rooted in a hidden wisdom above the Written Torah.
Engraved letters (chakikah), unlike written ones, are not separate from their material; they stand for Torah as it is one with the hidden wisdom (Chochmah Stima’ah) above.
TermsSha’ashu’imOsiyos hachakikahOz vesushiyahHamtakah+15
- Sha’ashu’im שעשועים
- Osiyos hachakikah אותיות החקיקה
- Oz vesushiyah עוז ותושיה
- Hamtakah דינים והמתקתם
- Hidden brain מוחא סתימאה
- Shalom שלום
- Richuk makom ריחוק מקום
- Torah shebiksav and Torah shebe’al peh תורה שבכתב ותורה שבעל פה
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Supernal Will רצון העליון
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Taanug תענוג
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Osiyos אותיות
- Ratzon רצון
Marei mekomos
- 1ואהיה שעשועים יום יום · Proverbs 8:30
- 2ושעשועי את בני האדם · Proverbs 8:31
- 3
- 4או יחזיק במעוזי יעשה שלום לי שלום יעשה לי · Isaiah 27:5
- 5בשם מדרש רבה נשא פי״ג · Bamidbar Rabbah 13:16
- 6זאת חקת התורה · Numbers 19:2
- 7אמרתי אחכמה והיא רחוקה ממני · Ecclesiastes 7:23
14ומשם ממשיכים האור בתורה שבכתב ותורה שבעל פה הרי זהו ג״כ בבחי׳ שלום לרחוק שממשיך מבחינת והיא רחוקה
And from there one draws down the light into the Written Torah and the Oral Torah; this too is in the level of “peace to the far,” for one draws down from the level of “but it is far,”
From that hidden wisdom light is drawn into the Written and Oral Torah. This is itself “peace to the far”: drawing from the level that is “far.”
והיינו שהיא עונג עליון בחינת ואהיה שעשועים1 ומשם ממשיכים שיהי׳ [שיהיה] ושעשועי את בני אדם2 והיינו ע״י שלום ולקרוב.
that is, that it is the supernal delight, the level of “And I was [His] delight”; and from there one draws down that there be “And My delights are with the children of men,” and this is through “peace … and to the near.”
That far level is G‑d’s delight, “I was His delight”; drawing it down so that “My delights are with the children of men” is “peace to the near.” So Torah study brings both kinds of peace.
The paragraph maps the two kinds of peace onto Torah study: drawing from the hidden, “far” delight above, and bringing it down to people, “the near.”
TermsSha’ashu’imShalomRichuk makomTorah shebiksav and Torah shebe’al peh+2
- Sha’ashu’im שעשועים
- Shalom שלום
- Richuk makom ריחוק מקום
- Torah shebiksav and Torah shebe’al peh תורה שבכתב ותורה שבעל פה
- Taanug תענוג
Also Torah
Marei mekomos
- 1ואהיה שעשועים · Proverbs 8:30
- 2ושעשועי את בני אדם · Proverbs 8:31
Study, action and Shemini Atzeres ¶15
15והנה בגמרא ספ״ק [סוף פרק קמא] דקדושין1 איכא מ״ד [מאן דאמר] מעשה גדול2 והיינו משום שהמעשה זהו אתעדל״ת [אתערותא דלתתא] של האדם שטורח את עצמו במעשה רב. משא״כ התורה הוא בחינת דיבור והוא בחי׳ אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא] שלמעלה מאתעדל״ת [מאתערותא דלתתא] כמ״ש בד״ה ואתחנן.
Now, in the Gemara at the end of the first chapter of Kiddushin, there is one who says that action is greater; this is because action is a person’s arousal from below, in which he exerts himself in substantial action. This is not so with Torah, which is the level of speech, and it is the level of an arousal from above, which is higher than an arousal from below, as is written in the discourse beginning “And I pleaded.”
Back to the Talmud’s debate. The view that action is greater holds that action is our own effort, an arousal from below, while Torah, which is speech, belongs to the arousal from above, higher than anything we initiate.
וכיון שהמעשה הוא מעשי ידי האדם ופעולתו ואתעדל״ת [ואתערותא דלתתא] שלו הרי עד״מ האדם מתפאר א״ע [את עצמו] שלו אף בבחי׳ רגל שבו משא״כ בשל אחרים אינו מתפאר אפילו ביד שהיא חשובה יותר כיון שאינו שלו
And since action is the work of a person’s hands, his own doing and his own arousal from below, then, by way of analogy, a person takes pride in what is his own, even in the level of the foot in him; whereas in what belongs to others he does not take pride, even in a hand, which is more important, since it is not his.
An analogy: a person is proud of what is his own, even something as humble as his foot, but not of what belongs to someone else, even a more important limb like a hand, since it is not his.
וכך לערך פד, גזה המעשה זהו אתעדל״ת [אתערותא דלתתא] ממש משא״כ התורה עיקרה מתנה מלמעלה3
And in this proportion, action is truly an arousal from below, whereas the Torah is essentially a gift from above.
So action, being truly our own effort, is “ours,” while the Torah is essentially a gift from above; a Kehot note cites the Midrash that Moshe received the Torah as a gift (Shemos Rabbah 41:6).
ועיין בזח״ב [בזהר חלק ב׳] (תרומה קכ״ח א׳) שלכן על עסק התורה נאמר לכו שברו ואכלו כו׳ בלא כסף ובלא מחיר יין וחלב4 משא״כ בעסק המצות צ״ל באגר שלים5 דוקא ע״ש ע״כ אמר מעשה גדול.
And see Zohar, vol. 2 (Terumah, 128a), that therefore concerning engaging in Torah it is said, “Come, buy and eat, etc., without money and without price, wine and milk,” whereas in engaging in the mitzvos it must be specifically “for full payment”; see there. Therefore he said, “Action is greater.”
The Zohar on Terumah explains that whoever wishes may acquire the Torah freely, as Isaiah says, “without money and without price,” but a mitzvah deed must be acquired “for full payment.” For this reason one view says action is greater: it is truly ours.
ואעפ״כ [ואף על פי כן] איכא למ״ד [למאן דאמר] לימוד גדול היינו אפילו מצד עצמו כיון שאדרבה הוא אתערותא דלעילא מבחינה שאין אתעדל״ת [אתערותא דלתתא] של מעשה המצות מגעת שם
And nevertheless there is one who says that study is greater, that is, even in its own right; since, on the contrary, it is an arousal from above, from a level which the arousal from below of performing the mitzvos does not reach.
The other view holds that study is greater in itself, precisely because it is an arousal from above reaching a level that no human deed can reach.
ועוד כי היא ג״כ בחינת עסק במחשבה ודיבור של האדם וגם עקימת שפתיו6 הוי מעשה רק שאינו מעשה רב כמעשה ממש עיין בגמרא פ״ז [פרק ז׳] דב״מ [דבבא מציעא] (דף צ׳ סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב])
And further, because it is also a level of engagement of a person’s thought and speech, and also “the moving of his lips is an action,” only it is not substantial action like actual action; see the Gemara, chapter 7 of Bava Metzia (folio 90, end of side b),
Study is also a deed of a sort: it involves a person’s thought and speech, and the Talmud says “moving the lips counts as an action,” though not a full physical action. In Likkutei Torah, Ha’azinu, the Alter Rebbe applies this to Torah study, whose chief mitzvah is in speech.
ובחידושי הרשב״א [הרבי שלמה בן אדרת] (רפ״ג [ריש פרק ג׳] דשבועות דכ״א ע״א) ועיין בתוספות שם ושם נמנו וגמרו דלימוד גדול שמביא לידי מעשה דהיינו שגם הכח שבמעשה המצות לעורר אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא] נמשך ע״י עסק התורה כנ״ל
and the Chiddushei HaRashba (beginning of chapter 3 of Shevuos, folio 21a), and see the Tosafos there. And there they took a vote and concluded that study is greater, for it leads to action; that is, that even the power in the performance of the mitzvos to arouse an arousal from above is drawn through engaging in Torah, as mentioned above.
The Talmud’s conclusion, by vote, is that study is greater because it leads to action; the text also cites the novellae of the Rashba (R. Shlomo ben Aderes) and Tosafos on Shevuos. As explained, this means that the very power of the mitzvos to arouse a response from above comes through Torah study.
¶2 This answers the question from paragraph 2.
וזהו ביום השמיני עצרת תהיה לכם7 פי׳ ביום השמיני מדרגה השמינית ממטה למעלה בחינת בינה דהיינו ע״י בחי׳ התבוננות
And this is “On the eighth day, there shall be an atzeres for you.” Meaning: “on the eighth day” is the eighth level from below upward, the level of Binah, that is, through the level of contemplation;
Now the opening verse is explained. The “eighth day” is the eighth level counting upward from Malchus, which is Binah, understanding: contemplation.
כמו שמלמעלה למטה כל מה שהוא למטה הוא בחינת אין וכלא חשיב נגד מה שלמעלה כך מלמטה למעלה יהיה כאין ואפס והוא בחינת מבין דבר מתוך דבר8 (עמ״ש בד״ה השמים כסאי)
just as from above to below, whatever is below is the level of ayin and considered as nothing in relation to what is above, so from below to above one will be as nothing and naught; and this is the level of understanding one thing from another. (See what is written in the discourse beginning “The heavens are My throne.”)
Just as from above everything below is as nothing, so through contemplation a person, looking upward, comes to feel himself as nothing. Binah is defined as “understanding one thing from another,” deriving deeper insight through reflection.
וכן בינה ליבא910 היא בחי׳ שמחת הלב זמן שמחתנו שמתקרבים יחד ב׳ השמחות ישמח ה׳ במעשיו וישמח ישראל בעושיו11
And likewise “Binah is the heart”: it is the level of the joy of the heart, “the season of our rejoicing,” when the two joys come close together, “Havayah will rejoice in His works” and “Israel will rejoice in its Maker”;
The Tikkunei Zohar says “Binah is the heart,” and so it is the joy of the heart: “the season of our rejoicing,” when Havayah’s joy in His works and Israel’s joy in its Maker come together.
והיינו על ידי התורה כי לכן נקרא שמחת תורה שהתורה היא עונג עליון ועונג תחתון כנ״ל.
and this is through the Torah; for this is why it is called Simchas Torah, for the Torah is supernal delight and lower delight, as mentioned above.
These joys meet through the Torah; that is why the day is called Simchas Torah, since the Torah is both G‑d’s delight above and ours below.
ואזי עצרת תהיה לכם כתרגומו כנישין תהי לכון פי׳ שיתאסף ויתקבץ יחד בחינת המקיף המתפשט וחופף מלמעלה בבחינת אין סוף וקץ
And then “there shall be an atzeres for you,” as the Targum renders it, “kenishin tehei lechon” (there shall be a gathering for you). Meaning: that the level of the encompassing light, which spreads and hovers from above in the manner of without end or limit, is gathered and collected together,
“Atzeres” is rendered by the Targum as “a gathering.” What is gathered is the encompassing light of Sukkos, which hovered, unlimited, above us.
להיות מוגבל בתוך נפשות בני ישראל ולהיות בבחינת פנימיות כדי שאח״כ יהיה בחי׳ המצות באתעדל״ת [באתערותא דלתתא] אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא] כו׳ כנ״ל
to be contained within the souls of Israel and to be in the manner of an inner [light], so that afterwards there will be the level of the mitzvos, [such that] through the arousal from below [there is] an arousal from above, etc., as mentioned above.
On Shemini Atzeres it is gathered in and contained within the souls of Israel as an inner light. That inward light then empowers the mitzvos all year, so that our deeds bring a response from above.
(ועיין מענין ביום השמיני עצרת12 ברבות בקהלת בפסוק תן חלק לשבעה וגם לשמונה13 ובפסוק ביום טובה היה בטוב14 ובשיר השירים בפסוק מה יפו פעמיך בנעלים15 ובפרשת נשא פרשה יו״ד גבי ויאמר מנוח כו׳ נעצרה נא אותך.1617
(See on the matter of “On the eighth day, an atzeres” in the Midrash Rabbah on Koheles, on the verse “Give a portion to seven and also to eight,” and on the verse “On the day of good, be in good”; and on Shir HaShirim, on the verse “How beautiful are your steps in sandals”; and on Parshas Naso, section 10, regarding “And Manoach said,” etc., “Let us detain (ne’etzrah) you.”
The text lists Midrashic passages on Shemini Atzeres, such as the verse “give a portion to seven and also to eight” and Manoach’s request to “detain” the angel, which the Midrash links to the festival called atzeres. A Kehot note says that most of these passages are copied out in the Tzemach Tzedek’s Or HaTorah.
וס״פ פנחס. ועמ״ש בד״ה למנצח על השמינית.18 ומ״ש במ״א בענין שבעתים כאור שבעת הימים19 ועיין בזהר ח״ג [חלק ג׳] בלק) (קפ״ה ב׳) בענין מי יעמוד ובפי׳ הרמ״ז [הרב משה זכות] שם:202122
And at the end of Parshas Pinchas. See also what is written in the discourse beginning “For the conductor, on the Sheminis [the eighth],” and what is written elsewhere on the matter of “sevenfold, like the light of the seven days.” And see Zohar, vol. 3, Balak) (185b), on the matter of “Who shall stand,” and in the commentary of the Ramaz there.
Further references follow: the Midrash at the end of Pinchas, discourses on “the Sheminis” (the eighth) and on “the light of the seven days,” and a Zohar passage on Balak, on “who (mi) shall stand,” with the Ramaz’s commentary.
The paragraph resolves the opening question of study and action, then explains the festival: on Shemini Atzeres, through contemplation and the joy of Torah, the encompassing light of Sukkos is gathered inward into the soul, to empower the mitzvos all year.
Counting up from Malchus, Binah is the eighth Sefirah; Binah as “the heart” links contemplation with joy, and the gathering (atzeres) turns makif into pnimiyus.
TermsAtzeresIsarusa dilesataOr shivas hayamimKiddushin / erusin and nisuin+11
- Atzeres עצרת explained hereFollowing the Targum, “a gathering shall be for you”: the encompassing light, spread over them without end or limit, is gathered together to be contained within the souls of Israel and become inward, so that afterwards the mitzvos, an arousal from below, can draw an arousal from above.
ואזי עצרת תהיה לכם כתרגומו כנישין תהי לכון פי׳ שיתאסף ויתקבץ יחד בחינת המקיף
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא explained hereHere, the toil of a mitzvah’s deed is truly one’s own arousal from below, while Torah, chiefly a gift, is an arousal from above reaching where deeds cannot.
המעשה זהו אתעדל״ת ממש משא״כ התורה עיקרה מתנה מלמעלה
- Or shivas hayamim אור שבעת הימים
- Kiddushin / erusin and nisuin קדושין ונשואין
- Mayin nukvin and mayin duchrin מיין נוקבין ומיין דוכרין (מ״ן ומ״ד)
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Simchah שמחה
- Hisbonenus התבוננות
- Taanug תענוג
- Binah בינה
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Ein Sof אין סוף
- Pnimiyus פנימיות
Marei mekomos
- 1בגמרא ספ״ק דקדושין · מ, ב. בארוכה באוה״ת פ׳ ואתחנן ע׳ רמא ואילך.
- 2מעשה גדול · Kiddushin 40b:8
- 3התורה עיקרה מתנה מלמעלה · Shemot Rabbah 41:6
- 4לכו שברו . . וחלב · Isaiah 55:1
- 5באגר שלים · Zohar, Terumah 5:30–6:38
- 6עקימת שפתי הוה מעשה · Bava Metzia 90b:13–14
- 7ביום השמיני עצרת תהיה לכם · Numbers 29:35
- 8מבין דבר מתוך דבר · Chagigah 14a:12
- 9בינה ליבא · ת״ז בהקדמה (פתח אלי׳).
- 10בינה ליבא · Tikkunei Zohar 17a:17–19
- 11וישמח ישראל בעושיו · Psalms 149:2
- 12ועיין מענין ביום השמיני עצרת · רוב המ״מ נעתקו באוה״ת כאן ע׳ א׳תשע ואילך.
- 13תן חלק לשבעה וגם לשמונה · Ecclesiastes 11:2
- 14ביום טובה היה בטוב · Ecclesiastes 7:14
- 15
- 16נעצרה נא אותך · Bamidbar Rabbah 10:5
- 17נעצרה נא אותך · Judges 13:15
- 18למנצח על השמינית · Psalms 6:1
- 19שבעתים כאור שבעת הימים · Isaiah 30:26
- 20נח״ר לפני שאמרתי ונעשה רצוני · ספרי במדבר כח, ח. וראה ג״כ טו, ז.
- 21
- 22ישמח ה׳ במעשיו · Psalms 104:31
Summary ¶16–20
16קיצור
Summary
Here begins the Kitzur, a short summary of the maamar’s main points in numbered sections.
The heading of the maamar’s summary.
(1) The meaning of “You will give truth to Yaakov” is [as in] “For Havayah is a G‑d of knowledges,” which includes two [kinds of] knowledge;
Summary of section 1: “truth to Yaakov” is the two “knowledges” of “a G‑d of knowledges,” the view from below and the view from above.
ושיהיה הגילוי למטה כמו למעלה זהו ואמת ה׳ לעולם ועז״נ [ועל זה נאמר] תתן אמת ליעקב ועיין מענין אמת3 ברבות פ׳ וישלח פ׳ פ״א4
and that the revelation be below as it is above: this is “And the truth of Havayah is le’olam,” and of this it is said, “You will give truth to Yaakov.” And see on the matter of truth in the Midrash Rabbah, Parshas Vayishlach, section 81.
The aim is that the view from above be revealed below just as it is above: that is “the truth of Havayah is le’olam,” revealed within the world. The Midrash the text cites teaches that the letters of emes (truth) are the first, middle and last of the alphabet, for G‑d says, “I am first and I am last.”
ומזה נמשך להיות חסד לאברהם היינו להיות באתערותא דלתתא נמשך אתערותא דלעילא זהו צדקה וחסד אשר עשה ה׳ עמנו
And from this is drawn [the level of] “kindness to Avraham,” that is, that through the arousal from below an arousal from above is drawn down; this is “the charity and kindness that G‑d has done with us.”
From truth comes “kindness to Avraham”: our deeds below draw kindness from above. The text calls this the charity and kindness G‑d has done with us.
ועמ״ש ע״פ אני ה׳ אלקיכם דפ׳ ציצית בענין פי׳ חסדי ה׳ לשון רבים ב׳ בחי׳ חסד ועמ״ש בד״ה בהעלותך את הנרות5 בענין בחי׳ אברהם ובחי׳ אהרן:67
See also what is written on the verse “I am Havayah your G‑d” in the section of tzitzis, on the meaning of “the kindnesses of Havayah” in the plural, two levels of kindness; and see what is written in the discourse beginning “When you light the lamps,” on the matter of the level of Avraham and the level of Aharon.
It refers to discourses on “the kindnesses of Havayah” in the plural, two kinds of kindness, and on the levels of Avraham and Aharon. In Likkutei Torah, Sh’lach, on “I am Havayah your G‑d,” the Alter Rebbe explains the two as the supernal “abundant kindness” to be revealed in the future and the kindness of Atzilus that serves as its vessel.
The summary of the first section: G‑d’s truth revealed below, from which flows the kindness drawn down by our deeds.
TermsChosamo shel HaKadosh Baruch Hu emesIsarusa dile’eilaTzedakahIsarusa dilesata+1
- Chosamo shel HaKadosh Baruch Hu emes חותמו של הקב״ה אמת
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Tzedakah צדקה
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Chesed חסד
Marei mekomos
- 1תתן אמת ליעקב · Micah 7:20
- 2כי אל דעות ה׳ · I Samuel 2:3
- 3מענין אמת · Bereshit Rabbah 81:2
- 4ברבות וישלח פ׳ פ״א · ”מהו אמת אמר ריש לקיש אלף ראשון [ברבות שלפנינו בראשון] של אותיות מ״ם באמצע תיו בסוף על שם אני ראשון ואני אחרון ומבלעדי אין אלקים” — אוה״ת ויחי שפט, א. וכ״ה גם באוה״ת כאן ע׳ א׳תשצז.
- 5בהעלותך את הנרות · Numbers 8:2
- 6ואמת ה׳ לעולם · Psalms 117:2
- 7אני ה׳ אלקיכם · Numbers 15:41
18(ב) והכח להיות אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא] תלוי באתעדל״ת [באתערותא דלתתא] זהו אשר נשבעת לאבותינו1 דהיינו מה שהבטיח נגד סדר ההשתלשלות.
(2) And the power for the arousal from above to depend on the arousal from below is “as You swore to our fathers,” that is, what He promised against the order of the chain of descending levels (hishtalshelus).
Summary of section 2: the power of our deeds to draw a response from above comes from G‑d’s oath to the fathers, a promise that goes against the ordered chain of descent.
והיינו מימי קדם קדמונו של עולם. מה שלמעלה מבחינת ימי עולם שהן בסדר השתלשלות. (וע׳ רבות אמור פכ״ט2 זח״ג [זהר חלק ג] פ׳ אחרי ס״ו ב׳3 נשא ק״ל ע״א4 קל״ד ב׳):
And this is “from the days of old,” [from] the Primordial One of the world: what is above the level of “the days of the world,” which are in the order of hishtalshelus. (See Midrash Rabbah, Emor, section 29; Zohar, vol. 3, Parshas Acharei, 66b; Naso, 130a, 134b.)
It comes from “the days of old,” the Primordial One, above “the days of the world,” which follow that ordered chain. The text cites the Midrash and the Zohar passages listed in section 2.
The summary of the second section: the oath to the fathers, from above the chain of descent, empowers our deeds.
TermsKadmono shel olamIsarusa dile’eilaIsarusa dilesataHishtalshelus
- Kadmono shel olam קדמונו של עולם
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
Marei mekomos
- 1אשר נשבעת לאבותינו · Micah 7:20
- 2וע׳ רבות אמור פכ״ט · Vayikra Rabbah 29:9
- 3זח״ג פ׳ אחרי ס״ו ב׳ · Zohar, Achrei Mot 29:182–31:193
- 4נשא ק״ל ע״א · Zohar, Idra Rabba 9:63–10:73
19(ג) וזהו אשר קב״ו [קדשנו במצותיו וצונו] אשר הוא עונג העליון ממנו נמשך וצונו צוותא והתקשרות להיות נמשך אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא] ע״ח [על ידי (צ״ל ע״י)] אתעדל״ת [אתערותא דלתתא]. ולכן יפה שעה אחת בתשובה ומע״ט [ומעשים טובים] בעוה״ז כו׳:
(3) And this is “asher kiddeshanu bemitzvosav” (who has sanctified us with His commandments): asher is the supernal delight, from which is drawn “vetzivanu” (and has commanded us), companionship and connection, so that an arousal from above be drawn down through an arousal from below. And therefore “One hour of teshuvah and good deeds in this world,” etc.
Summary of section 3: in the blessing over mitzvos, asher is G‑d’s delight and vetzivanu means connection; from that delight comes the bond by which our deeds draw a response from above. That is why an hour of good deeds here outweighs the World to Come.
(ד) וענין תשובה עד״מ שיש שני מיני תענוג לפני המלך האחד בעשיית המצות כמו נחת רוח לפני שאמרתי ונעשה רצוני עמ״ש בד״ה צו את בני ישראל ואמרת אליהם את קרבני.1
(4) And the matter of teshuvah: by way of analogy, there are two kinds of delight before the king. The first is in the carrying out of his commands, as in “It is a satisfaction before Me that I spoke and My will was done.” See what is written in the discourse beginning “Command the children of Israel and say to them, My offering.”
Summary of section 4: the king has two delights, the first in having his commands carried out, as the Sages say of the offerings that G‑d has satisfaction “that I spoke and My will was done.” The text refers to its discourse on the daily offering, “Command the children of Israel.”
And the second is when he sees his son coming from afar. And this is “Peace, peace, to the far and to the near,” and this is also the level of “he may make peace with Me; peace he shall make with Me”:
The second delight is in the son who returns from afar. These are the two kinds of peace, “to the far and to the near,” and the doubled “peace” in Isaiah.
that is, the union of yud-hei and the union of vav-hei. See what is written on the verse “These are the accounts of the Mishkan” and on the verse “And the number of the children of Israel shall be.”
The two peaces are also two unions of the letters of G‑d’s Name: yud with hei (the hidden, higher pair) and vav with hei (the revealed, lower pair). The text refers to its discourses on “These are the accounts of the Mishkan” and “And the number of the children of Israel.”
וזהו ענין שמאלו תחת לראשי6 שמר״ה [שמראש השנה] עד יוהכ״פ [יום הכפורים] שהוא בחי׳ לרחוק שנעשה קרוב בחי׳ תשובה
And this is the matter of “His left hand is under my head”: from Rosh Hashanah until Yom Kippur, which is the level of the far becoming near, the level of teshuvah.
The “left hand under my head” is the season from Rosh Hashanah to Yom Kippur, when the far becomes near through teshuvah.
ועי״ז כמ״כ [כמו כן] למעלה נמשך הבחי׳ מקיף עליון שלמעלה מהשתלשלות בחי׳ ימי קדם שלמעלה מימי עולם כמאמר המתנשא מימות עולם7 להיות מאיר בקירוב ע״ד ימי עולם
And through this, correspondingly above, there is drawn down the level of the supernal encompassing light, which is above hishtalshelus: the level of “the days of old,” which is above “the days of the world,” as in the saying, “Who is exalted from the days of the world”; [so that it] shine closely, in the manner of “the days of the world.”
Through this the encompassing light from above the ordered chain of worlds, “the days of old,” is drawn down. The morning prayer (the blessing Yotzer) praises G‑d “who is exalted from the days of the world” (in Iggeres HaKodesh the Alter Rebbe explains “the days of the world” as time itself); now this high light shines close, as within the world’s days.
וזהו דרשו ה׳ בהמצאו בהיותו קרוב
And this is “Seek Havayah when He can be found,” when He is near.
Isaiah’s “seek Havayah when He can be found … when He is near” refers to these days, which the Sages identify with the Ten Days of Teshuvah.
וגילוי עונג זה הוא בחי׳ שמן שמחתנו ישמח ה׳ במעשיו וישמח ישראל בעושיו8 ופעולת עונג זה העליון עם היותו בבחי׳ מקיף ליתן כח ועוז באהבה הטבעית שבנפש שיהיה אתערותא דלעילא תלוי באתערותא דלתתא
And the revelation of this delight is the level of “the season of our rejoicing,” “Havayah will rejoice in His works” and “Israel will rejoice in its Maker.” And the effect of this supernal delight, although it is in the manner of an encompassing light, is to give strength and power to the natural love in the soul, so that the arousal from above will depend on the arousal from below.
The revelation of this delight is the joy of Sukkos, when Havayah rejoices in His works and Israel in its Maker. This delight, though it remains an encompassing light, strengthens the natural love in the soul, so that our deeds draw a response from above.
וזהו אשר נשבעת לאבותינו מימי קדם9 וזהו ענין שבעת ימים דחג הסוכות להיות הוי״ה צלך:
And this is “as You swore to our fathers from the days of old.” And this is the matter of the seven days of the festival of Sukkos: that “Havayah is your shade.”
This is the oath to the fathers “from the days of old,” and it is the seven days of Sukkos, when “Havayah is your shade.”
(ה)10 ודרך פרט בכל יום הוא בחי׳ תורה דכתיב ואשים דברי בפיך ובצל ידי כסיתיך.11 וגם נאמר בה חצבה עמודיה שבעה1213 כמ״ש ברבות ר״פ שמיני14
(5) And in a particular way, each day, it is the level of Torah, as it is written, “And I have put My words in your mouth, and in the shade of My hand I have covered you.” And it is also said of it, “She has hewn out her seven pillars,” as is written in the Midrash Rabbah at the beginning of Parshas Shemini.
Summary of section 5: day by day, Torah study does the same, as G‑d’s words in our mouth form a shade. Proverbs says wisdom “has hewn out her seven pillars,” which the Midrash (Vayikra Rabbah 11:3) reads as the seven books of the Torah, counting Bamidbar as three.
ולכן גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה15 כי הוא מבחי׳ תענוג עליון שעשועים יום יום16 ע״כ הוא המביא לידי מעשה שנותן כח ועוז למעשה המצות שיהיה נמשך בהן ועל ידן האתעדל״ע [האתערותא דלעילא] וזהו או יחזיק במעוזי שנקרא עוז שהוא כח.1718
And therefore, “Study is great, for it leads to action,” for it is from the level of supernal delight, “delights day [by] day”; therefore it is what leads to action, for it gives strength and power to the performance of the mitzvos, so that the arousal from above be drawn down in them and through them. And this is “Or let him take hold of My strength (ma’uzi),” for it is called oz (might), which is power.
This is why study is great: it leads to action, because Torah comes from G‑d’s own delight, and so it gives the mitzvos their power to draw a response from above. Isaiah’s “take hold of My strength (ma’uzi)” alludes to this: oz, strength, is the power Torah gives.
The summary of sections 3–5: the delight behind the mitzvos, the deeper delight reached by teshuvah and revealed on Sukkos as an encompassing light, and Torah study as the daily source of power for the mitzvos.
The unions of yud-hei and vav-hei correspond to the higher and lower levels of the Name; the two kinds of peace, far and near, are mapped onto them.
TermsSha’ashu’imOsiyos hachakikahOz vesushiyahAhavah mesuteres+15
- Sha’ashu’im שעשועים
- Osiyos hachakikah אותיות החקיקה
- Oz vesushiyah עוז ותושיה
- Ahavah mesuteres אהבה מסותרת
- Shalom שלום
- Romemus רוממות
- Richuk makom ריחוק מקום
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Olam HaZeh עולם הזה
- Teshuvah תשובה
- Yichud יחוד
- Taanug תענוג
- Yud-hei and vav-hei י״ה ו״ה
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Hishtalshelus השתלשלות
Marei mekomos
- 1צו את בני ישראל ואמרת אליהם את קרבני · Numbers 28:2
- 2שלום שלום לרחוק ולקרוב · Isaiah 57:19
- 3יעשה שלום לי שלום יעשה לי · Isaiah 27:5
- 4אלה פקודי המשכן · Exodus 38:21
- 5והיה מספר בנ״י · Hosea 2:1
- 6שמאלו תחת לראשי · Song of Songs 2:6
- 7המתנשא מימות עולם · ברכת יוצר.
- 8וישמח ישראל בעושיו · Psalms 149:2
- 9אשר נשבעת לאבותינו מימי קדם · Micah 7:20
- 10הוי״ה צלך · Psalms 121:5
- 11ואשים דברי בפיך ובצל ידי כסיתיך · Isaiah 51:16
- 12חצבה עמודי׳ שבעה · Proverbs 9:1
- 13חצבה עמודיה שבעה · Vayikra Rabbah 11:3
- 14ברבות ר״פ שמיני · ”אלו שבעה ס״ת” — ראה אוה״ת בראשית כרך ד תרפג, א.
- 15גדול תלמוד שמביא לידי מעשה · Kiddushin 40b:8–9
- 16שעשועים יום יום · Proverbs 8:30
- 17דרשו ה׳ בהמצאו · Isaiah 55:6
- 18ישמח ה׳ במעשיו · Psalms 104:31
20והנה ביום השמיני מדרגה השמינית ממטה למעלה. הבחינה שיוכל להיות הגילוי למטה כמו למעלה בחי׳ ואמת ה׳ לעולם.
And now, “on the eighth day”: the eighth level from below upward, the level at which the revelation can be below as it is above, the level of “And the truth of Havayah is le’olam.”
The summary of the festival: the “eighth day” is the eighth level counting upward, Binah, the level at which the view from above can be revealed below, “the truth of Havayah le’olam.”
והוא שמחת תורה ושם מתחברים ב׳ השמחות דישמח ה׳ במעשיו וישמח ישראל בעושיו1 והיינו ע״י התורה שהיא אצלו ית׳ שעשועים ושעשועי את בני אדם2 לכן נקרא שמחת תורה.
And this is Simchas Torah, and there the two joys are joined, “Havayah will rejoice in His works” and “Israel will rejoice in its Maker”; and this is through the Torah, which before Him, may He be blessed, is “delights,” and “My delights are with the children of men.” Therefore it is called Simchas Torah.
That is Simchas Torah, when Havayah’s joy and Israel’s joy join through the Torah, which is G‑d’s delight and is shared with people.
ואזי עצרת תהיה לכם שיתאסף ויתקבץ האור מקיף להיות בבחי׳ פנימיות ע״ד יקוו המים אל מקום אחד345 ועד״ז נאמר מקוה ישראל6 ה׳ (ע׳ [עיין] זח״ בראשית י״ח א׳ ל״ג א׳)
And then “there shall be an atzeres for you”: that the encompassing light be gathered and collected together, to be in the manner of an inner light (pnimiyus), like “Let the waters be gathered to one place”; and in the same way it is said, “The mikveh (hope; also, gathering [of waters]) of Israel is Havayah.” (See Zohar, Bereishis, 18a, 33a.)
Then comes the atzeres, the gathering: the encompassing light is gathered inward, like the waters gathered into one place at creation. Jeremiah calls Havayah “the mikveh of Israel,” a word meaning both hope and a gathering of water; the Zohar passages cited read “to one place” as the point where all levels are gathered into one.
ולכן אומרים בשמע״צ [בשמיני עצרת] מוריד הגשם78 כדי שעי״ז יהיה בבחינת המצות באתעדל״ת [באתערותא דלתתא] אתעדל״ע [אתערותא דלעילא]:910
And therefore on Shemini Atzeres we say “He causes the rain to fall,” so that through this there will be, in the level of the mitzvos, through the arousal from below, an arousal from above.
This is why we begin to say “He causes the rain to fall” on Shemini Atzeres: so that, through the light now gathered within, the mitzvos all year will draw a response from above to our arousal from below.
The closing summary: on Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah the encompassing light of Sukkos is gathered inward, which is why we begin praying for rain, so that the mitzvos all year draw down a response from above.
The images of water run through the close: the waters “gathered to one place,” Israel’s mikveh, and the rain whose mention in the Amidah begins on this day.
TermsSha’ashu’imAtzeresIsarusa dile’eilaSimchah+5
- Sha’ashu’im שעשועים
- Atzeres עצרת
- Isarusa dile’eila אתערותא דלעילא
- Simchah שמחה
- Isarusa dilesata אתערותא דלתתא
- Or Makif אור מקיף
- Pnimiyus פנימיות
Marei mekomos
- 1וישמח ישראל בעושיו · Psalms 149:2
- 2ושעשועי את בני אדם · Proverbs 8:31
- 3יקוו המים אל מקום אחד · Genesis 1:9
- 4יקוו המים אל מקום אחד · Zohar, Bereshit 6:60–7:70
- 5יקוו המים אל מקום אחד · Zohar, Bereshit 39:373–384
- 6מקוה ישראל ה׳ · Jeremiah 17:13
- 7אומרים בשמע״צ מוריד הגשם · טוש״ע או״ח רסקי״ד. ועוד.
- 8אומרים בשמע״צ מוריד הגשם · Shulchan Arukh, Orach Chayim 114:1–2
- 9ואמת ה׳ לעולם · Psalms 117:2
- 10דישמח ה׳ במעשיו · Psalms 104:31
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
Each Rosh Chodesh the names of those learning here are brought to the Ohel. Add your name, and mark what you learn so it is counted.
In one’s avodah
Contemplate that before G‑d the world is nothing, and so “concede” to His truth in prayer; do the mitzvos knowing they reach G‑d’s own delight; in teshuvah, let the sense of being far bring you close; study Torah aloud every day, even topics with no practical use, since this gives the mitzvos their power; and on Shemini Atzeres, through contemplation and the joy of Torah, take the light of Sukkos inward for the whole year.
Questions for discussion
- How does the maamar resolve the difficulty that if study is great because it leads to action, action should be greater?
- What are the two “knowledges,” and how do the prayers Hodu, Modim and Hallel express the move from one to the other?
- Why does G‑d need an “oath” to the fathers, and how does it explain the power of a human deed to arouse a response from above?
- How does the delight reached through teshuvah differ from the delight in the mitzvos, and how does this explain “His left hand is under my head”?
- What does it mean that on Shemini Atzeres the encompassing light is “gathered” inward, and why does this connect to the prayer for rain?
Key terms in this maamar
- Teshuvah (return)תשובה
- Returning the soul, which descended into physical things, to its source and root, to cleave to G‑d; not only leaving sin. Its two levels are the return of the lower and the higher hei. ×21Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first Sefirah of revelation: a single point of insight (koach mah, the yud of Havayah) that comes from the “nothing” above it; being bittul, Or Ein Sof rests in it, and Binah expands it. ×10Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- Aramaic, “the Holy One, blessed be He”: G‑d as holy, set apart from the worlds, paired with Shechinteh, His indwelling; read as sovev kol almin, Z’eir Anpin, Atzmus, and sometimes memalei kol almin.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Name meaning “He brings into being”: by contraction and expansion, its four letters, He brings all worlds into being while Himself unchanged; was, is and will be are one to Him. Elokim conceals it.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Tzimtzum (contraction)צמצום
- Contraction: Or Ein Sof (not Ein Sof Himself) hidden in its source so finite worlds can exist, leaving a “vacated space” for the kav; also each later narrowing of light, as in Chochmah. ×4Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The higher unity (yichuda ila'ah)יחודא עילאה
- The unity seen from above: before G‑d all is as nothing and nothing exists besides Him (the Name Havayah, the Shema’s first verse); the lower unity is the existing world’s self-nullification. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The lower unity (yichuda tata'ah)יחודא תתאה
- The unity seen from below: through the Name Elokim the world exists as a “something” (yesh), and that yesh bows before G‑d (bittul hayesh). It receives from the higher unity, which through it rests below. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Name Elokimאלקים
- The Name of contraction and concealment, the shield and sheath over Havayah, through which creation appears separate (yesh) and runs as nature (hateva, numerically Elokim). Relative to a higher revelation, Havayah counts as Elokim. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Malchus (sovereignty)מלכות
- G‑d’s kingship: the lowest Sefirah, His “speech” and the revealed world, through which all worlds come into being from nothing and live, without touching His essence (“there is no king without a people”).Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- The Sefirah of kindness (the right arm; Avraham): giving that comes from its nature to do good, spreading from highest to lowest like water. Gevurah, its opposite, limits it; in tikkun each includes the other. ×15Where it’s explained, stated differently
- An arousal from aboveאתערותא דלעילא
- G‑d’s stirring toward the world and the soul: it may answer an arousal from below, come first to awaken one, or come from a level no arousal from below reaches. ×8Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Self-sacrifice (mesirus nefesh)מסירות נפש
- Giving over one’s life to G‑d: nullifying one’s very existence in the Or Ein Sof, as at “One” in the Shema. It stems from above reason, and every Jew has it in potential.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- An arousal from belowאתערותא דלתתא
- A stirring that begins with the person (love and awe won by toil, self-nullification, the deed of the mitzvos) which, “as water reflects a face,” awakens a matching arousal from above. ×6Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Willרצון
- Will, which rules the middos: a lower will born of intellect, and the Supernal Will above intellect (Keser, Gulgalta), which covers a hidden reason and delight and is the root of the mitzvos. ×9Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus)השתלשלות
- The descent of levels from cause to effect, linked like the rings of a chain, from Chochmah downward; each reveals what was hidden in the one above. Or Ein Sof itself is above this order. ×5Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof)אור אין סוף
- The boundless light radiating from G‑d’s Essence like sunlight from the sun: His “Name,” a revelation, not the Essence. Chiefly the light before the tzimtzum; also that light as clothed in the sefiros.Where it’s explained, stated differently, Sefer HaErchim
- The light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin)סובב כל עלמין
- G‑d’s light that is not clothed in the worlds: equal in all worlds, above and below, unchanged by them, it gives them life as an encompassing light. Its partner, memalei, is clothed within each world. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The light that fills all worlds (memalei kol almin)ממלא כל עלמין
- G‑d’s life-force clothed within each world and creature by its level, like a soul in a body; it can be known, and it varies with its receivers. Sovev, its partner, is not clothed in them.Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Delightתענוג
- Delight, the inner side of will. Above, the supernal delight of Atik, whose source is His very self: the source of Chochmah, covered by the Supernal Will and drawn down through the mitzvos. ×19Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The emotive attributes (middos)מדות
- The emotive powers (in the soul: love, fear, mercy). Born from the intellect and matching its measure, they are rooted above it, in the will; above, the middos of Z”A, emanated to conduct the worlds. ×3Where it’s explained
- Binah (understanding)בינה
- The Sefirah of comprehension (Imma, the first hei): it expands Chochmah’s flash in length and breadth; letters of thought appear in it; it is “yesh,” and from it love, joy and the middos are born. ×3Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Daas (knowledge)דעת
- Knowledge as felt recognition: the intellect bound into the soul until it is felt as if seen. Daas unites Chochmah with Binah and spreads into the middos as their inner life; the middos follow it. ×2Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Keser (the Crown)כתר
- The Crown over the Sefiros: intermediary between Or Ein Sof and the emanated, holding the lowest level of the Infinite; the Supernal Will and source of delight, beyond grasp; Chochmah emerges from it. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The inner dimension (pnimiyus)פנימיות
- The inner dimension: the part of anything that turns toward and cleaves to its source (from panim, face), its depth and chief will. Its partner, chitzoniyus, goes out to others; the inner does not descend. ×9Where it’s explained, stated differently
- Gevurah (restraint)גבורה
- The Sefirah of might (the left; Yitzchak), opposite Chesed: described as what limits and contracts Chesed’s flow, and as the life-force in greater intensity, which becomes judgment; included in Chesed, it gives life. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently
- The outer dimension (chitzoniyus)חיצוניות
- The outer dimension of a level: the part that goes out to give to others, as against pnimiyus, which cleaves to the source. Only the outer descends, becoming the inner of the level below. ×1Where it’s explained, stated differently