Likkutei Torah · Parshas Shelach · Maamar 18
וישלח יהושע מן השיטים שנים אנשים מרגלים חרש…
“And Yehoshua sent out from Shittim two men as spies, secretly” (Joshua 2:1)
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
Through Torah and mitzvos in thought, speech and action, the days of a person’s life become garments for the soul, a scent-like radiance that lets it be included in G‑d’s Oneness; every Jew must “spy out” his own Yericho, checking his thoughts each day so that his soul is not left naked.
The maamar in brief
The maamar asks why G‑d commanded Yehoshua to send spies only to Yericho, the “lock” that held all the nations of the land, while He left Moshe’s spies to Moshe’s discretion. The answer begins with the Zohar’s reading of Avraham, who “came into days”: the days of a person’s life, filled with Torah and mitzvos, become garments for the soul. We sanctify G‑d with a threefold “Holy” because the mitzvos are done in thought, speech and action, the three garments of the soul; without them a created soul cannot be included in the One, and with them it is “bound up in the bundle of life.” This radiance is the level of scent (rei’ach), Arich Anpin, the “long countenance,” which reaches from the Infinite down to the lowest place, and Yericho is named for it. The 365 days are channels for these garments, formed by overcoming the sitra achra, while evil thoughts are impure garments, so a person must reckon his thoughts every day. Moshe’s spies, examining love and awe, belong to Moshe’s level alone; Yehoshua’s spies, examining the garments, are every person’s task, and the Midrash’s “potters” are those who form these garments and, through the mitzvos, raise the fallen sparks. Finally cheresh is read as thought and as silence.
Outline
- Yehoshua’s spies and Moshe’sYehoshua sent spies at G‑d’s command, and only to Yericho, the lock that included all the land, while Moshe’s spies were left to his discretion; every Jew has his own Yericho.¶1–2
- Days as garmentsThe Zohar: Avraham “came into days,” clothed in the garments his days of Torah and mitzvos had made; why does the soul need garments at all?¶3
- The threefold “Holy”We sanctify G‑d in thought, speech and action; before Him action is equal to thought and speech, for He is holy and separate from heaven and earth alike.¶4–6
- Bound up in the bundle of lifeIsrael draws G‑d’s holiness into the three garments of the soul, which include it in the One; this radiance is scent, Arich Anpin, reaching from the Infinite to the lowest place.¶7–8
- The days and the guarding of thoughtThe 365 days are channels formed by overcoming the sitra achra; holy thoughts clothe the soul, and evil thoughts clothe it in impurity.¶9–10
- Adam’s nakedness and the two kinds of spiesAdam confessed that he did not draw the One into his days; examining love and awe is Moshe’s level, but examining the garments is everyone’s duty, and the Midrash’s “potters” are explained.¶11
- Cheresh: thought and silenceCheresh is read as careful thought, the work of the “masters of accounting,” and as silence.¶12–13
Key concepts
- Garments of the soulלבושי הנשמה
- The thought, speech and action of Torah and mitzvos, formed through a person’s days, which clothe the soul so that it can enjoy the radiance of the Shechinah and be included in G‑d’s Oneness.
- Scent (rei’ach)ריח
- A radiance that spreads from a thing without being its essence: the level of the light drawn down by the mitzvos, and the root of the name Yericho.
- Arich Anpinאריך אנפין
- The “long countenance,” the attribute through which this radiance lengthens from the Infinite down to the lowest level; it is also called “the nose.”
- The bundle of lifeצרור החיים
- Avigail’s phrase for the soul bound up “with Havayah”; here it is the garments that surround the soul and include it in the One.
- Masters of accountingמארי דחושבנא
- Those who reckon every day the thoughts that passed through them, since every thought is a garment for the soul.
- Thought, speech and actionמחשבה דבור ומעשה
- The three garments of the soul, corresponding to nefesh, ruach and neshamah and to the threefold “Holy.”
Yehoshua’s spies and Moshe’s ¶1–2
“And Yehoshua sent out from Shittim two men as spies, secretly (cheresh), saying: Go and see the land and Yericho,” etc.
The maamar opens with the verse in the book of Yehoshua: before Israel crossed the Jordan, Yehoshua secretly sent two spies from Shittim to see the land, and Yericho in particular. The word cheresh, “secretly,” will later be read in several ways: as earthenware, as thought and as silence.
והנה בודאי לא עשה יהושע מדעתו3 רק שהשי״ת [שהשם יתברך] ציוהו ע״כ. ובמרגלים ששלח משה כתיב שלח לך4 ואמרו רז״ל [רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] לדעתך אני איני מצוה5 לך.6
Now, Yehoshua certainly did not do this on his own initiative; rather, G‑d, may He be blessed, commanded him to do so. Yet regarding the spies whom Moshe sent, it is written, “Send for yourself,” and our Sages, of blessed memory, said: “At your discretion; I do not command you.”
The Alter Rebbe takes it as certain that Yehoshua sent his spies at G‑d’s command. Moshe’s spies were different: on the words “Send for yourself,” the Sages, quoted by Rashi, explain that G‑d left the matter to Moshe’s discretion and did not command it.
להבין ענין זה שבכל א״י [ארץ ישראל] לא ציוה השי״ת [השם יתברך] לשלוח מרגלים רק ביריחו שהיתה מנעולה של7 א״י [ארץ ישראל] כמ״ש ויריחו סוגרת8 וכו׳.
[We need] to understand this matter: that in the whole Land of Israel G‑d, may He be blessed, did not command that spies be sent, except to Yericho, which was the lock of the Land of Israel, as it is written, “And Yericho was shut up,” etc.
The question is why G‑d would command spies only for Yericho and not for the rest of the land. The answer begins with Yericho’s place: it was the “lock” of the Land of Israel, the city “shut up” against Israel, and the Midrash says that once Yericho was conquered the whole land would be conquered. In Likkutei Torah, Masei, the Alter Rebbe adds that Yericho had seven walls, for the seven nations, which are rooted in the seven middos, and that it was never divided among the tribes because it includes the whole land.
The maamar opens by contrasting the spies Yehoshua sent, at G‑d’s command and only to Yericho, with the spies Moshe sent at his own discretion, and asks why Yericho alone needed spies.
Kehot notes that the Rebbe explained this maamar in a discourse of the same opening words in 5736, and that Or HaTorah calls it “Vayishlach Yehoshua of Liozna” and prints a gloss on it. Rashi on the verse in Yehoshua explains that Yericho is named separately, though it was part of the land, because it was harder to conquer than all the rest, standing at the border.
Marei mekomos
- 1וישלח יהושע מן השיטים · ראה ברשימת המאמרים בסו״ס מאמרים-קצרים ע׳ תריד הערה 34. וראה אוה״ת שופטים ע׳ תתסד. באוה״ת במדבר-ו ע׳ א׳תתכו מציין לד״ה זה בשם ”וישלח יהושע דלאזני”. וראה שם הערה לכאן. הגהה לדרוש זה נדפסה באוה״ת במדבר-ב הוספות ע׳ 122 ואילך. נתבאר בד״ה משנת תשל״ו (נדפס בסה״מ מלוקט-ב ע׳ שיא ואילך). ראה גם ד״ה זה משנת תשמ״ב.
- 2וישלח יהושע מן השיטים · Joshua 2:1
- 3בודאי לא עשה יהושע מדעתו · ראה שיחת ש״פ שלח (בספר השיחות תשמ״ט ע׳ 536) הערה 25.
- 4שלח לך · Numbers 13:2
- 5לדעתך אני איני מצוה · Sotah 34b
- 6לדעתך אני איני מצוה לך · Rashi on Numbers 13:2
- 7ביריחו שהיתה מנעולה של א״י · ראה במדב״ר טו, טו. תנחומא בהעלותך י. ועל״ק (צא, א) במסעי. וש״נ. [כ].
- 8ויריחו סוגרת · Joshua 6:1
2ובה היו דרין מכל האומות כמ״ש החתי האמורי וגו׳ כל בעלי יריחו12 כו׳. שנתכללו בה שהיתה כללות א״י [ארץ ישראל].
And in it dwelt [people] of all the nations, as it is written, “The Hittite, the Amorite,” etc., all “the citizens of Yericho,” etc.; for they were included in it, since it was the general and collective expression (klalus) of the Land of Israel.
The Midrash teaches that people of all seven Canaanite nations gathered in Yericho, and the verse in Yehoshua lists them all as “the citizens of Yericho.” Because all of them were included in it, Yericho was the general and collective expression of the whole land, which is why conquering it meant conquering the land.
ולהבין ענין זה איך ענין זה הוא נמצא בכל ישראל שבבחי׳ יריחו שלו הוא צריך מרגלים ובבחי׳ שאר א״י [ארץ ישראל] שלו אין צריך מרגלים. הנה כתיב ואברהם זקן בא בימים3 כו׳.
And [we need] to understand how this matter is found in every Jew: that in the level of his Yericho he needs spies, while in the level of the rest of his Land of Israel he does not need spies. Now, it is written, “And Avraham was old, come into days (ba bayamim),” etc.
The Alter Rebbe turns to the inner meaning: every Jew has his own “Land of Israel,” and within it a “Yericho” that needs spies, while the rest of it does not. To explain this he brings the verse that Avraham was old and “came into days.”
Yericho held all the nations and so stood for the whole land; the question now is what Yericho and its spies mean in the service of every Jew, and the answer begins with Avraham, who “came into days.”
Marei mekomos
- 1החתי האמורי גו׳ כל בעלי יריחו · Joshua 24:11
- 2החתי האמורי וגו׳ כל בעלי יריחו · Bamidbar Rabbah 15:15
- 3ואברהם זקן בא בימים · Genesis 24:1
Days as garments ¶3
3ופי׳ בזהר1 שנתלבש בימים שהימים הם בחי׳ לבושין הניתן להנשמה וכל א׳ ניתן לו שני חייו כפי מה שצריך ללבושין.
And the Zohar explains that he clothed himself in the days; for the days are the aspect of garments given to the soul, and each person is given the years of his life according to what he needs for garments.
The Zohar reads “came into days” to mean that Avraham entered the next world clothed in his days: each day of a person’s life becomes part of a garment for the soul. So each person is given as many years as his soul needs for its garments. In Torah Ohr, Chayei Sarah, the Alter Rebbe brings the same Zohar in explaining the Sages’ saying that one hour of teshuvah and good deeds in this world is better than all the life of the World to Come.
כמ״ש ימים יוצרו2 והיינו ע״י תורה ומצות שאדם עוסק בימיו וכל יום שביטל תורה ומצות חסר מהנשמה הלבוש כפי ערך ביטולו.
As it is written, “Days were formed”: that is, through the Torah and mitzvos with which a person occupies himself in his days. And for every day in which he neglected Torah and mitzvos, the garment is missing from the soul, in proportion to his neglect.
The verse “Days were formed” is read as saying that a person’s days are formed into garments, through the Torah and mitzvos done in them. A day spent without Torah and mitzvos leaves a gap in the garment, in proportion to what was neglected.
ולהבין ענין הלבושין ולמה צריכה הנשמה ללבושין שלא תהיה ערומה וגם למה נכתב ענין זה בתורה להודיענו זאת:
And [we need] to understand the matter of the garments: why does the soul need garments, so that it not be naked? And also, why was this matter written in the Torah, to let us know this?
This raises the maamar’s main questions: what are these garments, why does the soul need them so as not to be “naked,” and why does the Torah tell us this at all?
The Zohar’s teaching that a person’s days become garments for the soul, made of Torah and mitzvos, sets up the questions of what the garments are and why the soul needs them.
In the Zohar (Vayechi) a day in which a person sinned is missing from his garment; Adam after the sin knew he was naked because not one of his days remained to clothe him, while Avraham, who merited, entered with his days complete.
Marei mekomos
- 1ופי׳ בזהר · Zohar I, 224a
- 2ימים יוצרו · Psalms 139:16
The threefold “Holy” ¶4–6
4והענין הוא דהנה אנחנו אומרים בכל יום נקדישך. ולכאורה הוא נפלא לומר כן על השי״ת [השם יתברך] שהוא קדוש ומקודש בעצמו ואיך אנו אומרים שאנחנו מקדישים אותו.
The explanation is this. We say every day, “We will sanctify You (nakdishcha).” At first glance it is astonishing to say this about G‑d, may He be blessed, who is holy and sanctified in Himself: how do we say that we sanctify Him?
In the Kedushah of the daily prayers we say, “We will sanctify You.” The Alter Rebbe asks how we can speak of sanctifying G‑d, who is holy in Himself and needs nothing from us.
וגם למה אומרים ג״פ [ג׳ פעמים] קדוש במספר זה דוקא.
Also: why do we say “Holy” three times, precisely this number?
A second question is why “Holy” is said exactly three times, no more and no less.
אך הנה התורה ניתנה לנו בשלשה דברים שהם מחשבה דבור ומעשה שכמה מצות תלוים בדיבור לבד וכמה מצות תלוים במחשבה לבדה וכמה מצות תלוים במעשה לבד.
However, the Torah was given to us in three things, which are thought, speech and action: for several mitzvos depend on speech alone, several mitzvos depend on thought alone, and several mitzvos depend on action alone.
The answer begins: the Torah was given to be fulfilled in three ways, thought, speech and action. Some mitzvos are fulfilled by speech alone, some by thought alone and some by action alone, so each of a person’s three faculties has mitzvos of its own.
The Kedushah’s “We will sanctify You” and its threefold “Holy” are puzzling, and the answer begins with the three faculties, thought, speech and action, through which the mitzvos are fulfilled.
In the discourse “And now, please, let the power of Ado-nai be great,” earlier in this parsha, the Alter Rebbe likewise divides the mitzvos into those that depend on thought and the intention of the heart, those that depend on speech and those of action, and calls them encompassing lights (makifim) for the soul.
5ולכאורה יטעה האדם לומר שאין בחי׳ גילוי אלקות המתגלה בבחי׳ מעשה שוה לבחינת גילוי אלקות המתגלה בבחי׳ דבור ומחשבה שבחי׳ מעשה הוא מתעבה ומתגשם יותר גם בבחי׳ דומם כמו כסף ונחושת ממעשה הצדקה.
At first glance a person might err and say that the level of the revelation of G‑dliness that is revealed in the level of action is not equal to the level of the revelation of G‑dliness that is revealed in the level of speech and thought; for the level of action is coarser and more corporeal, even in the level of the inanimate, such as the silver and copper of the act of charity.
One might think that G‑dliness revealed through action is lower than G‑dliness revealed through speech and thought. Action is coarser and more physical, and it even reaches the inanimate, as when charity is given in silver and copper coins.
אך באמת אינו כן כי הכל שוה אצלו ית׳ כי כולא קמיה כלא חשיב1 ואין הפרש אצלו בין עליונים לתחתונים כיון שהכל כאין נגדו כי הוא ית׳ א״ס ואין ערוך אליו ית׳.
But in truth it is not so, for all is equal before Him, may He be blessed; for “all before Him is considered as nothing,” and there is no difference for Him between the upper beings and the lower beings, since all is as nothing before Him; for He, may He be blessed, is the Infinite One (Ein Sof), and nothing can compare to Him, may He be blessed.
But before G‑d all levels are the same, since “all before Him is considered as nothing,” as the Zohar says. Next to the Infinite One, the difference between higher and lower beings is no difference at all, for nothing can compare to Him.
The paragraph rejects the idea that mitzvos of action draw less G‑dliness than mitzvos of thought and speech: before the Infinite One all levels are equally as nothing.
Marei mekomos
- 1כולא קמיה כלא חשיב · Zohar, Introduction 20:188–22:199
6וזהו מה שאומרים והקדוש בשמים ובארץ1 [ועמ״ש מזה בפ׳ ראה ע״פ אחרי ה׳ אלקיכם תלכו ואותו תיראו2 כו׳] כלומר שבחינת שמים ובחי׳ ארץ שוה אצלו כי הוא קדוש ומובדל מהם
And this is what we say, “And holy in heaven and on earth” [and see what is written about this in Parshas Re’eh, on the verse “After Havayah your G‑d shall you walk, and Him shall you fear,” etc.]: that is to say, the level of heaven and the level of earth are equal before Him, for He is holy and separate from them.
In the Yishtabach blessing we call G‑d “holy in heaven and on earth.” The Alter Rebbe reads this as saying that heaven and earth, the higher and the lower, are equal before Him, since “holy” means separate: He is set apart from both alike. The bracketed note refers to his discourse in Parshas Re’eh on “After Havayah your G‑d shall you walk.”
אף שהוא מחיה את כולם ומהווה את כולם החיות הוא בבחי׳ רצוא ושוב3 כו׳.
Although He gives life to them all and brings them all into being, the life-force (chayus) is in the aspect of “running and returning,” etc.
Although G‑d gives all the worlds life and brings them into being, the life-force He gives them comes in the manner of “running and returning”: it reaches them and withdraws, so He remains apart from them. The words echo Yechezkel’s vision, “and the chayos ran and returned”: there chayos are the living creatures of the Chariot, and here the same letters are read as chayus, the life-force.
The phrase “holy in heaven and on earth” means that G‑d is equally separate from the higher and the lower worlds, even while He gives them all life.
Marei mekomos
- 1והקדוש בשמים ובארץ · ברכת ישתבח.
- 2אחרי ה׳ אלקיכם תלכו ואותו תיראו · Deuteronomy 13:5
- 3רצוא ושוב · Ezekiel 1:14
Bound up in the bundle of life ¶7–8
7והנה המשכת החיות מקדושתו ית׳ נעשה ע״י ישראל כמ״ש ומי כעמך ישראל גוי אחד בארץ.12 פי׳ שאפילו בארץ מתחת ממשיכים בחי׳ אחד.35
Now, the drawing down of the life-force from His holiness, may He be blessed, is accomplished through Israel, as it is written, “And who is like Your people Israel, one nation on earth.” The meaning: even on the earth below they draw down the level of One.
Though G‑d is separate, Israel draws His holiness down into the world. The verse calls Israel “one nation on earth,” which the Alter Rebbe reads as: even here on the lowest earth, Israel draws down the level of One. In Iggeres HaKodesh (epistle 9) he reads the verse the same way: even in earthly matters, such as earning a living, a Jew must not be separated from the true One.
ולכן אומרים ג״פ [ג׳ פעמים] קדוש להמשיך קדושתו בג׳ בחי׳ אלו מחשבה דבור ומעשה שהן ג׳ בחי׳ הנשמה נר״נ [נפש רוח נשמה] (ועמ״ש מזה לעיל ע״פ ועתה יגדל נא] שבכולם נמשך בחי׳ קדוש
Therefore we say “Holy” three times: to draw His holiness into these three levels, thought, speech and action, which are the three levels of the soul, nefesh, ruach and neshamah (and see what is written about this above, on the verse “And now, please, let [the power of Ado-nai] be great”), so that into all of them the level of “Holy” is drawn;
This is why “Holy” is said three times: to draw G‑d’s holiness into a person’s thought, speech and action, which correspond to the three levels of the soul, nefesh, ruach and neshamah. The note sends the reader to the discourse “And now, please, let the power of Ado-nai be great,” earlier in this parsha, where three encompassing garments surround nefesh, ruach and neshamah on every side, so that the soul is “bound up in the bundle of life.”
דהיינו ע״י עסק התורה ומצות בג׳ בחי׳ שהם בחי׳ לבושין להנשמה שתוכל ליהנות מזיו השכינה דהיינו להכלל באחד,
that is, through occupation with Torah and mitzvos in the three levels, which are the aspect of garments for the soul, so that it can enjoy the radiance of the Shechinah (Divine Presence), that is, to be included in the One;
The holiness enters all three through Torah and mitzvos done in thought, speech and action, and these become garments for the soul. They let it “enjoy the radiance of the Shechinah,” the Sages’ description of the reward of the righteous in the World to Come, which the Alter Rebbe explains as being included in the One.
משא״כ כשהיא ערומה3 בלא לבוש אינה יכולה להתכלל באחד מאחר שהיא בחי׳ נברא וכל נברא הווה ונפסד45 ורחוק מאד מבחי׳ אחד
whereas when it is naked, without a garment, it cannot be included in the One, since it is the level of a created being, and every created being comes into being and passes away, and is very far from the level of One.
Without garments a soul cannot be included in G‑d’s Oneness, because it is a created thing, and everything created comes into being and passes away, far from the true One.
ולכן צריך ללבושין היינו מחשבות תורה ומצות שהן בחי׳ לבושין שמלבישין הנשמה ומקיפין אותה מראשה ועד רגלה והם נמשכים מבחי׳ אחד שעי״ז יוכלו נשמות להכלל באחד6
Therefore it needs garments, namely the thoughts of Torah and mitzvos, which are the aspect of garments that clothe the soul and surround it from its head to its foot; and they are drawn from the level of One, so that through this souls can be included in the One.
The garments are the thoughts of Torah and mitzvos, which surround the soul from head to foot. Because they are drawn from G‑d’s Oneness itself, they carry the soul into that Oneness.
וזהו והיתה נפש אדוני צרורה בצרור החיים789101112 את1314 ה׳) (בש״א [בשער א׳] סי׳ כ״ה כ״ט), דהיינו כמו שאדם צורר כספו בחרט כך תהיה נפשו צרורה בצרור החיים
And this is “And the soul of my lord shall be bound up in the bundle of life with Havayah” (in I Samuel, chapter 25, [verse] 29): that is, just as a person ties up his money in a pouch, so shall his soul be bound up in the bundle of life;
This is the meaning of Avigail’s blessing to David in the first book of Shmuel, that his soul would be “bound up in the bundle of life with Havayah.” As a person ties his money up in a pouch, so the soul is tied up and kept within the “bundle of life.”
דהיינו שיקיפנו וילבישנו לבוש וצרור החיים להכלל באחד את ה׳
that is, that the garment and the bundle of life will surround him and clothe him, to be included in the One, “with Havayah.”
The bundle is the garment of Torah and mitzvos, which surrounds and clothes the soul. Its purpose is in the verse’s last words, “with Havayah”: that the soul be included in the One.
[ועיין מענין צרורה בצרור15 כו׳ בגמרא פ״ב [פרק ב׳] דחגיגה (די״ב סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב]]16 ערבות שבו כו׳ ועמ״ש בביאור ע״פ זאת חנוכת המזבח. פ׳ בת׳ דשבת קנ״ב ב׳17 רבות ס״פ האזינו.18 נשא ס״פ19 י״א גבי וישמרך.
[And see on the matter of “bound up in the bundle,” etc., in the Gemara, chapter 2 of Chagigah (folio 12, end of side b): “Aravos, in which…,” etc. And see what is written in the explanation on the verse “This is the dedication of the altar.” The last chapter of Shabbos, folio 152, side b. Rabbah, end of Parshas Haazinu. Nasso, end of section 11, regarding “and guard you.”
A bracketed note now lists sources on “bound up in the bundle.” The Talmud in Chagigah places the souls of the righteous in Aravos, the seventh heaven, and the Talmud in Shabbos says that they are stored away beneath the Throne of Glory, both citing this verse. The note also points to the Alter Rebbe’s explanation on “This is the dedication of the altar” and to Midrash Rabbah on Haazinu and on Nasso, where “and guard you” is read as G‑d guarding the soul.
בקהלת רבה בפסוק מי יודע רוח בני האדם20 העולה. זח״א [זהר חלק א] וירא ק״ו ב׳ תרומה קמ״ב סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב]21 קע״ח סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב] ויקרא כ״ה22 א׳ מצורע נ״ה23 א׳ אחרי ע״א ב׳. בפרדס ערך צרור.24 במא״א [במאורי אור] אות צדיק25 ס״כ]:)36
In Koheles Rabbah, on the verse “Who knows the spirit of men that ascends.” Zohar, Part I, Vayera, folio 106, side b; Terumah, folio 142, end of side b, [and] folio 178, end of side b; Vayikra, folio 25, side a; Metzora, folio 55, side a; Acharei, folio 71, side b. In the Pardes, the entry “Tzror” (bundle). In Me’orei Or, the letter Tzaddik, section 20.]
The list continues with Koheles Rabbah, which says that the souls of the righteous are kept in a treasury, citing Avigail’s words, and with several passages of the Zohar, the Pardes and Me’orei Or. The Zohar explains that the nefesh is bound to the ruach, the ruach to the neshamah and the neshamah to G‑d, so that the nefesh is “bound up in the bundle of life.”
ב והארה והמשכה זו היא בחי׳ ריח כמ״ש והריחו ביראת26 ה׳
2. And this illumination and drawing down is the level of scent (rei’ach), as it is written, “And his scenting shall be in the fear of Havayah.”
A new section begins. The light drawn down by Torah and mitzvos is the level of scent (rei’ach), as Yeshayahu says of Mashiach, “his scenting shall be in the fear of Havayah.”
והוא למשל כמו שהריח אינו עצמיות הדבר אלא הארה והמשכה ממנו כך הארה זו מתפשטת מאור א״ס ב״ה
It is, by way of analogy, like the scent, which is not the essence of the thing but an illumination and extension from it: so this illumination spreads forth from the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He.
A scent is not the thing itself, only something that spreads from it. In the same way, this light is not G‑d’s essence but a radiance spreading from the Infinite Light.
ונקרא מדה זו אריך אנפין כמ״ש אאריך אפי ותהלתי אחטם לך,27
And this attribute is called Arich Anpin, as it is written, “I will lengthen My anger (a’arich api), and [for] My praise I will hold [it] back (echetom) for you”;
The attribute through which this radiance spreads is called Arich Anpin, the “long countenance,” the outer level of Keser (the Crown). Its name is heard in the verse “I will lengthen My anger (a’arich api)”: af means both anger and nose, so “lengthening the af” suggests a long countenance, and the verse’s next word, echetom, comes from chotem, the nose.
כמ״ש באדרא דנשא [ק״ל ע״ב] לבעל החוטם אני מתפלל28 ולבעל החוטם אני מתחנן29 שהארה זו נקרא בחינת חוטם והוא בחי׳ ריח והקב״ה נקרא בעל החוטם שהוא עצמיות ומקור ההארה המתפשטת ממנו
as is said in the Idra of Nasso [folio 130, side b]: “To the Master of the nose (chotem) I pray, and to the Master of the nose I make supplication”; for this illumination is called the level of the nose, and it is the level of scent. And the Holy One, blessed be He, is called the Master of the nose, for He is the essence and source of the illumination that spreads forth from Him.
In the Idra of Nasso, Rav Hamnuna Sava would pray “to the Master of the nose,” and the Alter Rebbe explains that this radiance is called the nose because it is the level of scent, while G‑d Himself, its essence and source, is “the Master of the nose.” In Likkutei Torah, Ki Savo, he gives the reason one prays to “the Master of the nose”: prayer takes the place of the offerings, which were a “pleasing scent.”
והארה זו ארוכה מארץ מדה30 ומתפשטת ממקום גבוה מאד דהיינו א״ס ב״ה שהוא בלי גבול בבחי׳ מטה מטה מאד מקום הגבול,
And this illumination is “longer than the earth in measure,” and it spreads forth from a very high place, namely the Infinite One (Ein Sof), blessed be He, who is without limit, into the level of the very, very low, the place of limitation.
The phrase “longer than the earth in measure,” from Iyov, describes how far this radiance reaches: from the highest place, the Infinite One who has no limit, down to the lowest level, the place of limitation.
[ואפ״ל [ואפשר לומר] שלכן פירשו ברבות במדבר ס״פ31 ה׳ אחטם לך לשון חותם32 כמו שימני כחותם33 שזהו ענין המשכת האור למטה ועמ״ש מענין חותמו של הקב״ה אמת בביאור ע״פ אלה מסעי].3437383940
[And one can say that this is why they explained in Rabbah, Bamidbar, end of section 5, “echetom lach” as a term for a seal (chotam), as in “Set me as a seal”; for this is the drawing of the light downward. And see what is written on the matter of “The seal of the Holy One, blessed be He, is truth” in the explanation on the verse “These are the journeys.”]
In a bracketed note the Alter Rebbe suggests that this is why the Midrash reads echetom lach as chotam, a seal, as in “Set me as a seal upon your heart”: a seal presses its form into what lies below it, which is the drawing of the light downward. The note also refers to the Sages’ saying “The seal of the Holy One, blessed be He, is truth,” which he explains in the discourse on “These are the journeys,” where Moshe’s writing down of Israel’s journeys, their ascents from below to above, is linked with that seal.
The paragraph answers the opening questions: Israel draws G‑d’s holiness into thought, speech and action through Torah and mitzvos, which become garments that let the soul be included in G‑d’s Oneness, “bound up in the bundle of life.” This radiance is the level of scent, called Arich Anpin and “the nose,” which reaches from the Infinite down to the lowest place.
In the Idra, as Yahel Or quotes it, 375 worlds are filled from the length of the nose, and all of them cleave to Z’eir Anpin: a picture of a radiance that reaches far down.
Marei mekomos
- 1ומי כעמך ישראל גוי אחד בארץ · דברי הימים-א ז, כא (אבל בשמואל-ב ז, כג ”כישראל”).
- 2ומי כעמך ישראל גוי אחד בארץ · I Chronicles 17:21
- 3משא״כ כשהיא ערומה · קטע מכאן, נדפס ג״כ בשינויים קלים באוה״ת שלח ע׳ תרנו.
- 4וכל נברא הווה ונפסד · ראה רמב״ם הל׳ יסוה״ת ד, ג.
- 5וכל נברא הווה ונפסד · Mishneh Torah, Foundations of the Torah 4:3
- 6שעי״ז יוכלו נשמות להכלל באחד · באוה״ת פ׳ שלח ע׳ תרנו יש הגהה לכאן.
- 7
- 8צרורה בצרור החיים · Shabbat 152b:6–7
- 9והיתה נפש אדוני צרורה בצרור החיים · Zohar, Vayera 16:230–18:251
- 10נפש אדוני צרורה בצרור החיים · Zohar, Vayikra 64:424–65:435
- 11נפש אדוני צרורה בצרור החיים · Zohar, Metzora 11:41–13:50
- 12נפש אדוני צרורה בצרור החיים · Zohar, Achrei Mot 45:271–46:280
- 13והיתה נפש אדוני צרורה בצרור החיים את ה׳ · I Samuel 25:29
- 14צרורה בצרור החיים את ה׳ · Zohar, Terumah 29:296–306
- 15ועיין מענין צרורה בצרור · ראה גם ד״ה זה במאמרי אדה״ז-נביאים ע׳ טו. כעין זה ראה אוה״ת ויקרא-ב ע׳ תרצג. וראה לעיל לט, א במ״מ.
- 16בגמרא פ״ב דחגיגה [די״ב סע״ב] · ”דהיינו ברקיע השביעי הנקרא ערבות” — אוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ שנ. וראה שם ע׳ כט.
- 17פ׳ בת׳ דשבת קנ״ב ב׳ · ”ועל נשמתן הוא אומר והיתה נפש אדוני צרורה כו׳ ופי׳ מהרש״א אביגיל אמרה כן לדוד” — אוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ כט.
- 18רבות ס״פ האזינו · ”והיכן היא מונחת תחת כסא הכבוד בשמים שכן אביגיל אומרת והיתה נפש אדוני צרורה בצרור החיים כו׳” — אוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ ל.
- 19נשא ס״פ י״א גבי וישמרך · ”ד״א וישמרך ישמור את נפשיך וכן הוא אומר והיתה נפש אדוני צרורה בצרור כו׳” — אוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ כט.
- 20
- 21תרומה קמ״ב סע״ב · ”וההיא נשמתה אתקשרת בא״ס ב״ה כו׳ וע״ד כתיב והיתה...” — אוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ ל.
- 22ויקרא כ״ה א׳ · ראה יהל אור ע׳ תקסד.
- 23מצורע נ״ה א׳ · ”ע״פ והיתה נפש אדוני צרורה בצרור החיים את ה׳ אלקיך נפש אדוני סתם, כד״א אשר לא נשא לשוא נפשי, ופי׳ במק״מ נפש כו׳ היא בחי׳ מל׳ שהיא צרורה בצרור החיים שהוא היסוד שיש בו מוחין דאו״א הנק׳ חיים עכ״ל” — אוה״ת יהל אור ע׳ תקסב. וראה שם ע׳ תקסד. תרצד.
- 24בפרדס ערך צרור · ראה באוה״ת במדבר-ז ע׳ א׳תשצ. וראה גם באוה״ת נ״ך ע׳ לא.
- 25במאו״א אות צדיק ס״כ · באוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ לא ”צרור החיים נק׳ יסוד דבינה שנצרר בה יסוד החכמה כו׳”. וראה גם ע׳ תרצד. וראה יהל אור (הוצאת תשד״מ) ע׳ תשיח. מובא גם באוה״ת שלח ע׳ תעו.
- 26והריחו ביראת ה׳ · Isaiah 11:3
- 27אאריך אפי ותהלתי אחטם לך · Isaiah 48:9
- 28כמ״ש באדרא דנשא . . לבעל החוטם אני מתפלל · ”תאנא כדהוה רב המנונא סבא בעי לצלאה צלותיה אמר לבעל החוטם אני מתפלל לבעל החוטם אני מתחנן, והיינו דכתיב ותהלתי אחטם לך, תנא אורכא דחוטמא תלת מאה וע״ה עלמין אתמליין מההוא חוטמא וכולהו מתדבקין בז״א” — יהל אור ע׳ תרסח.
- 29לבעל החוטם אני מתפלל ולבעל החוטם אני מתחנן · Zohar, Idra Rabba 9:63–10:73
- 30ארוכה מארץ מדה · Job 11:9
- 31ברבות במדבר ספ״ה · ”ע״פ למען שמי אאריך אפי . . דורש אחטם לשון חותם קץ הגאולה החתום (כמו חתום הוא באוצרותי בפ׳ האזינו) גם חותמה לטובה כמ״ש שימני כחותם כו׳ והיא גרמה להם שלא נכרתו בגלות” — אוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ קעט.
- 32אחטם לך לשון חותם · Bamidbar Rabbah 5:6
- 33שימני כחותם · Song of Songs 8:6
- 34בביאור ע״פ אלה מסעי · לקמן צא, ד.
- 35פי׳ שאפי׳ בארץ מתחת ממשיכים בחי׳ אחד · ראה גם אגה״ק סי׳ ט׳ ”דהיינו שגם בעניני ארץ לא יפרידו [נ״א יפרדו] מאחד האמת ח״ו”. דרך מצותיך דף צה, א ”פי׳ שישראל עושים שגם בארץ יהי׳ גילוי בחי׳ אחד”.
- 36זח״א ויקרא ק״ו ב׳ · ”צרור החיים ג״ע העליון” — אוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ ל.
- 37אחרי ע״ח ב׳ · אולי צ״ל ע״א ב׳. וכ״ה באוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ ל ”משמע הצרור ג׳ הנפש מתקשרא ברוח ורוח בנשמה ונשמה בקב״ה נמצא הנפש צרורה בצרור החיים ע״י רוח ונשמה” ע״ש.
- 38ב — בחי׳ ריח · ראה אוה״ת בראשית רפו, ב. רצה, ב.
- 39בזהר בלק דקפ״ו א׳ · ראה לקמן פ׳ מסעי פט, ב. ובזהר שם מדובר בלבושים כפשוטם וריח כפשוטו, שהשייכות דלבושים לריח היא בכל הלבושים, ומחשבה דיבור ומעשה נק׳ בשם יריחו יריחו מלשון ריח גם לפני הכיבוש ואפילו לפני שילוח המרגלים לשם — בד״ה וישלח יהושע תשל״ו הערה 10.
- 40
8ולכן נקרא א״א אריכא דאנפין שמתארך בבחי׳ ריח הנ״ל להלביש הנשמה בבחינות מחשבה דבור ומעשה המצות והתורה
Therefore Arich Anpin is called aricha de’anpin, “long of countenance,” for it lengthens itself in the level of scent mentioned above, to clothe the soul in the levels of thought, speech and action of the mitzvos and the Torah.
This is why Arich Anpin is called aricha de’anpin, “long of countenance”: through the level of scent it lengthens itself far enough to clothe the soul in the thought, speech and action of the mitzvos and the Torah.
[ועמ״ש מזה ע״פ אלה מסעי כו׳ בענין ירדן יריחו. וע׳ בזהר בלק דקפ״ו א׳ בריחא דלבושייכו1 כו׳ ומ״ש סד״ה ועתה יגדל נא2 כו׳].3
[And see what is written about this on the verse “These are the journeys,” etc., on the matter of “the Jordan [at] Yericho.” And see the Zohar, Balak, folio 186, side a: “By the scent of your garments,” etc.; and what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “And now, please, let [the power of Ado-nai] be great,” etc.]
A bracketed note refers to the discourse on “These are the journeys,” where the Alter Rebbe explains that all the journeys led to “the Jordan at Yericho” and that Yericho is the level of scent (rei’ach), a slight radiance from a thing’s essence. It cites the Zohar in which a child knew “by the scent of your garments” what two sages had done that day, showing that garments carry a scent. It also refers to the end of the discourse “And now, please, let the power of Ado-nai be great,” earlier in this parsha, which reads “long-suffering” (erech apayim) as this revelation lengthening and being drawn further down.
Arich Anpin “lengthens” its scent-like radiance down into the garments of thought, speech and action, and the Zohar’s story of the scent of garments shows that garments and scent belong together.
Kehot cites the Rebbe’s discourse of 5736, note 10: in the Zohar the garments are literal garments and the scent a literal scent, since the bond between garments and scent holds for all garments; and thought, speech and action are called Yericho, from rei’ach (scent), even before the conquest and before the spies were sent there.
Marei mekomos
- 1בריחא דלבושייכו · Zohar, Balak 4:24–6:33
- 2סד״ה ועתה יגדל נא · לעיל לט, ב ואילך.
- 3
The days and the guarding of thought ¶9–10
9והנה בחינת הלבושין הם נמשכים ע״י בחי׳ ימים שיש שס״ה ימים שהם שס״ה המשכות, כמו למשל שס״ה גידין שהדם והחיות היוצא מן הלב לכל האברים נמשך דרך הגידים [עמ״ש בד״ה לסוסתי בשיר השירים]
Now, the level of the garments is drawn down through the level of days: for there are 365 days, which are 365 drawings-down; as, by way of analogy, the 365 sinews, for the blood and the life-force that go out from the heart to all the limbs are drawn through the sinews [see what is written in the discourse beginning “To My mare,” in Shir HaShirim],
The garments come to the soul through days, and the year has 365 days, which are 365 channels through which light is drawn down. They are compared to the 365 sinews through which the blood and life of the heart reach every limb.
שהם בחי׳ גבורות שצריך האדם התגברות להתגבר לאכפייא לסט״א [לסטרא אחרא] בג׳ בחי׳ אלו שיהיו כל בחי׳ אלו דהיינו מחשבתו ודבורו ומעשיו לעבודת ה׳ לבד.
and they are the level of gevuros (might); for a person needs a mighty effort (hisgabrus) to prevail, to subdue the sitra achra (the other side) in these three levels, so that all these levels, namely his thought, his speech and his actions, will be for the service of G‑d alone.
These channels are gevuros, powers of might, and the words play on each other: gevuros call for hisgabrus, a mighty effort, because the garments are formed when a person exerts himself to overcome the sitra achra. He must strive that all his thought, speech and action serve G‑d alone.
[ועיין בזח״ג [בזהר חלק ג] פנחס (דף רמ״ט ע״ב) ע״פ משכו וקחו1 מאי משכו כמאן דמשיך מאתר אחרא לאתר דא משכו יומין עילאין לגבי יומין תתאין2 יומין עילאין אינון שס״ו כחשבון משכו כו׳ ע״ש.
[And see the Zohar, Part III, Pinchas (folio 249, side b), on the verse “Draw forth and take”: “What is ‘draw forth’? As one who draws from another place to this place: draw forth the supernal days toward the lower days. The supernal days are 366, the numerical value of mishchu (draw forth),” etc.; see there.
The bracketed note cites the Zohar on “Draw forth (mishchu) and take”: the word mishchu equals 366, the number of the supernal days, which are drawn down to the lower days.
וע׳ בפרדס ערך ימי עולם ובזח״א [ובזהר חלק א] ויחי (דף רמ״ז ע״א) גבי שבעת ימים ושבעת ימים3 ובפ׳ מקץ (דר״ד סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב]) ובפ׳ בראשית (דנ״א סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב]) ובסה״מ [ובספר הדרת מלך] סי׳ קמ״א].
And see the Pardes, the entry “Yemei Olam” (days of the world); and the Zohar, Part I, Vayechi (folio 247, side a), regarding “seven days and seven days”; and in Parshas Miketz (folio 204, end of side b); and in Parshas Bereishis (folio 51, end of side b); and in Sefer Hadras Melech, section 141.]
The note lists further places on the subject of the days: the Pardes under “Yemei Olam,” the Zohar on “seven days and seven days” and two other passages of the Zohar, and Sefer Hadras Melech.
כללא דמילתא שישים האדם מחשבתו להתבונן אשר במחשבתו הקדושה ממשיך עליו מלמעלה בחינת לבוש להנשמה ולא שתהא כוונתו ע״מ [על מנת] לקבל פרס45 רק שעי״ז יוכלל באחד כנ״ל.6
The upshot of the matter: a person should set his mind to contemplate that through his holy thought he draws upon himself, from above, the aspect of a garment for the soul; and his intention should not be in order to receive a reward, but only that through this he will be included in the One, as mentioned above.
The practical point: when a person thinks holy thoughts, he should be aware that he is drawing a garment for his soul from above. His aim should not be a reward, as the Mishnah warns against serving “in order to receive a reward,” but only to be included in G‑d’s Oneness.
The garments are drawn through the days, as blood flows through the sinews, by the effort of overcoming the sitra achra; a person should think holy thoughts knowing that they clothe his soul, aiming not at reward but at being included in the One.
In the Zohar on “Draw forth and take,” the lower days sometimes number 355, and rise to 365, “mishchu less one,” when the moon shines in its fullness; the supernal days, 366, are drawn down to them. The Zohar on Vayechi reads the “seven days and seven days” of Shlomo’s feast as the upper world and the lower world.
Marei mekomos
- 1משכו וקחו · Exodus 12:21
- 2משכו יומין עילאין לגבי יומין תתאין · Zohar, Pinchas 104:696–105:706
- 3שבעת ימים ושבעת ימים · Zohar, Vayechi 75:771–781
- 4ע״מ לקבל פרס · וראה אבות א, ג.
- 5ע״מ לקבל פרס · Pirkei Avot 1:3
- 6בד״ה לסוסתי בשה״ש · לקו״ת שם יא, ג.
10ובזה יהיה תמיד רצונו שלא ליפרד מאחדותו ית׳ ויתבונן ג״כ בזה לעו״ז [לעומת זה] דהיינו מחשבות רעות שהם לבושים טמאים להנשמה ולא כטעות הפתיים שקל בעיניהם לחשוב מחשבות חוץ מאחר שאינו למעשה כלל.
And in this his will should always be not to be separated from His unity, may He be blessed. And he should also contemplate this regarding the opposing side, namely evil thoughts, which are impure garments for the soul; and not as the error of the simple-minded, in whose eyes it is a light thing to think extraneous thoughts, since it does not come to action at all.
Since holy thought clothes the soul, a person’s constant desire should be never to be separated from G‑d’s unity. He should likewise consider the opposite: evil thoughts are impure garments for the soul, and the simple-minded are wrong to treat stray thoughts lightly because they never lead to action.
Just as holy thoughts clothe the soul in holiness, evil thoughts clothe it in impurity, so a thought is never trivial even if it is never acted on.
Adam’s nakedness and the two kinds of spies ¶11
11וגם אמרו רז״ל [רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] מחשבה רעה אין הקב״ה מצרפה1 למעשה ומכש״כ [ומכל שכן] הרהורים רעים [נ״א [נוסחא אחרינא] בטלים] שאינם אפילו בכלל מחשבה רעה.
Also, our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “An evil thought, the Holy One, blessed be He, does not join to the deed”; and all the more so evil musings [another reading: idle], which are not even in the category of an evil thought.
The Sages taught that G‑d does not count an evil thought as if it were a deed, and idle or evil musings are lighter still. One might conclude that thoughts matter little.
אבל באמת לאמיתו המחשבה בעצמה הנה היא לבוש הטומאה שמלבישה ומקיפה להנשמה מראשה ועד רגלה ואינה יכולה להכלל באחדותו
But in very truth, the thought itself is a garment of impurity that clothes and surrounds the soul from its head to its foot, and [the soul] cannot be included in His unity.
The Alter Rebbe answers that, even so, the thought itself is an impure garment that surrounds the soul from head to foot. While it is clothed in it, the soul cannot be included in G‑d’s unity.
ולכן יהיה בעיניו מחשבת חוץ כעבודת כוכבים היותר חמורה ממש מאחר שבזה נפרד מאחדותו ית׳ ויהיה ממארי דחושבנא לחשוב בכל יום ויום ממש כמה וכמה מחשבות שעברו בו ביום שהמחשבות הם לבושין כנ״ל.
Therefore an extraneous thought should be in his eyes like the most severe idolatry, literally, since through it he is separated from His unity, may He be blessed. And he should be one of the “masters of accounting” (marei d’chushbena), reckoning every single day, literally, how many thoughts passed through him that day; for the thoughts are garments, as mentioned above.
That is why an extraneous thought should seem to a person as grave as idolatry: both separate him from G‑d’s Oneness. Like the “masters of accounting” of the Zohar, he should review each day how many thoughts passed through his mind, since each one is a garment.
This is [the meaning of] “Days were formed, and not one among them” (in Psalms, chapter 139, [verse] 16).
This is the meaning of the verse in Tehillim, “Days were formed, and not one among them.” In its plain sense David praises G‑d, who saw him before he was formed and wrote all his days in His book, but the Alter Rebbe reads it in another way.
שאמר אדם הראשון אחר שאכל מעץ הדעת גלמי ראו עיניך4.56 פי׳ שראיתי א״ע [את עצמו] ערום בלי לבוש כמו גולם כמ״ש כי עירום אנכי.7
Adam, the first man, said [this] after he had eaten from the Tree of Knowledge: “Your eyes saw my unformed mass (golmi).” The meaning: I saw myself naked, without a garment, like a golem, as it is written, “For I am naked.”
Following the Midrash and the Zohar, he reads the verse as words of Adam after he ate from the Tree of Knowledge. “Your eyes saw my unformed mass (golmi)” means that after the sin Adam saw himself naked, without garments, like an unformed golem, as he told G‑d, “For I am naked.”
ואמר ימים יצרו. פי׳ שנתת לי ימים בחי׳ לבושין להלביש בהם הנשמה להמשיך על ידם בחי׳ אחד,8 אבל ולא אחד בהם פי׳ שאני הוא שלא המשכתי בהם בחי׳ אחד
And he said, “Days were formed”: meaning, You gave me days, the aspect of garments in which to clothe the soul, to draw down through them the level of One; but “and not One (echad) in them”: meaning, it is I who did not draw down the level of One into them.
Adam goes on: “Days were formed”: You gave me days to be formed into garments, to draw the One into them; but “and not One in them”: I did not draw the One into any of them. The Alter Rebbe reads echad, “one,” as G‑d’s Oneness, and in Likkutei Torah on Shir HaShirim he explains the verse the same way: the days are garments, formed so that the level of One should shine in them.
(ועיין מענין הפסוק גלמי פ״ד דסנהדרין) (דל״ח א׳) רבות בראשית (רפ״ח פכ״ד) תזריע פי״ד [פרק י״ד / פרשה י״ד] זח״א [זהר חלק א] בראשית (נ״ה ב׳) לך (ד״צ ע״ב).
(And see on the matter of the verse “my unformed mass,” chapter 4 of Sanhedrin) (folio 38, side a); Rabbah, Bereishis (beginning of section 8; section 24); Tazria, section 14; Zohar, Part I, Bereishis (55b); Lech (folio 90, side b).
The note lists where the verse “my unformed mass” is discussed: the Talmud in Sanhedrin, which says that Adam’s dust was gathered from the whole world, Midrash Rabbah, and the Zohar.
ימים יצרו וירא (צ״ט א׳) חיי (קכ״א ע״ב). ובהרמ״ז [ובהרב משה זכות] שם ויחי (דרכ״ד סע״א [סוף עמוד א] דרל״ג ב׳).9
[On] “Days were formed”: Vayera (99a); Chayei (folio 121, side b). And in the Ramaz there. Vayechi (folio 224, end of side a; folio 233, side b).
It continues with the passages of the Zohar that explain “Days were formed” and the Ramaz’s commentary on them. In Vayechi the Zohar says that when a person merits with good deeds in this world, his days are blessed above.
וזהו בחי׳ מרגלים10 ששלח יהושע111213 לרגל את יריחו דהיינו בחינת ריח הנ״ל לרגל ולהבחין בחי׳ הלבושין שמבחינת ריח הנ״ל (ועמ״ש בפ׳ חיי שרה בד״ה עיין בע״ח [בעץ חיים] שמ״ט פ״ה).
And this is the level of the spies whom Yehoshua sent to spy out Yericho, namely the level of scent (rei’ach) mentioned above: to spy out and to discern the garments that come from the level of scent mentioned above. (And see what is written in Parshas Chayei Sarah, in the discourse beginning […]; see Etz Chaim, Sha’ar 49, chapter 5.)
Yehoshua’s spies stand for the level of scent: the name Yericho holds the letters of rei’ach, scent, the radiance described above. Every person must “spy out” and examine the garments of his soul, which come from this level. The note points to Etz Chaim, Sha’ar 49, chapter 5, where the Arizal teaches that the Torah and mitzvos were given to refine the garments of the soul: intention in Torah and mitzvos completes the garment of the neshamah, Torah study refines the garment of the ruach, and the mitzvos of action the garment of the nefesh.
ובחי׳ מרגלים ששלח משה לתור את ארץ כנען דהיינו לבחון את מהות אהוי״ר [אהבה ויראה]
And the level of the spies whom Moshe sent to scout out the land of Canaan is, namely, to examine the essential nature of love and awe.
Moshe’s spies were sent to scout the land of Canaan; inwardly, this is examining the true nature of a person’s love and awe of G‑d.
וזהו א״א אלא בבחי׳ משה בחי׳ חמה שהוא מחכמה כמאמרם ז״ל [זכרונו לברכה / זכרונם לברכה] פני משה כפני חמה14 ואינו שוה לכל נפש
And this is impossible except in the level of Moshe, the level of the sun (chamah), which is from Chochmah (wisdom), as [the Sages], of blessed memory, said, “The face of Moshe was like the face of the sun”; and it is not within the reach of every soul.
Such an examination is possible only at the level of Moshe, whose face was “like the face of the sun,” and the Alter Rebbe says that this sun, chamah, comes from Chochmah, wisdom. Not every soul can reach this level.
ולכן לא היה צווי ע״ז לכל אדם כמארז״ל [כמאמר רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] אני איני מצוה לך15 (ועיין בסש״ב [בספר של בינונים] פרק י״ד)16
Therefore there was no command about this for every person, as our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “I do not command you” (and see Sefer Shel Beinonim [Tanya], chapter 14);
That is why G‑d did not command it: “I do not command you” means that it is not a duty for everyone. Tanya, chapter 14, explains that the level of the beinoni is open to every person, while the perfection of the tzaddik is not.
משא״כ בחי׳ המרגלים ששלח יהושע יש לכל אדם לרגל ולחשוב שלא תהיה נשמתו ערומה בלי לבושין שהן מחשבות התורה והמצות כנ״ל
whereas [regarding] the level of the spies whom Yehoshua sent, every person must spy out and consider that his soul not be naked, without garments, which are the thoughts of the Torah and the mitzvos, as mentioned above.
Yehoshua’s spies are different: every person must check that his soul is not left naked, without the garments of thoughts of Torah and mitzvos.
(וברבות נזכר ענין וישלח יהושע ר״פ שלח. ברות ריש פרשה ב׳ המה היוצרים17 אלו המרגלים הה״ד [הדא הוא דכתיב] וישלח יהושע18 כו׳ זח״ב [זהר חלק ב׳] ס״פ תרומה בספד״צ [בספרא דצניעותא] ספ״ד [ספרא דצניעותא] ח״ג [חלק ג׳] אחרי) (ד״ס ע״ב ודס״ב ב׳)
(And in Rabbah the matter of “And Yehoshua sent” is mentioned at the beginning of Parshas Shelach. In Ruth [Rabbah], at the beginning of section 2: “They are the potters (hayotzrim): these are the spies, as it is written, ‘And Yehoshua sent,’” etc. Zohar, Part II, end of Parshas Terumah, in the Sifra deTzniusa, end of chapter 4. Part III, Acharei) (folio 60, side b, and folio 62, side b);
A note gathers sources on Yehoshua’s spies. Midrash Rabbah on Shelach opens with them, Ruth Rabbah reads “They are the potters” in Divrei HaYamim as speaking of these spies, and the Zohar on Acharei calls “two men as spies” a secret of the Sifra deTzniusa.
פ׳ שלח (ק״ס ע״ב) וע׳ בשל״ה [בשני לוחות הברית] פ׳ בשלח19 (דף שי״ד ב׳) סד״ה אמנם יש מה שפי׳ מאמר הזהר הנ״ל.
Parshas Shelach (folio 160, side b). And see in the Shelah, Parshas Beshalach (folio 314, side b), at the end of the passage beginning “However, there is,” what he explained of the above-mentioned statement of the Zohar.
The note continues with the Zohar on Shelach, where Yehoshua learned to send two spies from the two who carried the cluster of grapes, and with the Shelah, who explains the Zohar’s statement.
ואפשר לומר פי׳ הרבות המה היוצרים ע״פ מ״ש למעלה שהם מרגלים לבחי׳ ימים יצרו
And one may say [that] the meaning of the Rabbah’s “They are the potters (hayotzrim)” is according to what was written above: that they are spies for the level of “Days were formed (yutzaru),”
The Alter Rebbe offers his own reading of “They are the potters (yotzrim)”: the spies examine what is “formed” (yutzaru), the days that are formed into garments.
גם לבחינת וייצר ה׳ אלקים את האדם וייצר בשני יודין שפירשו ברבות בראשית ר״פ י״ד ב׳ יצירים יצר טוב ויצר הרע20 וצ״ל היצה״ר [היצר הרע] כפוף ובטל ליצ״ט [ליצר טוב]
and also for the level of “And Havayah Elokim formed (vayyitzer) the man”: vayyitzer with two yuds, which [the Sages] explained in Rabbah, Bereishis, beginning of section 14: two inclinations, the good inclination and the evil inclination. And the evil inclination must be bent and nullified before the good inclination;
They also examine the forming of man himself. In the verse “And Havayah Elokim formed the man,” vayyitzer is spelled with two yuds, which the Midrash reads as two inclinations (yetzer), the good and the evil; and the evil inclination must bow and give way to the good.
ולכן אחד מן היודין נקוד ונרגש והשני נסתר רמז שחפץ ה׳ שיצה״ר [שיצר הרע] יהיה נכלל ביצ״ט [ביצר טוב] ונכפף לו. כ״כ [כל כך] הרמ״ז [הרב משה זכות] בפ׳ תזריע21 (דמ״ו ע״ב)
therefore one of the yuds is vocalized and sounded and the other is hidden, an allusion that G‑d desires that the evil inclination be included in the good inclination and bow to it. So writes the Ramaz in Parshas Tazria (folio 46, side b).
One of the two yuds is voweled and heard, and the other is silent: a hint that G‑d wants the evil inclination to be absorbed into the good inclination and to submit to it. This is the Ramaz’s comment on Parshas Tazria.
והכנעה זו זהו ע״י שמירת המחשבה דבור ומעשה כמ״ש בבינונים וע״ז אמר המה היוצרים שהם המרגלים ושלוחים להבחין בחי׳ הלבושים דמחודומ״ע [דמחשבה דבור ומעשה].
And this subjugation comes through guarding thought, speech and action, as is written in [Sefer Shel] Beinonim. And of this it says, “They are the potters”: they are the spies and emissaries to discern the garments of thought, speech and action.
The evil inclination is subdued by guarding thought, speech and action, as Sefer Shel Beinonim (Tanya) explains. That is why the spies are called “potters”: they are sent to examine these garments.
ולפי פשוטו של הרבות דפי׳ המה היוצרים מלשון יוצר כלי חרש כמ״ש מרגלים חרש.22 י״ל [יש לומר] ע״פ מ״ש במא״א [במאורי אור] אות פ׳ סעי׳ [סעיף] נ׳.
And according to the plain sense of the Rabbah, which explains “They are the potters” in the sense of a potter (yotzer) of earthenware vessels (cheres), as it is written, “spies, cheresh,” it can be explained according to what is written in Me’orei Or, the letter Pei, section 50:
The Midrash’s plain meaning is that the spies disguised themselves as potters, makers of earthenware (cheres), matching “spies, cheresh.” The Alter Rebbe explains this through a passage of Me’orei Or.
פכים קטנים23 שחזר עליהם יעקב24 הם ניצוצים שנפלו בשבירת הכלים מעולם התהו וידוע שע״י המצות מעלים הניצוצים הנ״ל שנפלו לשרשן וע״כ המה היוצרים כלים הנ״ל.25
the small jugs for which Yaakov went back are sparks that fell in the breaking of the vessels from the World of Tohu; and it is known that through the mitzvos one raises to their root the aforementioned sparks that fell. Therefore “they are the potters” of those vessels.
Yaakov went back for small jugs, and Me’orei Or says these stand for the sparks that fell when the vessels of the World of Tohu broke. Since the mitzvos raise these sparks to their root, those who do them are the “potters” of those vessels.
A thought matters even when it never becomes action, because it clothes the soul; Adam’s confession, “not one among them,” describes a soul left naked. Moshe’s spies, examining love and awe, belong to Moshe’s level alone, but Yehoshua’s spies, examining the garments of thought, speech and action, are every person’s task, and the Midrash’s “potters” are read in this light.
The Zohar in Acharei speaks of two who draw nourishment every day and are called “spies of the land,” and calls this the secret of “two men as spies” in the Sifra deTzniusa. In his discourse of 5742, cited by Kehot, the Rebbe explains that by pointing to Tanya, chapter 14, the Tzemach Tzedek resolves how love and awe can be left to Moshe’s level: the measure of the beinoni, service in thought, speech and action, belongs to everyone, while the perfection of the tzaddik is not within every person’s choice.
Marei mekomos
- 1מחשבה רעה אין הקב״ה מצרפה · Kiddushin 39b:9–10
- 2ימים יצרו ולא אחד בהם · Zohar, Vayechi 32:294–303
- 3ימים יצרו ולא אחד בהם · Zohar, Vayechi 48:495–51:505
- 4
- 5גלמי ראו עיניך · Psalms 139:16
- 6גלמי ראו עיניך · Bereshit Rabbah 8:1
- 7כי עירום אנכי · Genesis 3:10
- 8להמשיך על ידם בחי׳ אחד · ראה סה״מ תש״ט ע׳ 77. בלקו״ת שה״ש כב, ב (מובא ביהל אור ע״פ) ”כי מים הם לבושים והם יוצרו בכדי שיהי׳ אחד מאיר בהם
- 9פ״ד דסנהדרין (דל״ח א׳) . . ויחי . . דרל״ג ב׳ · כל המראה מקומות נזכרים גם ביהל אור ע׳ תקכד.
- 10וזהו בחי׳ מרגלים · מובא באוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ א.
- 11וישלח יהושע · Bamidbar Rabbah 16:1
- 12וישלח יהושע · Zohar, Achrei Mot 11:76–12:86
- 13וישלח יהושע · Zohar, Sh'lach 10:67–75
- 14פני משה כפני חמה · Bava Batra 75a:16
- 15אני איני מצוה לך · Rashi on Numbers 13:2
- 16ועיין בסש״ב פרק י״ד · ראה אוה״ת שלח ע׳ תלט. תמג. ציון זה נתבאר בארוכה בד״ה וישלח יהושע תשמ״ב. שבציון זה מיישב כ״ק הצ״צ הקושיא איך אפ״ל שהעבודה דאהוי״ר אינה אלא בבחי׳ משה ולא הי׳ ציווי ע״ז לכל אדם ועל זה מציין כ״ק הצ״צ לתניא פי״ד דשם מבואר שמדת הבינוני שהיא מדת כל אדם ואחרי׳ כל אדם ימשוך היא העבודה במדו״מ, אבל שלימות העבודה שהיא בבחי׳ צדיק הרי אין לאדם משפט הבחירה ע״ז ע״ש בארוכה.
- 17המה היוצרים · I Chronicles 4:23
- 18המה היוצרים אלו המרגלים הה״ד וישלח יהושע · Ruth Rabbah 2:1
- 19(וברבות . . בשל״ה פ׳ בשלח · המ״מ נעתקו באוה״ת נ״ך-א ע׳ א. ושם מציין גם לשל״ה פ׳ וישב.
- 20ב׳ יצירים יצר טוב ויצר הרע · Bereshit Rabbah 14:4
- 21כ״כ הרמ״ז בפ׳ תזריע · הלשון נעתק באוה״ת פ׳ בלק ע׳ תתקנב ”וייצר בשני יודי״ן שהם נמשכים מחו״ג מים ואש, אבל אחד מן היודי״ן נקוד ונרגש והשני נסתר רמז שחפץ ה׳ שהיצה״ר יהי׳ נכלל ביצ״ט ויכנע לו” ע״ש.
- 22מרגלים חרש · Joshua 2:1
- 23פכים קטנים · חולין צא, סע״א.
- 24פכים קטנים שחזר עליהם יעקב · Chullin 91a:22–23
- 25וייצר ה״א את האדם · Genesis 2:7
Cheresh: thought and silence ¶12–13
12וגם כמ״ש אנחנו החומר ואתה יוצרנו12 ועיין מזה ברבות כי תשא פמ״ו3 ועיין ברבות בראשית פי״ד [פרק י״ד / פרשה י״ד] ע״פ ככלי יוצר45 וזהו המה היוצרים כו׳
And also, as it is written, “We are the clay, and You are our Potter (yotzrenu)”; and see on this in Rabbah, Ki Sisa, section 46; and see in Rabbah, Bereishis, section 14, on the verse “like a potter’s vessel.” And this is “They are the potters,” etc.
Another verse built on yotzer, “potter,” is “We are the clay, and You are our Potter.” The Alter Rebbe points to Midrash Rabbah on Ki Sisa and to Bereishis Rabbah on the verse “like a potter’s vessel,” and connects them with “They are the potters.”
מיהו שם אמר ככלי חרס אין כתיב כאן אלא ככלי יוצר א״כ א״א לומר כן פי׳ מרגלים חרש. אך פי׳ חרש לשון מחשבה כמו אל תחרוש על רעך.6
However, there it says, “It is not written here ‘like an earthenware vessel (cheres),’ but ‘like a potter’s vessel’”; if so, it is impossible to explain “spies, cheresh” this way. Rather, cheresh is a term for thought, as in “Do not devise (tacharosh) against your fellow.”
But that Midrash distinguishes “an earthenware vessel” (cheres), which has been fired, from “a potter’s vessel,” which has not; so “potters” cannot explain cheresh in “spies, cheresh.” Instead, cheresh means thought, as in “Do not devise (tacharosh) against your fellow.”
היינו כי צריך להיות ממארי דחושבנא ולחשוב מחשבות להזהר בלבושי הנפש מחודומ״ע [מחשבה דבור ומעשה] שתהיינה בבחי׳ ריח ניחוח לה׳7 כנ״ל.
That is, one must be of the “masters of accounting” and think thoughts, to take care with the garments of the soul, thought, speech and action, that they be in the level of “a pleasing scent to Havayah,” as mentioned above.
The spies’ work is that of the “masters of accounting” (marei d’chushbena), who reckon their thoughts: thinking carefully about the soul’s garments of thought, speech and action, so that they are “a pleasing scent to Havayah.”
Since the Midrash separates earthenware from potter’s vessels, cheresh is read here as thought: the spies are the careful thinking that keeps the soul’s garments a pleasing scent before G‑d.
In Bereishis Rabbah, Rabbi Yitzchak notes that the verse does not say “like earthenware vessels You will shatter them” but “like a potter’s vessels”: a potter’s vessels that have not yet been fired can be restored.
Marei mekomos
- 1אנחנו החומר ואתה יוצרנו · Isaiah 64:7
- 2אנחנו החומר ואתה יוצרנו · Shemot Rabbah 46:4
- 3ברבות כי תשא פמ״ו · הלשון נעתק באוה״ת בראשית דף נא, ב.
- 4ככלי יוצר · Psalms 2:9
- 5ככלי יוצר · Bereshit Rabbah 14:7
- 6אל תחרוש על רעך · Proverbs 3:29
- 7ריח ניחוח לה׳ · Leviticus 1:9
13ועמ״ש בד״ה על כן יאמרו המושלים בואו חשבון1 כו׳ גם חרש2 ענין שתיקה כדפרש״י [כדפירש רש״י / כדפירוש רש״י] ע״ד מ״ש ברבות פ׳ וישב פ״ד ע״פ מאלמים אלומים3 משתוקיתא דאימא קמה4 וכן ברבות באסתר ע״פ אין אסתר מגדת.5 ישפה יש פה ושותק6 כו׳
And see what is written in the discourse beginning “Therefore the rulers say: Come to Cheshbon,” etc. Cheresh is also a term for silence, as Rashi explains, along the lines of what is said in Rabbah, Parshas Vayeshev, section 84, on “binding sheaves (me’almim alumim)”: “The silence of the mother arose”; and likewise in Rabbah on Esther, on “Esther did not tell”: “Yashfeh: yesh peh (there is a mouth), yet he is silent,” etc.
The Alter Rebbe first refers to his discourse on “Therefore the rulers say: Come to Cheshbon,” whose cheshbon, a reckoning, recalls the “masters of accounting.” Then he gives a third meaning of cheresh, silence: Rashi renders it “in secret” and says the spies were told to act as if deaf. The Midrash calls what would stand up for Yosef “the silence of the mother,” Rachel, and traces that silence to her descendants: Binyamin, whose stone in the breastplate was yashfeh, read yesh peh, “there is a mouth,” for he knew of Yosef’s sale yet kept silent, and Esther, who “did not tell” her origins.
ועיין בפי׳ המשניות להרמב״ם [להרבי משה בן מימון] ספ״ק [סוף פרק קמא] דאבות על המשנה ולא מצאתי לגוף טוב משתיקה:7
And see the Rambam’s Commentary on the Mishnah, end of the first chapter of Avos, on the mishnah, “I have found nothing better for the body than silence.”
The Alter Rebbe also points to the Rambam’s commentary on the Mishnah in Avos, “I have found nothing better for the body than silence.”
The maamar closes with a third meaning of cheresh, silence, supported by the Midrash on Rachel’s silent descendants and by the Mishnah’s praise of silence.
Esther Rabbah traces this silence from Rachel, who kept silent when she saw her betrothal gifts in her sister’s hand, to Binyamin, to Shaul, who did not tell his uncle about the kingship, and to Esther. In Bereishis Rabbah, on Yosef’s dream of the sheaves, the one who would stand up for Yosef is called “the silence of the mother.”
Marei mekomos
- 1על כן יאמרו המושלים בואו חשבון · Numbers 21:27
- 2חרש · Rashi on Joshua 2:1
- 3מאלמים אלומים · Genesis 37:7
- 4משתוקיתא דאימא קמה · Bereshit Rabbah 84:10
- 5אין אסתר מגדת · Esther 2:20
- 6ישפה יש פה ושותק · Esther Rabbah 6:12
- 7ולא מצאתי לגוף טוב משתיקה · Pirkei Avot 1:17
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
Each Rosh Chodesh the names of those learning here are brought to the Ohel. Add your name, and mark what you learn so it is counted.
In one’s avodah
A person should set his mind on the fact that every holy thought draws a garment for his soul from above, and should think, speak and act in Torah and mitzvos not for a reward but to be included in G‑d’s Oneness. He should regard an extraneous thought as gravely as idolatry and, as one of the “masters of accounting,” review each day the thoughts that passed through him, so that his soul is not left naked.
Questions for discussion
- Why did Yehoshua’s spies need G‑d’s command while Moshe’s were left to his discretion, and what does each kind of spying mean in a person’s inner life?
- How can a mitzvah done with silver and copper coins draw the same G‑dliness as one done in thought or speech?
- Why can a soul without garments not be included in G‑d’s Oneness, and how do Torah and mitzvos change that?
- If G‑d does not count an evil thought as a deed, why does the maamar treat an extraneous thought as gravely as idolatry?
- How do the readings of cheresh as earthenware, as thought and as silence each describe the work of the spies?
Key terms in this maamar
- The general and collective expression (klalus)כללות
- That which encompasses the particulars as one: their general and collective expression (the klal, as against the prat). Never “sum”, “sum total”, “totality” or “general principle”, as if the particulars were added up (וכללותן היא מצות הצדקה is “their general and collective expression is the mitzvah of charity”). Render by sense: “their general and collective expression”, “that which encompasses them all”, “X in general”, “X as a whole”. Keep התכללות as “inclusion” / “inter-inclusion”. ×1
- The Infinite One (Ein Sof)אין סוף
- G‑d's own boundless essence.
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Tetragrammaton: G‑d as transcending time and bringing all into being.
- Life-forceחיות
- The divine vitality that sustains every creation. ×3
- The Shechinah (Divine Presence)שכינה
- G‑d's presence as it dwells in the world. ×1
- The Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof)אור אין סוף
- G‑d's light as it is, beyond all limits, before any contraction.
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- The sitra achra (the other side)סטרא אחרא
- The realm opposed to holiness.
- Love and aweאהבה ויראה
- The two 'wings' of divine service.
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first flash of insight. ×1
- The Name Elokimאלקים
- G‑d as concealed within nature, measuring and limiting. ×1
- Daas (knowledge)דעת
- Deep connection to an idea, bridging intellect and emotion. ×1