Likkutei Torah · Parshas Rosh Hashanah · Maamar 5
להבין ענין הפסוק מי אל כמוך וגו׳ שהוא…
To Understand the Verse “Who Is a G‑d Like You”
Kept on this device only. Sign in to save it on every device
The big idea
G‑d’s supernal kindness (Kel), flowing from the Infinite Light that is above time, reaches specifically the lowest place, as water runs downhill. Teshuvah with kelos hanefesh, born of the knowledge that all of time is a moment before G‑d, reaches that level; and even one who cannot rise so high draws it by seeing his own lowliness and making himself like “leftovers,” for then G‑d bears the desire behind his sin and treads down the act, removing what separates his soul from Him.
The maamar in brief
Micah’s “Who is a G‑d like You” speaks of Kel, kindness, which flows without limit from the Infinite Light to the lowest place, as water runs downhill. Teshuvah, read as tashuv hei, returns the upper and lower letters hei of the Name, and it applies to Torah scholars and to every person’s thought and speech. Its essence is kelos hanefesh, the soul’s longing to expire into G‑d, kindled by contemplating that the world and all of time, renewed each hour through the permutations of Havayah, are a single moment before G‑d, who is unchanged by creation. Such teshuvah is “before the world,” above the contractions that the letters of the Name describe, and it draws G‑dliness down into a dwelling below. Even one who only despises his life because he sees how low he has fallen draws the supernal kindness of Atik Yomin. G‑d “bears” the desire behind sin, lifting it to its holy root, and “suppresses” the act, casting it into the depths of the sea. This is granted to one who makes himself like “leftovers,” crushed by his distance from G‑d, until kindness, like water, frees his soul from the body.
Outline
- Kindness that flows downwardKel is Chesed, a kindness that flows from the Infinite Light to the lowest place like water. “He bears iniquity and passes over transgression” shows how it reaches there, and teshuvah, tashuv hei, is the return of the upper and lower hei, which concerns Torah scholars and every person’s thought and speech.¶1–2
- Teshuvah that precedes the worldTeshuvah’s essence is kelos hanefesh. Time is created hour by hour through the permutations of Havayah, yet all of it is a moment before G‑d, who has not changed. Contemplating this brings the soul’s expiry, a teshuvah above time and the world, which draws G‑dliness down to make a dwelling below.¶3–9
- The letters of the Name and the unificationYud is contraction, hei expansion, vav the drawing down, and the final hei Malchus; a world (olam) is concealment (he’elem). Teshuvah reaches above all this, and the unification sought is that G‑d be revealed after the contractions as before them: in the upper worlds now, and in this world, even to physical perception, in the Time to Come.¶10–12
- Supernal kindness for the lowlyThe revelation begins already in the penitent. Even one who only despises his life because he sees how low he is draws the kindness of Atik Yomin, as people pity a prisoner. This inner kindness is far above the kindness that builds the world. How can it reach one who was so far?¶13–16
- Bearing iniquity and suppressing itSin has two parts. The desire behind it is neutral and rooted in holiness, so G‑d “bears” it, lifting it up; the act is complete evil, so G‑d “suppresses” it in the depths of the sea. With these screens removed, the unchanging Infinite Light is revealed upon the soul, but only for one who makes himself like “leftovers.”¶17–18
- Why the soul does not expireMalachi complains that though G‑d has not changed, the children of Yaakov have not come to kelos hanefesh, for their souls come from the “heel” and the light reaches them only as a makif. The soul is stuck in the body like a lung with adhesions; the Zohar’s counsel is to “strike” it, refusing the transgressor’s excuse, “this is how I was made.”¶19–21
- A broken and crushed heartDaka is one crushed by nature; nidkeh is one made crushed by contemplation or suffering. David prayed that even such acquired brokenness not be despised, but bring at least an encompassing revelation of the Infinite Light.¶22–23
- Like leftoversOne who sees that the Infinite Light reaches him only as a remnant, a makif, becomes crushed and nullified before it. Then the supernal kindness bears his iniquity and passes over his transgression and, like water loosening adhesions, frees the G‑dly soul from the body to cleave to G‑d.¶24–25
Key concepts
- Kelos hanefeshכלות הנפש
- The soul’s longing to the point of expiry, to leave the body and cleave to G‑d. It arises from contemplating that G‑d is above time and unchanged by creation, and it is the teshuvah that “preceded the world.”
- Supernal kindnessחסד עליון
- The inner kindness that comes from the light that encompasses all worlds and from Atik Yomin, far above the outer kindness that builds the world. Like water, it flows most to the lowest place.
- Tashuv heiתשוב ה׳
- The Zohar’s reading of teshuvah as the return of the letter hei: the upper hei (thought, the Written Torah) and the lower hei (speech, the Oral Torah), returned to their source.
- Avon and peshaעון ופשע
- Two aspects of sin: avon, the desire and thought behind it, which G‑d “bears” and lifts to its holy root; and pesha, the act itself, which G‑d “passes over,” treading it down into the depths of the sea.
- Daka and nidkehדכא ונדכה
- Daka is one who is crushed in his very nature; nidkeh is one made crushed through his own effort or through suffering. David prayed that even the second not be despised.
- Leftoversשיריים
- The Sages’ reading of “the remnant of His inheritance”: one who regards himself as receiving only the remnant of the light from above the chain of worlds, which reaches him as a makif.
- Makifמקיף
- An encompassing light that touches a person from outside and above without entering his inner heart, as for the souls that come from the level of the “heel.”
- Atik Yominעתיק יומין
- “The Ancient of Days,” the level removed (ne’etak) and exalted above “the days of the world,” the source of time. The Idra says “Who is a G‑d like You” is said of it.
Kindness that flows downward ¶1–2
1להבין ענין הפסוק1 מי אל כמוך וגו׳ שהוא פי׳ לי״ג מדות שבתורה. והנה אל הוא חסד2 כמ״ש חסד אל כל היום.37
To understand the meaning of the verse “Who is a G‑d (Kel) like You,” etc., which is the explanation of the Thirteen Attributes [of Mercy] that are in the Torah. Now, Kel is Chesed (kindness), as it is written, “The kindness of Kel is all the day.”
The maamar opens with Micah’s verse “Who is a G‑d like You, who bears iniquity and passes over transgression…”, whose phrases are an explanation of the Thirteen Attributes of Mercy that G‑d revealed in the Torah. The Divine Name Kel used in the verse stands for the attribute of Chesed, kindness, as the psalm says, “The kindness of Kel is all the day.”
ופי׳ מי בעל חסד כמוך שהחסדים שלך מתפשטים לאין קץ מאור א״ס ב״ה למקום נמוך מאד שלכן נמשל למים שיורדים4 ממקום גבוה למקום נמוך5 מאד.6
And the meaning is: who is a master of kindness like You, for Your kindnesses spread without end, from the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, to a very low place; this is why [kindness] is likened to water, which descends from a high place to a very low place.
Read this way, “Who is a G‑d like You” means “Who is a master of kindness like You?” G‑d’s kindness has no limit: it flows from the Infinite Light down to the very lowest place, and that is why kindness is likened to water, which leaves the heights and runs down to the lowest ground.
The opening sets the theme of the whole maamar: G‑d’s kindness (Kel) is unlike any other because it flows without limit from the Infinite Light to the very lowest place, as water runs downhill.
The Talmud (Taanis 7a) uses the same image for the Torah: as water leaves a high place and goes to a low one, so words of Torah endure only in one whose spirit is humble. The maamar will apply the image to the penitent who is low in his own eyes (paragraphs 13–14). Kehot also refers to Me’orei Or, a Kabbalistic lexicon, for Kel as Chesed.
Marei mekomos
- 1להבין ענין הפסוק · נדפס בשינויים בס׳ מאמרי אדה״ז הקצרים ושם מחולק לכמה מאמרים: א) ד״ה להבין פי׳ הפסוק מי א-ל כמוך, ע׳ קפג. ב) לה״ע התשובה, ע׳ תקפד. ג) ענין תשובה קדמה לעולם, ע׳ שכט. ד) להבין מ״ש ויעש דוד שם, ע׳ קל. ה) להבין מ״ש לב נשבר, ע׳ רט. ולפי הנסמן במאמרי אדה״ז הקצרים שם, מאמר זה הוא משבת תשובה תקנ״ו. ראה גם בהנסמן להלן בהמ״מ לפ׳ האזינו עח, א. קיצורים לד״ה זה באוה״ת דברים כרך ז ע׳ ב׳תצב. חלק מהמאמר (מלהלן סא, א שו״ה בתחתונים) נמצא ג״כ בשינויים בס׳ מאמרי אדה״ז — פרשיות ע׳ תקסה ומתחיל: ושמרתם. באוה״ת תצוה ע׳ א׳תרא ובאוה״ת ויקרא כרך א ע׳ קיב מציין לד״ה זה ”בדרושי עשי״ת”.
- 2א-ל הוא חסד · ראה ג״כ מא״א אות א, ס״פ.
- 3חסד אל כל היום · Psalms 52:3
- 4למים שיורדים · ע׳ תענית (ז, א). [כ].
- 5ממקום גבוה למקום נמוך · Taanit 7a:15
- 6מי א-ל כמוך · Micah 7:18
- 7חסד א-ל כל היום · Psalms 50:3
2ודרך שיוכלו החסדים לירד לבחי׳ מטה מאד מפרש ואומר נושא עון ועובר על פשע1.2 פי׳ מה שהוא עדיין בבחי׳ עון
And the way in which the kindnesses can descend to the level of what is very low, [the prophet] explains, saying: “He bears iniquity and passes over transgression.” That is: what is still at the level of iniquity (avon),
The next words of Micah’s verse explain how G‑d’s kindness can reach even the very lowest level: “He bears iniquity and passes over transgression.” The Alter Rebbe distinguishes two levels of wrongdoing, avon (iniquity) and pesha (transgression), and begins with avon.
הנה הוא מגביה ונושא למעלה ומה שהוא בבחי׳ פשע שהוא בחי׳ יותר בעביות ואינה יכולה
He raises and bears upward; but what is at the level of transgression (pesha), which is a level of greater coarseness and cannot
What is at the level of avon G‑d “bears”: He lifts it up and carries it upward. Pesha, however, is a coarser and denser level, and it cannot be lifted.
לעלות וכתיב עוונותיכם היו מבדילים וטהור עינים מראות ברע3 ואינם יכולים החסדים לרדת שם לכן עובר ודורך על פשע שלא יפסיקו כו׳.
rise — and it is written, “Your iniquities have separated,” and “[You are] too pure of eyes to see evil,” so the kindnesses cannot descend there — therefore He passes over and treads upon transgression, so that they not interrupt, etc.
Sin forms a barrier, as Isaiah says, “Your iniquities have separated [between you and your G‑d],” and G‑d is “too pure of eyes to see evil” (Habakkuk), so His kindness cannot descend into such a place. Therefore G‑d “passes over” pesha, treading it down so that it no longer interrupts the flow of His kindness.
רק כ״ז [כל זה] הוא באם שהוא לשארית נחלתו45 כו׳. כמ״ש בגמרא פ״ק [פרק קמא] דראש השנה (י״ז א׳) וע׳ רבות ר״פ נצבים6 ובפ׳ בשלח (פכ״ו)7 מגילה (כ״ח א׳).
But all this is only if it is “for the remnant of His inheritance,” etc., as is stated in the Gemara, in the first chapter of Rosh Hashanah (17a); and see the Midrash Rabbah at the beginning of Parshas Nitzavim, and in Parshas Beshalach (chapter 26); [and] Megillah (28a).
All this applies only “for the remnant of His inheritance,” the verse’s next words, which the Talmud in Rosh Hashanah explains as “one who makes himself like a remnant,” a theme the maamar develops at its end. The Alter Rebbe adds the Midrash Rabbah and tractate Megillah, where this verse is also expounded.
וביאור הדברים דרך פרט הנה ארז״ל [אמרו רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] גדולה תשובה שמגעת8 עד כסא הכבוד9 ובזהר אמרו תשובה תשוב10 ה׳ ה׳ עילאה ה׳ תתאה.
The explanation of the matter in detail: our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “Great is teshuvah (return), for it reaches the Throne of Glory”; and in the Zohar they said, “Teshuvah is tashuv hei, ‘the hei returns’”: the upper hei [and] the lower hei.
To explain in detail, the Alter Rebbe brings two teachings: the Talmud’s “Great is teshuvah, for it reaches the Throne of Glory,” and the Zohar’s reading of the word teshuvah (תשובה) as tashuv hei (תשוב ה׳), “the hei returns.” The Name Havayah has two letters hei, the upper hei (Binah) and the lower hei (Malchus), and teshuvah returns both.
ולהבין זה צריך להבין מהות התשובה11 כי העולם טועים לומר דוקא אנשים פחותי הערך ובעלי עבירות הם הם הצריכים לתשובה והאמת אינו כן כי מאחר שעיקר התשובה היא בה׳ תתאה ועילאה ואיש בער לא ידע.12
To understand this, one must understand what teshuvah essentially is. For people err in saying that it is specifically people of little worth and transgressors who are the ones who need teshuvah. But the truth is not so, since the essence of teshuvah is in the lower hei and the upper [hei], and “a boorish man does not know.”
To understand this one must first grasp what teshuvah really is. People think it is only for those of low standing and for sinners, but this is a mistake. The essence of teshuvah lies in the upper and lower hei, something the “boorish man” of the psalm, who “does not know,” cannot even grasp; the next part shows that the Zohar was speaking of those who study Torah.
אמנם באמת אמרו זה על אנשים יושבי אהל ולומדי תורה13 שתורה שבכתב היא ה׳ עילאה ותושבע״פ [ותורה שבעל פה] היא14 ה׳ תתאה וכשמפסיק מהם ועוסק בהבלי עולם צריך לחזור ולהשיב ההי״ן אלו למקורם וזהו דרך כלל.
In truth, however, they said this about people who sit in the tent and study Torah: for the Written Torah is the upper hei and the Oral Torah is the lower hei, and when one breaks off from them and occupies himself with the vanities of the world, he must go back and return these letters hei to their source. This is [the explanation] in general terms.
In truth the Zohar’s words were said about those who “sit in the tent” and study Torah. The Written Torah corresponds to the upper hei and the Oral Torah to the lower hei; when a scholar breaks off from them and busies himself with the vanities of the world, he must bring these two letters back to their source. This is the general explanation.
ודרך פרט הנה התבוננות בגדולת ה׳ ועיון תפלה וכוונתה במחשבה הוא בחי׳ ה׳ עילאה וכשמוציאם בפה בעסק התורה והתפלה היא בחי׳ ה׳ תתאה.15
And in particular terms: contemplation of the greatness of G‑d, and concentration in prayer (iyun tefillah) and its intent in thought, is the level of the upper hei; and when one brings them out with the mouth, in the study of Torah and in prayer, that is the level of the lower hei.
In detail, the two letters hei are found in every person’s service. Contemplating G‑d’s greatness and concentrating one’s thought on prayer and its meaning belong to the upper hei, the realm of thought; saying the words aloud, in Torah study and in prayer, belongs to the lower hei, the realm of speech.
The words “He bears iniquity and passes over transgression” show how G‑d’s kindness reaches the lowest: avon is lifted up, while pesha, too coarse to rise, is trodden down so that it no longer blocks the kindness. The Alter Rebbe then begins a detailed explanation of teshuvah as the return of the upper and lower hei, which applies to Torah scholars and to every person’s thought and speech.
In the Raaya Mehemna on Nasso (Zohar 3:122a), teshuvah is read “tashuv hei,” and there the mitzvah of teshuvah is identified with Binah and confession in words with Malchus; Kehot also cites the Raaya Mehemna on 123a–b. Chapter 4 of the Alter Rebbe’s Iggeres HaTeshuvah opens with this Zohar, explaining the lower hei as the lower teshuvah and the upper hei as the upper teshuvah.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2נושא עון ועובר על פשע · Shemot Rabbah 26:2
- 3וטהור עינים מראות ברע · Habakkuk 1:13
- 4
- 5
- 6רבות ר״פ נצבים · פ״ח. בסה״מ תרכ״ו (הוצאת תשמ״ט) ע׳ שו.
- 7ובפ׳ בשלח (פכ״ו) · אוה״ת נ״ך כרך א ע׳ תצב. בסה״מ תרכ״ו שם.
- 8גדולה תשובה שמגעת · יומא פו, סע״א.
- 9גדולה תשובה שמגעת עד כסא הכבוד · Yoma 86a:16
- 10תשובה תשוב ה׳ · Zohar III, 122a
- 11ולהבין זה צריך להבין מהות התשובה · ראה מאמרי אדה״ז הקצרים ע׳ תקפד (הנ״ל).
- 12ואיש בער לא ידע · Psalms 92:7
- 13על אנשים יושבי אוהל ולומדי תורה · ראה לקמן סו, ג. ר״פ האזינו. ועוד.
- 14שתורה שבכתב . . ה׳ עילאה ותושבע״פ היא ה׳ תתאה · ע׳ מאו״א מערכת תורה טו וריש מערכת ה, ס״א. [כ].
- 15עונותיכם היו מבדילים · Isaiah 59:2
Teshuvah that precedes the world ¶3–9
3והנה ארז״ל [אמרו רבותינו זכרונם לברכה]1 שבעה דברים קדמו לעולם2 ואחת מהן התשובה [עיין בבראשית רבה פ׳ א׳] והענין כי הנה עיקר התשובה היא בלב3 שהיא בחי׳ ה׳ עילאה דהיינו לכות הנפש אליו ית׳.4
Now, our Sages, of blessed memory, said that seven things preceded the world, and one of them is teshuvah [see Bereshis Rabbah, chapter 1]. The explanation is that the essence of teshuvah is in the heart, which is the level of the upper hei: that is, the soul’s expiry (kelos hanefesh) toward Him, may He be blessed.
Our Sages list teshuvah among the things that preceded the creation of the world; the text points to the Midrash in Bereshis Rabbah, chapter 1. The Alter Rebbe explains that teshuvah is essentially in the heart, the upper hei: kelos hanefesh, the soul’s yearning to expire into G‑d (the printed לכות is evidently כלות).
Teshuvah is introduced as one of the things that preceded the world, and its essence is located in the heart: the upper hei, the soul’s longing to dissolve into G‑d. The next paragraphs explain how this longing is reached and why it is “before the world.”
The Midrash supports teshuvah’s precedence with the psalm “Before the mountains were born… You return man to dust,” which the maamar takes up in paragraph 11. Kehot also cites the Rambam (Laws of Teshuvah 2:3), who rules that one who confesses in words without resolving in his heart to abandon the sin is like one who immerses while holding an impure creature.
Marei mekomos
- 1ארז״ל · Pesachim 54a
- 2ארז״ל שבעה דברים קדמו לעולם · ראה מאמרי אדה״ז הקצרים ע׳ שכט (הנ״ל).
- 3עיקר התשובה היא בלב · ראה רמב״ם הל׳ תשובה פ״ב, ה״ג. תניא פרק כט (לו, ב). לעיל נח, ד הערה וכמארז״ל.
- 4
4והיינו ע״י שמתבונן שכל העולם הוא תחת הזמן שיתא אלפי שני1 כו׳ ואפילו ימות המשיח ותחיית המתים הוא בזמן והזמן הוא נברא2 להחיות העולמות עליונים ותחתונים שעל ידי י״ב צירופי הוי׳ שמתחדשים בכל יום
That is, through contemplating that the whole world is subject to time, “six thousand years,” etc., and even the days of Mashiach and the Resurrection of the Dead are within time; and time is created, to give life to the upper and lower worlds: for through the twelve permutations of [the Name] Havayah, which are renewed each day,
Kelos hanefesh is reached through contemplation: the whole world is subject to time, the “six thousand years” the Talmud gives for the world’s existence, and even the era of Mashiach and the Resurrection belong to time. Time itself is a creation, made to give life to the worlds through the twelve permutations of the letters of the Name Havayah, which are renewed every day.
דהיינו בכל שעה צירוף אחד3 הוא מהוה ומחיה העולמות עליונים ותחתונים [ובכל לילה י״ב צירופי
that is, in each hour one permutation brings into being and gives life to the upper and lower worlds [and in each night, the twelve permutations of
In each hour of the day one of the twelve permutations rules, bringing the worlds into being and giving them life. At night, the bracket adds, the twelve permutations of the Name Ado-nai do this.
אדנ״י] והחיות רצוא ושוב4 פי׳ שהחיות שהיה ע״י צירוף הראשון עולה למקורו ויורד החיות אח״כ על ידי צירוף השני שאל״כ [שאם לא כן] היה די בצירוף אחד
Ado-nai], and the life-force (chayus) is “running and returning” (ratzo vashov): that is, the life-force that came through the first permutation rises to its source, and afterwards the life-force descends through the second permutation; for otherwise one permutation would have sufficed.
The life-force moves in “running and returning,” Ezekiel’s words for the movement of the holy chayos: the vitality given through one permutation rises back to its source, and then new vitality descends through the next. If the life-force simply remained, one permutation would have been enough.
ולכן מזה נמשך בחינת עבר ועתיד שהחיות הראשון מסתלק ונכלל במקורו מלמטה למעלה ויורד ונמשך חיות אחר מלמעלה למטה ונעשה בחי׳ זמן [והוא כמשל המורה שעות שקורין זייגער בל״א [בלשון אשכנז]].
Therefore from this comes the dimension of past and future: the first life-force withdraws and is absorbed into its source, from below upward, and another life-force descends and is drawn down from above to below, and so the dimension of time comes into being [it is like the example of the hour-indicator, which in Yiddish is called a zeiger].
This rhythm of withdrawal and renewal is what makes past and future, and so time comes into being. The Alter Rebbe compares it to a clock, a zeiger in Yiddish, which shows the hours one after another.
Time is shown to be a creation: the life-force comes through a different permutation of Havayah each hour, rising and descending in “running and returning,” and this succession is what makes past and future.
Tanya ch. 41 gives the same teaching: in each hour a different flow comes from the upper worlds to give life to the lower ones, and the life-force of the hour before returns to its source “in the secret of running and returning” of Sefer Yetzirah, for in each of the twelve hours of the day one of the twelve permutations of Havayah rules, and those of Ado-nai at night.
Marei mekomos
- 1שיתא אלפי שני · Rosh Hashanah 31a:8–9
- 2והזמן הוא נברא · ראה לעיל בלק ע, ג.
- 3בכל שעה צירוף אחד · Tanya, Likkutei Amarim 41:26
- 4והחיות רצוא ושוב · Ezekiel 1:14
5ולכן נק׳ שעה פי׳ הפונה שפונה החיות מלמעלה למטה בבחי׳ רצוא ושוב1 וכן הלב שבו עיקר חיות האדם שהוא עולם קטן23 הוא דופק תמיד מחמת שהחיות הוא ברצוא ושוב [ועמ״ש מזה סד״ה
This is why it is called sha’ah (hour), meaning “turning,” for the life-force turns from above to below in the manner of running and returning. Likewise the heart, in which the main life-force of man resides — man being a miniature world — beats constantly, because the life-force is in running and returning [and see what is written about this at the end of the discourse beginning
An hour is called sha’ah, which the Alter Rebbe reads as “turning,” for in each hour the life-force turns from above to below in running and returning. The human heart, the seat of a person’s life, shows the same pattern: it beats without pause because its life-force too runs and returns, for man is “a miniature world” that mirrors the greater one.
“For as the new heavens”]. Now, “From my flesh I behold G‑d”: by way of analogy, a person who has some matter to speak about —
A bracket refers to the end of a Torah Ohr discourse on “For as the new heavens” for more on this. The Alter Rebbe then invokes Job’s “From my flesh I behold G‑d”: from a person’s own make-up one can grasp something about G‑d, and he gives an analogy from a person who has something to say.
הנה הדברים חקוקים על לבו כולם כאחד כל מה שיוכל לדבר ולפרוט בשפתיו בשעה ושתים.
the words are engraved on his heart all together as one, everything he could speak and spell out with his lips in an hour or two.
Before speaking, everything he will say is engraved on his heart at once, even though spelling it out with his lips would take an hour or two. In the heart there is no sequence; sequence appears only in speech.
כך כביכול למעלה מקור החיות והצרופים שהוא חיי החיים אור א״ס ב״ה שם אין שום התחלקות זמן עבר הוה ועתיד
So too, as it were, above: the source of the life-force and of the permutations, which is the Life of all life, the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He — there, there is no division of time whatever, past, present and future,
So too above, as it were: in the source of the life-force and of the permutations, the Infinite Light, called “the Life of all life,” there is no division of time into past, present and future.
כי שם נכללו כולם כאחד והרי יש בכחו להוות ולחיות עוד כמה פעמים שיתא אלפי שני כו׳
for there they are all included as one; and indeed it has the power to bring into being and give life for many more times “six thousand years,” etc.,
There all of time is contained as one. The Infinite has the power to bring into being and sustain many more spans of “six thousand years.”
וכמה שמיטין ויובלין עד אין סוף ותכלית רק כשהחיות נמשך מלמעלה למטה להחיות העולמות נעשה בחי׳ זמן
and many Sabbatical cycles and Jubilees, without end or limit. Only when the life-force is drawn down from above to below to give life to the worlds does the dimension of time come into being.
It could sustain countless cycles of Shemitah and Yovel (in Kabbalah, great cosmic cycles), without end. Time comes into being only when the life-force is drawn down to give life to the worlds.
וכן קודם שנברא העולם לא היה בחי׳ זמן כלל [ועמ״ש בביאור ע״פ יונתי6 גבי כי לא מחשבותי מחשבותיכם]7 והנה כתיב אני ה׳ לא שניתי8 ואתה הוא9 קודם10 שנברא העולם כו׳.
So too, before the world was created there was no dimension of time at all [and see what is written in the explanation on the verse “My dove,” regarding “For My thoughts are not your thoughts”]. Now, it is written, “I, Havayah, have not changed,” and “You are He before the world was created,” etc.
Before the world was created there was no time at all; a bracket refers to the biur on “My dove” on the verse “For My thoughts are not your thoughts.” The Alter Rebbe then cites Malachi’s “I, Havayah, have not changed” and the words of the morning prayers, “You are He before the world was created [and You are He since the world was created].”
פי׳ כמו שהיה יחיד ומיוחד קודם שנברא כן עתה יחיד ומיוחד ממש אחר שנברא כמ״ש אתה הוא ה׳ לבדך ואע״פ [ואף על פי] שנברא העולם לזה אומר אתה עשית וגו׳.
That is: just as He was single and unique before [the world] was created, so now He is truly single and unique after it was created, as it is written, “You are He, Havayah, alone.” And though the world was created, to this it says, “You made,” etc.,
The point is that G‑d is as truly single and unique after creation as He was before, as Nehemiah says, “You are He, Havayah, alone.” Although the world has been created, the verse goes on to address that too: “You made [the heavens]… and You give life to them all,” which the next paragraph explains.
Through the analogy of words held in the heart before they are spoken, the Alter Rebbe shows that in G‑d, the source of all life, past, present and future are one. Time exists only as the life-force descends to the worlds, and G‑d remains as single after creation as before.
Kehot lists many places for man as a “miniature world”: Avos deRabbi Nasan ch. 31, Koheles Rabbah 1:4, Midrash Tanchuma (Pekudei 3), Tikkunei Zohar 69, Zohar 1:134b and the Guide for the Perplexed 1:72. The analogy of the heart and speech is the human “flesh” from which, in Job’s words, one beholds G‑d.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2האדם שהוא עולם קטן · Kohelet Rabbah 1:8
- 3שהוא עולם קטן · Midrash Tanchuma, Pekudei 3:3
- 4סד״ה כי כאשר השמים החדשים · תו״א ב, ג.
- 5מבשרי אחזה אלו-ה · Job 19:26
- 6בביאור ע״פ יונתי · לקמן שה״ש יז, ד.
- 7כי לא מחשבותי מחשבותיכם · Isaiah 55:8
- 8אני ה׳ לא שניתי · Malachi 3:6
- 9אתה הוא ה׳ לבדך · Nehemiah 9:6
- 10אתה הוא קודם שנה״ע · תפלת השחר.
6ואתה מחיה וגו׳.1 כי ביו״ד נברא העוה״ב [העולם הבא]2 ובה׳ נברא העוה״ז. והם כל סדר הזמנים ואפילו ימות המשיח ותחיית המתים3 שאינם אלא בחי׳ יו״ד וה״א.
“and You give life,” etc. For with the yud the World to Come was created, and with the hei this world was created; and these are the whole order of times, even the days of Mashiach and the Resurrection of the Dead, which are no more than the level of yud and hei.
The verse continues, “and You give life [to them all].” The Talmud teaches that the World to Come was created with the letter yud and this world with the hei, the first two letters of the Name; all the orders of time, even the days of Mashiach and the Resurrection, are no more than these two letters.
והוא למשל כמו באדם אות4 א׳ נגד כל דבורים שלו שיכול לדבר כל ימי חייו אינו נחשב לכלום כך כל העולמות עליונים ותחתונים כולא קמי׳ [קמיה] כלא חשיב.5
This is by way of analogy like a person: one letter, compared to all the words he can speak all the days of his life, counts as nothing at all. So too all the worlds, upper and lower: “all before Him is considered as nothing.”
A single letter counts as nothing beside all the words a person can say in his whole life. So too all the worlds, upper and lower, are as nothing before G‑d, in the Zohar’s words: “all before Him is considered as nothing.”
Creation through the letters yud and hei, a letter or two beside G‑d’s infinite power, shows that all the worlds and all their times are as nothing before Him.
Tanya ch. 20 develops the same analogy: a single utterance is as nothing compared with the soul’s whole power of speech and thought, and so all the worlds are as nothing before G‑d.
Marei mekomos
- 1ואתה מחיה וגו׳ · Nehemiah 9:6
- 2ביו״ד נברא העוה״ב · Menachot 29b:13–14
- 3ואפילו ימות המשיח ותחיית המתים · Song of Songs 3:4
- 4למשל כמו באדם אות א׳ · תניא פרק כ. אוה״ת שה״ש ע׳ נב.
- 5כולא קמי׳ כלא חשיב · Zohar I, 11b
7וז״ש [וזהו שכתוב] ברגע קטן עזבתיך1 שאינה אלא רגע קטן. ומ״ש כי אלף שנים כיום כו׳. היינו בזמן הגלות וכמ״ש ואשמורה בלילה.2
And this is [the meaning of] what is written, “For a brief moment I forsook you”: that it is no more than a brief moment. And what is written, “For a thousand years are like a day,” etc., refers to the time of exile, as it is written, “and a watch in the night.”
This explains Isaiah’s “For a brief moment I forsook you”: the exile is no more than a brief moment. The psalm’s “For a thousand years [in Your eyes] are like a day… and a watch in the night” describes the time of exile, the “night,” when a thousand years are seen as a day.
משא״כ לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] שיתגלה אלקותו בעולם ואז עין בעין יראו3 וראו כל בשר4 שהכל נחשב לרגע ולזאת ברגע קטן עזבתיך וברחמים גדולים אקבצך פי׳ כשאקבצך ברחמים גדולים
Whereas in the Time to Come, when His G‑dliness will be revealed in the world, then “they will see eye to eye,” and “all flesh will see” that everything counts as a moment. Therefore, “For a brief moment I forsook you, and with great compassion I will gather you in”: that is, when I gather you in with great compassion,
In the Time to Come G‑dliness will be revealed in the world; “they will see eye to eye” and “all flesh will see” that all of time counts only as a moment. So the Alter Rebbe reads the verse’s two halves together: “with great compassion I will gather you” tells when the exile will be seen as “a brief moment.”
דהיינו שיתגלה אלקותו אז תראה כי ברגע קטן עזבתיך וזהו יעלה ויבא זכרוננו כו׳. שאינו אלא זכר בעלמא.
that is, when His G‑dliness is revealed, then you will see that “for a brief moment I forsook you.” And this is [the meaning of] “May our remembrance rise and come,” etc.: that it is merely a remembrance.
When G‑dliness is revealed at the ingathering, it will be seen that the exile was only “a brief moment.” The Alter Rebbe connects this to the prayer “May our remembrance rise and come” (Ya’aleh VeYavo): what is spoken of there is merely a remembrance, in keeping with all of time being as a moment before G‑d.
The verses on the exile as “a brief moment” and a thousand years as a day show that all of time is as a moment before G‑d, a truth that will be seen openly when G‑dliness is revealed in the Time to Come.
Marei mekomos
- 1ברגע קטן עזבתיך · Isaiah 54:7
- 2כי אלף שנים כיום . . ואשמורה בלילה · Psalms 90:4
- 3עין בעין יראו · Isaiah 52:8
- 4וראו כל בשר · Isaiah 40:5
8וכשישים האדם הדברים האלה על לבו שכל העולם הוא תחת הזמן והזמן הוא נחשב כרגע לפניו ית׳
And when a person takes these matters to heart — that the whole world is subject to time, and time counts as a moment before Him, may He be blessed,
The Alter Rebbe now draws the conclusion of the contemplation described above. A person should take to heart that the whole world is bound by time, and that all of time is like a single moment before G‑d.
שהוא למעלה מהזמן ואין לפניו שום התחלקות זמן כלל והיתה בלבו כיקוד אש בוערת ותכלה נפשו לדבקה בו ית׳ וזהו תשובה קדמה לעולם.1
who is above time, and before Him there is no division of time whatever — then it will be in his heart like a blaze of burning fire, and his soul will expire [with longing] to cleave to Him, may He be blessed. And this is [the meaning of] “teshuvah preceded the world.”
G‑d is above time altogether, and before Him there is no past, present or future. When a person truly absorbs this, his heart burns like fire and his soul longs to the point of expiry to cleave to G‑d; this, the Alter Rebbe says, is what the Sages meant by “teshuvah preceded the world.”
שאין הפי׳ שהיתה קודם בריאת העולם. שאם אין עולם אין עון אשר חטא ואין תשובה.
For the meaning is not that it existed before the creation of the world: if there is no world, there is no iniquity that one has committed, and there is no teshuvah.
The saying cannot mean that teshuvah existed before creation in time: without a world there is no sin, and so no teshuvah. It must speak of the level of teshuvah, not of its date.
אלא הענין שהתשובה בכלות הנפש הוא למעלה מהזמן והעולם.2 שהוא לדבקה בו ית׳ באור א״ס ב״ה שאין לפניו שום התחלקות זמן כלל.
Rather, the point is that teshuvah with the soul’s expiry (kelos hanefesh) is above time and the world, for it is to cleave to Him, may He be blessed, to the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, before whom there is no division of time at all.
Teshuvah with kelos hanefesh is “before the world” in the sense that it is above time and the world: the soul seeks to cleave to the Infinite Light, before which there is no division of time at all.
שמחמת התבוננות הזה בא לידי תשובה בכלות הנפש ועמ״ש בד״ה שיר השירים3 כמ״ש אני הוי׳ לא שניתי ואתם בני יעקב לא כליתם4 פי׳ שאין לכם כלות הנפש הרי שכלות הנפש הוא מחמת לא שניתי.
For as a result of this contemplation he comes to teshuvah with the soul’s expiry. And see what is written in the discourse beginning “The Song of Songs”: as it is written, “I, Havayah, have not changed, and you, children of Yaakov, have not expired” — that is, you do not have the soul’s expiry. Thus the soul’s expiry comes about because of “I have not changed.”
It is the contemplation of G‑d’s timelessness that brings a person to this teshuvah. Referring to his discourse on “The Song of Songs,” the Alter Rebbe reads Malachi’s verse as a reproach: “I, Havayah, have not changed,” yet “you, children of Yaakov, have not expired,” that is, have not come to kelos hanefesh; the knowledge that G‑d is unchanged by creation is what should bring the soul to expire in longing.
Contemplating that G‑d is beyond time, while the world and all its time are as a moment before Him, kindles kelos hanefesh, a teshuvah that is itself above time and the world. This is the true meaning of “teshuvah preceded the world.”
In the discourse on “The Song of Songs” to which the Alter Rebbe refers, the bride (kallah) is read from kilayon, “consuming”: the soul’s longing that consumes everything else, which is kelos hanefesh. Paragraph 19 returns to Malachi’s verse at length.
Marei mekomos
- 1תשובה קדמה לעולם · Pesachim 54a:8–9
- 2למעלה מהזמן והעולם · ראה אוה״ת וישב רסו, א.
- 3בד״ה שיר השירים · Song of Songs 1:1
- 4אני הוי׳ לא שניתי ואתם בני יעקב לא כליתם · Malachi 3:6
9ועי״ז ימשיך אלקותו בעולם להיות לו דירה בתחתונים12 [ומוסיף אור באצילות] כמ״ש ושמרתם את כל מצותי3 ועשיתם אותם4 אתם כתיב חסר וי״ו וארז״ל [ואמרו רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] א״ת [אל תקרי] אותם אלא אתם5 מעלה עליהם הכתוב כאלו עשאוני.
And through this he will draw His G‑dliness down into the world, so that He will have a dwelling place among the lower realms [and he adds light in the World of Atzilus (Emanation)], as it is written, “And you shall keep all My commandments and do them (osam)”: it is written atem, without a vav, and our Sages, of blessed memory, said, “Do not read osam (‘them’) but atem (‘you’): Scripture accounts it to them as though they had made Me.”
Through such teshuvah a person draws G‑dliness down into the world and makes for G‑d “a dwelling place among the lower realms,” the purpose of creation; a bracket adds that it also adds light in Atzilus. The Sages read the verse’s “do them” (osam), written without a vav, as atem, “you”: one who keeps the mitzvos is regarded as though he had “made” G‑d, that is, made His presence manifest below.
וכתיב (תהלים י״ו) שויתי ה׳ וגו׳. שהוא פי׳ כמו עשיתי כמו הוד והדר תשוה עליו6 (בתהלים כ״א).
And it is written (Psalms 16), “I have set (shivisi) Havayah,” etc., which means “I have made,” as in “Majesty and splendor You set (teshaveh) upon him” (in Psalms 21).
So too King David’s “I have set (shivisi) Havayah [before me always]” means “I have made,” for the same verb appears in “Majesty and splendor You set (teshaveh) upon him.” David’s service made G‑d present before him.
והיינו כמ״ש ויעש דוד שם7 שכל עיקר כוונתו היה בתורתו ובתפלתו לעשות שם [וע׳ מזה בזהר פ׳ בחקתי דקי״ג א׳ ב׳]:8
And this is as it is written, “And David made a name”: for the whole main intent of his Torah and his prayer was to make a name [and see on this in the Zohar, Parshas Bechukosai, 113a–b].
This is the meaning of “And David made a name”: the whole intent of David’s Torah study and prayer was to “make” G‑d’s Name, to reveal it below. The Alter Rebbe refers to the Zohar on Bechukosai, which explains the verse this way.
Teshuvah that rises above time also draws G‑dliness down, making a dwelling place for G‑d below. The Sages’ reading of “do them” as “you,” David’s “I have set Havayah” and “David made a name” all express how a person’s service “makes” G‑d’s presence in the world.
The Zohar (3:113a) asks why the verse adds “and do them” after “walk” and “keep,” and answers that one who keeps the mitzvos is “as though he made Him above”; in the same way David, by walking in the ways of the Torah and praising G‑d at midnight, “made a name above.” Kehot also cites Vayikra Rabbah 35:7 for this reading.
Marei mekomos
- 1דירה בתחתונים · Bamidbar Rabbah 13:8
- 2להיות לו דירה בתחתונים · Midrash Tanchuma, Nasso 16:1
- 3ושמרתם את כל מצותי · שמות כב, לא. מכאן ואילך ראה מאמרי אדה״ז הקצרים ע׳ קל. מאמרי אדה״ז על פרשיות התורה פ׳ קדושים ע׳ תקסה.
- 4ושמרתם את כל מצותי ועשיתם אותם · Leviticus 22:31
- 5א״ת אותם אלא אתם · Zohar III, 113a
- 6
- 7ויעש דוד שם · II Samuel 8:13
- 8
The letters of the Name and the unification ¶10–12
10ב ולהבין זה צריך להבין פי׳ לשם יחוד קוב״ה [קודשא בריך הוא] שנתייסד קודם התפלה ליחדא שם י״ה בו״ה ביחודא שלים וגם להבין פי׳ אותיות של שם הוי׳ ב״ה דהנה היו״ד מורה על הצמצום
2. To understand this, one must understand the meaning of “For the sake of the unification of the Holy One, blessed be He,” which was instituted before prayer, “to unite the Name yud-hei with vav-hei in perfect unity”; and also understand the meaning of the letters of the Name Havayah, blessed be He. Now, the yud indicates the tzimtzum (contraction),
A new section explains how this unification comes about. Before prayer one says the formula “For the sake of the unification of the Holy One, blessed be He… to unite the Name yud-hei with vav-hei in perfect unity,” and to understand it one must understand the four letters of the Name Havayah, the first of which, the yud, signifies tzimtzum, contraction.
כי עיקר התורה והמצות להיות לו דירה בתחתונים וכל העולמות עליונים ותחתונים הם בזמן שהוא כרגע לפניו ית׳1 כו׳ וצריך לזה כמה בחי׳ וצמצומים והשתלשלות שיהיה בחי׳ זמן.
for the main purpose of the Torah and the mitzvos is that He should have a dwelling place among the lower realms, and all the worlds, upper and lower, are within time, which is as a moment before Him, may He be blessed, etc. For this, many levels and contractions and the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus) are needed, so that there will be the dimension of time.
The purpose of the Torah and mitzvos is a dwelling place for G‑d below, yet all the worlds exist within time, which is no more than a moment before Him. For G‑d’s light to relate to time at all, many levels, contractions and stages of descent are needed, and the yud stands for this.
To explain how G‑d’s unity is revealed below, the Alter Rebbe turns to the letters of the Name Havayah, beginning with the yud: the contraction needed so that worlds in time can exist.
Kehot quotes the parallel wording in Maamarei Admur HaZaken HaKetzarim: “For the world is in time, and how can He, who is above time and the world, dwell there? But it is through the tzimtzum by which He contracted Himself.”
Marei mekomos
- 1וכל העולמות עליונים . . כרגע לפניו ית׳ · במאמרי אדה״ז הקצרים ע׳ קל הלשון ”דהנה העולם הוא בזמן ואיך יכול הוא ית׳ לדור שם שהוא למעלה מהזמן והעולם, אמנם הוא ע״י צמצום שצמצם א״ע”. וראה במאמרי אדה״ז פרשיות פ׳ אמור ע׳ תקסה.
11ובחי׳ הצמצומים היינו שיסלק בחי׳ עצמותו מכל וכל שהיא בחי׳ א״ס וישרה בזמן וגבול ועמ,ש מזה בד״ה ולא אבה1 בפ׳
The level of the contractions means that He withdraws the level of His essence altogether, which is the level of the Infinite One (Ein Sof), and rests in time and limitation; and see what is written on this in the discourse beginning “And He would not,” in Parshas
The tzimtzum means that G‑d withdraws His very essence, the Infinite, altogether, so that His light can rest within time and limitation. The Alter Rebbe refers to his discourse “And He would not,” in Parshas Ki Seitzei, for more on this.
כי תצא ואח״כ בחי׳ ה׳ שהוא התפשטות אורך ורוחב ואח״כ ו׳ שהוא המשכה בשמי׳ [בשמים] ממעל
Ki Seitzei. Afterwards [comes] the level of the hei, which is expansion in length and breadth; and afterwards the vav, which is a drawing down “in the heavens above
Next comes the first hei, an expansion in length and breadth, and then the vav, a line drawn downward, in the words of the verse, “in the heavens above and on the earth below.”
ועל הארץ מתחת ולד׳ סטרין בחינת ו״ק [ו׳ קצוות] [וגם שמים רוחניים שהם בחי׳ אהבה ויראה כו׳ אש ומים2 כו׳]
and on the earth below,” and to the four directions, the level of the six extremities (vav ketzavos) [and also the spiritual heavens, which are the levels of love and awe, etc., fire and water, etc.].
The vav, whose numerical value is six, also extends to the four directions and so corresponds to the six extremities (vav ketzavos), the six emotive attributes. A bracket adds the “spiritual heavens,” love and awe, which are fire and water, for the Sages read shamayim (heavens) as esh u’mayim, fire and water.
וזהו בחי׳ הוי״ו שהוא המשכת אלקותו ממעלה למטה ואח״כ בחינת ה׳ תתאה וכן בכל השתלשלות העולמות מעולם ועד עולם נעשה צמצום והתפשטות המשכה והתפשטות
This is the level of the vav, which is the drawing down of His G‑dliness from above to below; and afterwards the level of the lower hei. And so too in the whole chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus), from world to world, there is contraction and expansion, drawing down and expansion.
The vav is the drawing down of G‑dliness from above to below, and after it comes the lower, final hei. The same pattern of contraction, expansion and drawing down repeats at every stage of the descent from one world to the next.
ולכן נק׳ עולם מלשון העלם שהעלים והסתיר עצמותו ית׳ וזהו תשובה קדמה לעולם [ועמ״ש מענין התשובה בד״ה כי המצוה הזאת אשר אנכי מצוך3 כו׳
This is why it is called olam (world), from the word he’elem (concealment), for He concealed and hid His essence, may He be blessed. And this is [the meaning of] “teshuvah preceded the world” [and see what is written on the subject of teshuvah in the discourse beginning “For this commandment which I command you,” etc.;
That is why a world is called olam, from he’elem, concealment: each world exists because G‑d’s essence is hidden from it. Teshuvah “preceded the world” in that it reaches what is before this concealment; a bracket opens here, referring to the discourse on “For this commandment which I command you.”
ע״ש ובמדרש בראשית רבה שם איתא שנאמר בטרם הרים יולדו4 מאותה השעה תשב אנוש56 כו׳ והיינו כמו שכתוב בד״ה כי ההרים ימושו7 כו׳
see there. And in the Midrash Bereshis Rabbah there, it says: “as it is said, ‘Before the mountains were born’; from that very hour, ‘You return man,’” etc. And this is as is written in the discourse beginning “For the mountains may depart,” etc.,
The bracket continues with the Midrash already cited, which learns teshuvah’s precedence from “Before the mountains were born… You return man,” and refers to the discourse on Isaiah’s “For the mountains may depart” for further explanation.
וחסדי מאתך לא ימוש כו׳ אמר מרחמך הוי׳ שזה הפסוק מדבר בגילוי רחמים גדולים לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] ע״י התשובה ואזי ההרים ימושו כו׳ ע״ש והיינו לפי
“but My kindness shall not depart from you,” etc., “says Havayah, who has compassion on you”: this verse speaks of the revelation of great compassion in the Time to Come through teshuvah, and then “the mountains may depart,” etc.; see there. And this is because
That verse ends, “but My kindness shall not depart from you… says Havayah, who has compassion on you,” and it speaks of the great compassion that will be revealed in the Time to Come through teshuvah; then even “the mountains may depart.”
כי התשובה היא מבחי׳ ומדרגת בטרם הרים יולדו שקדמה לעולם שהיא גילוי מבחי׳ אנכי מי שאנכי כו׳ שלמעלה מבחי׳ הצמצומים דשם הוי׳ להיות עולם והעלם
teshuvah is from the level and rank of “before the mountains were born,” which preceded the world: it is a revelation from the level of “I am who I am” (Anochi mi she’Anochi), etc., which is above the level of the contractions of the Name Havayah, so that there be a world (olam) and concealment (he’elem),
The reason is that teshuvah comes from the level of “before the mountains were born,” before the world: a revelation from “I am who I am” (Anochi mi she’Anochi), G‑d’s own self, above the contractions of the Name Havayah that make a world and its concealment.
דהיינו למעלה אפילו מעולם האצילות שמקבל מבחי׳ היו״ד דשם הוי׳] וזהו פי׳ היחוד שיהיה יחיד ומיוחד אחר הצמצום וההתפשטות כמו קודם
that is, above even the World of Atzilus (Emanation), which receives from the level of the yud of the Name Havayah]. And this is the meaning of the unification: that He be single and unique after the contraction and the expansion just as prior
This level is above even the World of Atzilus, which receives from the yud of Havayah, the first contraction; here the bracket closes. The “unification” of the prayer formula means that G‑d is revealed as single and unique after the contraction and expansion just as before them.
to it, without any change. But in this world the unification is not complete until the days of Mashiach, for then “they will see eye to eye,” etc., and “all flesh will see,” etc.
In this world that unity will be complete only in the days of Mashiach, when “they will see eye to eye” and “all flesh will see.”
But in the upper worlds one can effect the unification even now, so that His unity will be revealed. And this is [the meaning of] “And appear in the splendor of the majesty of Your might.”
In the upper worlds the unification can be effected even now, so that G‑d’s unity is revealed there. This is what is asked in the Rosh Hashanah prayer, “And appear in the splendor of the majesty of Your might.”
פי׳ שיאירו היודי״ן והווי״ן שהם בחי׳ צמצומים והתשלשלות המשכות והארת אור עליון [ע׳ [עיין] בשער היחודים
That is, that the yuds and vavs should shine — they being the levels of the contractions and of hishtalshelus, the drawings-down and the radiance of the supernal light [see Shaar HaYichudim,
The “splendor of the majesty” is the shining of the yuds and vavs, the letters that stand for the contractions and the descending flow of the supernal light. The Alter Rebbe cites Sha’ar HaYichudim, from the Arizal’s teachings, and the Kabbalistic work Mishnas Chassidim for this.
פ״ז [פרק ז׳] ובמ״ח מסכת היחודים פ״ד] אור א״ס ב״ה יאירו גם למטה מטה אפי׳ [אפילו] בעוה״ז עד כי וידע כל פעול כו׳ דקאי על כל הברואים.
chapter 7, and Mishnas Chassidim, Tractate HaYichudim, chapter 4], the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He — that they should shine even far below, even in this world, until “every creature will know,” etc., which refers to all created beings.
The prayer asks that the Infinite Light shine through these channels even far below, in this world, until “every creature will know” that G‑d made it. These words, the Alter Rebbe notes, refer to all created beings.
The letters of Havayah map the descent of G‑d’s light: yud, the contraction; hei, expansion; vav, the drawing down; and the final hei. Teshuvah reaches the level before all this, “before the mountains were born,” and the unification sought is that G‑d be revealed as single after the contractions just as before them: possible now in the upper worlds, and in this world in the days of Mashiach.
Kehot quotes the Tzemach Tzedek’s Or HaTorah: the revelation of the Infinite Light below just as above is what is called “the unification of the Holy One, blessed be He.” The Ki Seitzei discourse that the Alter Rebbe cites explains that Chochmah comes into being from the Infinite Light only as a tiny, contracted glimmer, after G‑d’s essence has been hidden, just as hair grows from the skull that covers the brain.
Marei mekomos
- 1ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה ולא אבה · לעיל לח, ד.
- 2שמים . . אש ומים · Chagigah 12a:19–20
- 3כי המצוה הזאת אשר אנכי מצוך · Deuteronomy 30:11
- 4בטרם הרים יולדו · Psalms 90:2
- 5תשב אנוש · Psalms 90:3
- 6בטרם הרים יולדו מאותה השעה תשב אנוש · Bereshit Rabbah 1:4
- 7כי ההרים ימושו · Isaiah 54:10
- 8עין בעין יראו · Isaiah 52:8
- 9וראו כל בשר · Isaiah 40:5
- 10וזהו פי׳ היחיד . . שיתגלה יחודו · באוה״ת בהעלותך שלז: ור״ל שיהי׳ גילוי אוא״ס למטה כמו למעלה ממש זהו נק׳ יחוד קוב״ה. ראה אוה״ת נ״ך כרך ב ע׳ תתקכא שמביא קטע מכאן.
- 11והופע בהדר גאון עוזך · בתפלת שמ״ע לר״ה.
12וסוף המאמר מוכיח שהכל ידעו וישיגו אלקותו ית׳ כי אפס זולתו שזהו לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] שכ״כ [שכל כך] יאיר ויתגלה אור א״ס ב״ה עד שיהא נתפס ג״כ בשכל האנושי1 ומושג בהשגה גשמיי׳ [גשמיים].
And the end of the passage proves that all will know and apprehend His G‑dliness, may He be blessed, that there is nothing besides Him. This will be in the Time to Come, when the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, will shine and be revealed so greatly that it will be grasped also by the human intellect and apprehended with physical apprehension.
The end of that prayer passage shows that in the Time to Come all will know and grasp G‑dliness, that there is nothing besides Him. The Infinite Light will then shine so strongly that even the human mind, and physical perception, will grasp it.
משא״כ בזמן שאין גילוי אור א״ס אלא בנפש אלקית של עובדי ה׳. ואף גם זאת אינה בבחי׳ השגה אלא בבחי׳ אמונה אשר היא ירושה מאבות.2
Whereas at a time when the Infinite Light is revealed only in the G‑dly soul of those who serve G‑d; and even this is not in the manner of apprehension, but in the manner of faith, which is an inheritance from the forefathers.
Now, by contrast, the Infinite Light is revealed only in the G‑dly soul of those who serve G‑d, and even there not as understanding but as faith, inherited from the Patriarchs. The Sages call the Jewish people “believers, children of believers.”
ולכן כתיב לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] כשיתגלה אור א״ס ב״ה ובאו במערות צורים3 ובמחילות עפר מפני פחד ה׳ ומהדר גאונו. דהיינו מחמת גילוי בחי׳ הדר גאון עוזך שהן היודי״ן והווי״ן הנ״ל
This is why it is written of the Time to Come, when the Infinite Light, blessed be He, will be revealed: “And they will go into the caves of the rocks and into the holes of the earth, from before the terror of Havayah and from the splendor of His majesty”; that is, because of the revelation of the level of “the splendor of the majesty of Your might,” which are the yuds and vavs mentioned above
This is why Isaiah says of the Time to Come that people will hide “in the caves of the rocks… from before the terror of Havayah and from the splendor of His majesty.” That “splendor of majesty” is the revelation of the yuds and vavs described above.
(ולשון הדר גאונו יובן ע״ד מ״ש במ״א בפי׳ כי גאה גאה4 כו׳ ומשם הוא המשכת היודי״ן ווי״ן הנ״ל להיות הגילוי אחר הצמצומים כמו קודם הצמצומים וזהו ממעמקים קראתיך5 הוי׳ כמ״ש בד״ה שובה ישראל עד6 ואזי)
(the phrase “the splendor of His majesty” will be understood along the lines of what is written elsewhere on the meaning of “For He is exalted, exalted,” etc.; and from there comes the drawing down of the yuds and vavs mentioned above, so that the revelation after the contractions is as it was before the contractions; and this is [the meaning of] “From the depths I have called You, Havayah,” as is written in the discourse beginning “Return, O Israel, unto”) — and then
A parenthesis explains “the splendor of His majesty” by “For He is exalted, exalted” (ga’oh ga’ah) of the Song at the Sea, discussed elsewhere: from that level come the yuds and vavs, so that the revelation after the contractions is as it was before them. This is also the meaning of “From the depths I have called You, Havayah,” as explained in the discourse beginning “Return, O Israel, unto.” With the parenthesis closed, the sentence resumes: “and then” terror will fall.
תפול אימה ופחד7 בגשמיי׳ [בגשמיים] ממש מן המראה הגדול הזה8 אשר יראו כל בשר וישיגו פועל אלקים בקרב הארץ הלזו הגשמיות בשכל אנושי הגשמי. שלא יהא גשמיות העולם והאדם מעלים ומסתיר על אור ה׳:
terror and dread will fall in a truly physical way, from this great sight that all flesh will see, and they will apprehend the work of G‑d in the midst of this physical earth with the physical human intellect, so that the physicality of the world and of man will not conceal and hide the light of G‑d.
When this is revealed, awe will be felt physically at the great sight that all flesh will see: people will grasp G‑d’s work in this physical world with their physical intellect. The physicality of the world and of man will no longer hide G‑d’s light.
In the Time to Come the Infinite Light will be revealed so fully that even the physical mind will grasp it and even the body will feel awe, whereas now it reaches only the G‑dly soul, and only as faith.
The phrase “terror and dread will fall” echoes the Song at the Sea (Exodus 15:16), where awe falls on the nations at the sight of G‑d’s might. Kehot cites Shabbos 97a, where the Jewish people are called “believers, children of believers,” for the faith inherited from the Patriarchs.
Marei mekomos
- 1שיהא נתפס ג״כ בשכל האנושי · ראה אוה״ת פ׳ שמות ע׳ פד שמציין לכאן. ראה גם באוה״ת בראשית נ, א.
- 2אמונה אשר היא ירושה מאבות · Shabbat 97a:4
- 3ובאו במערות צורים · Isaiah 2:19
- 4כי גאה גאה · Exodus 15:1
- 5ממעמקים קראתיך הוי׳ · Psalms 130:1
- 6שובה ישראל עד · Hosea 14:2
- 7תפול אימה ופחד · Exodus 15:16
- 8המראה הגדול הזה · Exodus 3:3
Supernal kindness for the lowly ¶13–16
13ג והנה גילוי יחוד זה שיתגלה אור א״ס ב״ה שלפני ההשתלשלות ולמעלה מן הזמן למטה בסדר ההשתלשלות שתחלת הזמן הוא מתגלה
3. Now, the revelation of this unification — that the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, which is before the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus) and above time, be revealed below in the order of hishtalshelus — its beginning in time is revealed
A new section begins. The unification described above, the revelation below of the Infinite Light that is before the chain of worlds and above time, will be complete only in the Time to Come, but its beginning is revealed already now.
בבע״ת [בבעלי תשובה] ששב אל ה׳ בכל נפשו ומאודו בכלות הנפש מעומקא דלבא כי ע״י התשובה זו נמשך לו הארה מלמעלה מאור א״ס שלפני ההשתלשלות ולמעלה מהזמן
in the penitent (baal teshuvah) who returns to G‑d with all his soul and all his might, with the soul’s expiry (kelos hanefesh), from the depth of the heart. For through this teshuvah a radiance is drawn down to him from above, from the Infinite Light that is before hishtalshelus and above time
It is revealed in the baal teshuvah who returns to G‑d with all his soul and might, with kelos hanefesh from the depth of his heart. Such teshuvah draws down to him a radiance from the Infinite Light that is above the chain of worlds and above time.
(שהוא בחי׳ המתנשא מימות עולם כלומר שהוא מרומם למעלה מעלה מבחי׳ ומדרגת ימי עולם וימות עולם וכמ״ש מזה בד״ה אתם נצבים1 והיינו שבחינת ימות עולם הם מקור ושרש הזמן.
(which is the level of “He who is exalted above the days of the world,” meaning that He is exalted far, far above the level and rank of “the days of the world” (yemei olam, yemos olam), as is written about this in the discourse beginning “You are standing”; that is, the level of “the days of the world” is the source and root of time.
A parenthesis describes this level with the words of the morning prayers, “He who is exalted above the days of the world”: G‑d is far above even the “days of the world,” the supernal attributes that are the source and root of time. The Alter Rebbe refers to his discourse on “You are standing” for more.
ונק׳ אלף שנים בעיניך כיום2 כו׳ שאף שיום זה אינו בבחי׳ זמן ממש מאחר שכולל אלף שנים כאחת עכ״ז [עם כל זה] הוא מקור ושרש לבחי׳ זמן
And it is called “A thousand years in Your eyes are like a day,” etc.: for although this “day” is not actually in the dimension of time, since it includes a thousand years as one, nevertheless it is the source and root of the dimension of time,
These supernal “days” are what the psalm means by “A thousand years in Your eyes are like a day.” Such a “day” is not time as we know it, since it holds a thousand years as one, yet it is the source and root of time.
ולכן נק׳ ימות עולם אבל הוא ית׳ בעצמו הוא מתנשא ומרומם לאין קץ מבחי׳ יומין אלו כי הוא למעלה מהזמן לגמרי)
and therefore it is called “the days of the world.” But He Himself, may He be blessed, is exalted and lifted infinitely above the level of these “days,” for He is altogether above time).
That is why they are called “the days of the world.” G‑d Himself is infinitely above even these “days,” for He is entirely beyond time; here the parenthesis closes.
ולזאת על ידי המשכת הארה זו גם האדם ימאס חיי הזמן לדבקה באור א״ס ב״ה עצמו ממש כנ״ל.
Therefore, through the drawing down of this radiance, the person too will despise the life of time, so as to cleave to the very Infinite Light, blessed be He, itself, as mentioned above.
Through this radiance the penitent himself comes to despise a life bound by time and longs to cleave to the Infinite Light itself, as described in paragraph 8.
ואף מי שאין דעתו יפה כ״כ [כל כך] לדבקה בו מחמת גדולת ורוממות א״ס ב״ה ממש רק שצר לו
And even one whose mind is not so refined as to cleave to Him because of the greatness and exaltedness of the Infinite One (Ein Sof), blessed be He, Himself, but is only pained by
The Alter Rebbe now considers a person whose understanding is not refined enough to be moved by contemplating G‑d’s greatness. What moves him is only the pain of his own situation.
מקומו ושעתו שנמשך אחר הבלי הזמן ובחשך שמו יכוסה3 ומכיר ערכו ושפלותו ונעשה נבזה בעיניו נמאס4 מחמת שנק׳ רע ומנווול כו׳.
his place and his time — that he has been drawn after the vanities of time, and “his name is covered in darkness” — and he recognizes his worth and his lowliness, and becomes “despicable in his own eyes, repulsive,” because he is called bad and repulsive, etc. —
He is pained by his place and his time, having been drawn after the vanities of time so that, in Koheles’s words, “his name is covered in darkness.” Recognizing his true standing and lowliness, he becomes “despicable in his own eyes, repulsive,” as the psalm says, because he sees that he is called bad and repulsive.
עכ״ז [עם כל זה] מאחר שמואס בחייו חיי הזמן נמשך עליו מאליו וממילא חסד ה׳ להיות בו גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה שלפני ההשתלשלות ולמעלה מן הזמן
nevertheless, since he despises his life, the life of time, G‑d’s kindness is drawn upon him of itself, as a matter of course, so that there is in him a revelation of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, that is before hishtalshelus and above time.
Even so, because he despises his life in time, G‑d’s kindness comes to him of its own accord and reveals in him the Infinite Light that is above the chain of worlds and above time.
כי גדול כח החסד עליון שמתפשט לאין קץ ותכלית וכמים היורדים ממקום גבהו למקום נמוך מאד.
For great is the power of the supernal kindness, which spreads without end or limit, like water that descends from its high place to a very low place.
This is the power of the supernal kindness described at the opening of the maamar: it spreads without limit, like water that flows from a height down to the lowest place.
The unification that will be complete in the Time to Come begins already in the baal teshuvah, whose kelos hanefesh draws down a radiance from the Infinite Light above time. Even one who cannot contemplate G‑d’s greatness, but despises his life because he sees how low he has fallen, draws the supernal kindness to himself, for kindness flows like water to the lowest place.
The Idra Rabba (Zohar 3:134b), to which the Alter Rebbe refers in the next paragraph, distinguishes the “days of old” (yemei kedem), the tikkunim of the beard of the Ancient of Ancients, from the “days of the world” (yemei olam), those found in Z’eir Anpin. The Alter Rebbe explains that these supernal “days of the world” are the root of time, while G‑d Himself is exalted above them.
Marei mekomos
- 1אתם נצבים · Deuteronomy 29:9
- 2אלף שנים בעיניך כיום · Psalms 90:4
- 3ובחשך שמו יכוסה · Ecclesiastes 6:4
- 4נבזה בעיניו נמאס · Psalms 15:4
14ואדרבה במקום שנמוך מאד שם הם מתקבצים יותר כך החסד עליון נמשך ומתפשט דוקא במקום נמוך
On the contrary: in a place that is very low, there they gather the more. So too the supernal kindness is drawn down and spreads specifically in a low place,
Water does not merely reach low places; it gathers most in the lowest. So the supernal kindness spreads specifically in a “low place.”
דהיינו במי שהוא שפל ונבזה בעיניו נמאס וגם הליות בחי׳ חסד ורחמים אינו נופל אלא על מי שהוא צריך לחסד ורחמנות וכמשל מי
that is, in one who is lowly and “despicable in his own eyes, repulsive.” And also, since the level of kindness and compassion applies only to one who needs kindness and compassion — as in the example of one
That “low place” is a person who is humble and despicable in his own eyes. Moreover, kindness and compassion by their nature go only to one who needs them, and the Alter Rebbe gives an example (the printed הליות is evidently להיות).
שהוא תפוס בבית האסורים שאינו יכול לחזור על הפתחים נתעורר החסד והרחמנות בלבות בני האדם עליו עד שמביאין לו לחם ומזון לבית המאסר וכך הוא
who is held in prison and cannot go begging from door to door: kindness and compassion toward him are aroused in people’s hearts, until they bring him bread and food in the prison. And so it is
When a person is locked in prison and cannot even go begging from door to door, people’s hearts fill with compassion and they bring him bread and food in the prison.
למעלה בחסד עליון שנמשך מאליו וממילא על האדם שצר לו מאד במה שנתפס במאסר הגוף והנפש הבהמית עד שיחפץ וישתוקק מאד להתפשט מלבושים צואים כו׳
above, with the supernal kindness, which is drawn of itself, as a matter of course, upon a person who is in great distress at being held in the prison of the body and the animal soul, so that he wishes and yearns greatly to strip off the filthy garments, etc.,
So too above: the supernal kindness comes of itself to one who suffers at being imprisoned in the body and the animal soul and longs to strip off its “filthy garments,” the image from Zechariah’s vision of the High Priest Yehoshua.
וחייו אינם חיים בעיניו ולזאת מעורר רחמים רבים מלמעלה עד שנמשך עליו חיים וחסד מלמעלה ממקור החיים וחיי החיים א״ס ב״ה ממש
and his life is no life in his eyes. Therefore he arouses great compassion from above, until life and kindness are drawn upon him from above, from the source of life and the Life of all life, the Infinite One, blessed be He, Himself.
His life seems no life to him, and this arouses great compassion above, until life and kindness flow to him from the very source of life, the Infinite One.
וזהו מי אל כמוך1 שבחי׳ אל הוא בחי׳ חסד ואין החסד שיהיה כחסד עליון המתפשט
And this is [the meaning of] “Who is a G‑d (Kel) like You”: for the level of Kel is the level of Chesed (kindness), and there is no kindness like the supernal kindness, which spreads
This is the meaning of “Who is a G‑d (Kel) like You”: Kel is kindness, and no kindness compares with the supernal kindness.
לאין קץ ותכלית מרום המעלות מאור א״ס ב״ה ממש עד מדרגות התחתונות שמעשי׳ [שמעשיה] הגשמי׳ [הגשמיים / הגשמיות / הגשמית] להחיות רוח שפלים2 אשר אסורים במאסר הגוף הגשמי.
without end or limit, from the highest of heights, from the Infinite Light, blessed be He, itself, down to the lowest levels of the physical World of Asiyah (Action), “to revive the spirit of the lowly” who are bound in the prison of the physical body.
It flows without limit from the highest heights, the Infinite Light itself, down to the lowest levels of physical Asiyah, “to revive the spirit of the lowly” (Isaiah) who are imprisoned in physical bodies.
(ובאדרא) (דקל״ב א׳) ורזא דכתיב מי אל כמוך בעתיק יומין אתמר.3 פי׳ עתיק יומין היינו בחי׳ המתנשא מימות עולם
(And in the Idra) (132a): “And the secret of what is written, ‘Who is a G‑d (Kel) like You,’ was said of Atik Yomin.” The meaning of Atik Yomin is the level of “He who is exalted above the days of the world,”
The Zohar’s Idra Rabba says that “Who is a G‑d like You” refers to Atik Yomin, “the Ancient of Days.” The Alter Rebbe identifies Atik Yomin with “He who is exalted above the days of the world” of the previous paragraph.
כי עתיק מלשון המעתיק הרים4 כלומר שנעתק ומרומם מבחינת ימות עולם וע״ ש (דקל״ד ב׳).
for atik is from the expression “who removes (ha’ma’atik) mountains”; that is, He is removed and exalted from the level of “the days of the world.” And see there (134b).
The word atik is related to “who removes (ha’ma’atik) mountains” in Job: Atik Yomin is removed and exalted above the “days of the world,” the source of time. The Idra speaks of those “days” further on 134b.
וזהו אל עליון גומל חסדים טובים כי אל היינו ע״ש [על שם] התלבשות אור א״ס ב״ה במדת החסד כמ״ש חסד אל כל היום5 ואית חסד ואית חסד
And this is [the meaning of] “the most high Kel, who bestows good kindnesses”: for He is called Kel on account of the enclothing of the Infinite Light, blessed be He, in the attribute of Chesed, as it is written, “The kindness of Kel is all the day.” And there is chesed and there is chesed:
This also explains the words of the first blessing of the Amidah, “the most high Kel, who bestows good kindnesses.” G‑d is called Kel because the Infinite Light is enclothed in Chesed, but there are two kinds of chesed.
that is, outer chesed (chesed de’lebar), which is called “kindness of the world” (chesed olam); and in the enclothing of the Infinite Light so that there be a world — “the world is built by kindness” — He is called “Kel of the world” (Kel olam).
Outer chesed is “kindness of the world” (chesed olam), the kindness that builds the world, as in “the world is built by kindness.” As the Infinite Light is enclothed in it to create the world, G‑d is called “Kel of the world” (Kel olam), the name by which Avraham called Him.
אך חסד דלגאו שע״ז נאמר ובחסד עליון בל ימוט8 עליון דייקא שהוא מבחי׳ סוכ״ע זהו פי׳ אל עליון
But inner chesed (chesed de’legav), of which it is said, “and through the supernal kindness (chesed elyon) he will not falter” — “supernal” (elyon) specifically, for it is from the level of the light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin) — this is the meaning of “the most high Kel” (Kel elyon),
Inner chesed is the “supernal kindness” of the verse “through the supernal kindness he will not falter.” It comes from sovev kol almin, the light that encompasses all worlds and is not bounded by them, and it is “the most high Kel” (Kel elyon).
שהוא למעלה מעלה מבחי׳ ומדרגת חסד עולם וע״ז נאמר מי אל כמוך ועמ״ש בד״ה לסוסתי בשיר השירים בענין אדם אדמה לעליון9 כו׳ ע״ש.
which is far, far above the level and rank of chesed olam; and of this it is said, “Who is a G‑d (Kel) like You.” And see what is written in the discourse beginning “To a mare,” in Shir HaShirim, on the subject of adam (man), “I will be likened (adameh) to the Most High,” etc.; see there.
This inner kindness is far above the kindness that builds the world, and it is what Micah means by “Who is a G‑d like You.” The Alter Rebbe refers to his discourse “To a mare” in Shir HaShirim, on man (adam) as one who can be likened (adameh) to the Most High.
Kindness flows to whoever needs it most, like water to the lowest place or food to a prisoner, so the penitent who feels imprisoned by his body draws the supernal kindness from the Infinite One Himself. This supernal, “inner” kindness, from Atik Yomin and from sovev kol almin, is far above the “outer” kindness that builds the world, and it is the kindness meant by “Who is a G‑d like You.”
In the Idra Rabba (Zohar 3:132a), “Who is a G‑d like You” is said of the first tikkun of the holy beard of Atik Yomin, where even Kel, the attribute of strength, yields to the compassion of Atik Yomin. In the Idra the thirteen phrases of Micah’s verses correspond to the thirteen tikkunim of that beard.
Marei mekomos
- 1מי אל כמוך · Micah 7:18
- 2להחיות רוח שפלים · Isaiah 57:15
- 3ורזא דכתיב מי אל כמוך בעתיק יומין אתמר · Zohar, Idra Rabba 11:100–112
- 4המעתיק הרים · Job 9:5
- 5חסד אל כל היום · Psalms 52:3
- 6עולם חסד יבנה · Psalms 89:3
- 7אל עולם · Genesis 21:33
- 8ובחסד עליון בל ימוט · Psalms 21:8
- 9אדמה לעליון · Isaiah 14:14
15והנה מבחי׳ חסד עליון נמשך להיות גומל חסדים טובים שהוא להיות המשכת החסד למטה מטה ועמ״ש סד״ה ועתה יגדל נא כח אד׳1 כו׳
Now, from the level of supernal kindness [it] is drawn down to be “who bestows good kindnesses,” which is the drawing down of kindness far below. And see what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “And now, may the power of Ado-nai be great,” etc.;
From the supernal kindness comes “who bestows good kindnesses,” kindness drawn down to the lowest levels. The Alter Rebbe refers to the end of his discourse on Moshe’s plea “And now, may the power of Ado-nai be great,” which continues, “Havayah is slow to anger and abundant in kindness, bearing iniquity and transgression.”
ועמ״ש ע״פ ויגמול שקדים2 בפרשת קרח ובמ״א ע״פ חסדי ה׳ כי לא תמנו3 כו׳ וע״פ הוי׳ יחתו מריביו4 ועיין מ״ש בביאור ע״פ משה ידבר5 וע׳ בסידור האריז״ל [האר״י זכרונו לברכה] בכוונת אוחילה לאל כו׳.
and see what is written on the verse “and it bore ripe (vayigmol) almonds,” in Parshas Korach; and elsewhere, on the verse “The kindnesses of Havayah, for we are not consumed,” etc., and on the verse “Havayah — His adversaries will be shattered”; and see what is written in the explanation on the verse “Moshe would speak”; and see in the Siddur of the Arizal, of blessed memory, on the intention of “I will hope to Kel,” etc.
He lists further discussions: on Aharon’s staff, which “bore ripe (vayigmol) almonds,” from the same root as gomel, “bestows”; on “The kindnesses of Havayah, for we are not consumed”; on “Havayah — His adversaries will be shattered”; on “Moshe would speak”; and on the Arizal’s kavanah for the High Holiday prayer “I will hope to Kel.”
וע׳ בפי׳ הרמ״ז [הרב משה זכות] ר״פ שמיני בענין ישראל ישר אל וזהו אשריך ישראל מי כמוך6 כו׳
And see in the commentary of the Ramaz (Rabbi Moshe Zacuto) at the beginning of Parshas Shemini, on Yisrael as yashar Kel (“upright toward Kel”); and this is [the meaning of] “Fortunate are you, Israel; who is like you?” etc.
He also cites the Ramaz, Rabbi Moshe Zacuto, who reads Yisrael as yashar Kel, “upright toward Kel,” the attribute of kindness. Hence Moshe’s blessing, “Fortunate are you, Israel; who is like you?”, echoes “Who is a G‑d (Kel) like You?”
ועל דרך זה הוא משארז״ל [מה שאמרו רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] גבי בצלאל בצל אל היית וידעת7 כמ״ש בספר עמ״ה [עמק המלך] שער י״ג פ״מ:8
And along these lines is what our Sages, of blessed memory, said regarding Betzalel: “You were in the shadow of Kel (betzel Kel), and you knew,” as is written in the book Emek HaMelech, Sha’ar 13, chapter 40.
Similarly, the Sages explain Betzalel’s name as “in the shadow of Kel” (betzel Kel): Moshe said to him, “Perhaps you were in the shadow of Kel, and you knew.” The Alter Rebbe cites the Kabbalistic work Emek HaMelech for the explanation.
The supernal kindness is drawn all the way down as “who bestows good kindnesses,” and the Alter Rebbe gathers other places where the Name Kel, kindness, is discussed, among them Israel as yashar Kel and Betzalel as betzel Kel.
Marei mekomos
- 1ועתה יגדל נא כח אד׳ · Numbers 14:17
- 2ויגמול שקדים · Numbers 17:23
- 3חסדי ה׳ כי לא תמנו · Lamentations 3:22
- 4הוי׳ יחתו מריביו · I Samuel 2:10
- 5משה ידבר · Exodus 19:19
- 6אשריך ישראל מי כמוך · Deuteronomy 33:29
- 7בצל אל היית וידעת · Berakhot 55a:12
- 8
16ד אך כיצד יומשך ויתגלה חסד עליון מאור א״ס ב״ה ממש בבע״ת [בבעלי תשובה] שהיה רחוק מאור א״ס בתכלית
4. But how can the supernal kindness, from the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, itself, be drawn down and revealed in a penitent who was utterly far from the Infinite Light?
A new section asks the central question: how can the supernal kindness, from the Infinite Light itself, be revealed in a penitent who was utterly far from that light?
הנה ע״ז אמר הנביא נושא עון ועובר על פשע.1 וביאור הענין דהנה בגמרא איתא פלוגתא מר אמר נושא עון ומר אמר כובש עון.23
To this the prophet said, “He bears iniquity and passes over transgression.” The explanation of the matter: in the Gemara there is a dispute; one Sage says “He bears (nosei) iniquity,” and one Sage says “He suppresses (kovesh) iniquity.”
The prophet answers with “He bears iniquity and passes over transgression.” The Talmud records a dispute about how G‑d deals with sin: one Sage says He “bears” (nosei) it, as in this verse, and another says He “suppresses” (kovesh) it, as in the next verse, “He will suppress our iniquities.”
The question of how boundless kindness can reach one who was far from G‑d is answered through the Talmud’s two readings of how G‑d deals with sin: He “bears” it, and He “suppresses” it.
In the Talmud (Rosh Hashanah 17a) the dispute explains how G‑d, “abundant in kindness,” tips the scales toward kindness: Rabbi Eliezer says He suppresses the sin, and Rabbi Yosi bar Chanina says He bears it. The next paragraph shows that both are true, each of a different part of the sin.
Marei mekomos
- 1נושא עון ועובר על פשע · Micah 7:18
- 2מר אמר נושא עון ומר אמר כובש עון · Rosh Hashanah 17a:12
- 3כובש עון · Micah 7:19
Bearing iniquity and suppressing it ¶17–18
17ושניהם אמת כי הנה מעשה העבירה אשר יעשה האדם לחטוא באחת מכל המצות ל״ת [לא תעשה] או ביטול מ״ע [מצות עשה] הוא רע גמור.1
And both are true. For the act of transgression that a person commits, sinning against any one of the prohibitions, or the neglect of a positive commandment, is complete evil.
Both opinions in the Talmud are true, because a sin has two parts. The act itself, whether violating a prohibition or neglecting a positive commandment, is complete evil.
אך הכח המתאוה לדברים האסורים הוא הממשיך לבו לבטל ממ״ע [ממצות עשה] הנה הכח ההוא אף שהוא מלובש ברע גמור מ״מ אין בכח זה חטא מצד עצמו
But the faculty that desires forbidden things, or that draws his heart to neglect a positive commandment — that faculty, although it is enclothed in complete evil, nevertheless has no sin in itself,
The faculty within a person that desires forbidden things, or that draws his heart away from a mitzvah, is different: though it is enclothed in complete evil, there is no sin in the faculty itself.
שהרי כח המתאוה הוא שוה בין באיסור בין בהיתר וכן כח הממשיך לבו אלא שהטה כח המתאוה כ״כ [כל כך] עד שנתלבש במעשה העבירה או שהטה את כח הממשיך הלב עד שנמשך לסור מ״ע [מצות עשה]
for the faculty of desire is the same whether toward the forbidden or the permitted, and so too the faculty that draws his heart; only that he inclined the faculty of desire so far that it became enclothed in the act of transgression, or he inclined the faculty that draws the heart until it was drawn to turn away from a positive commandment.
Desire as such is neutral; the same faculty desires permitted things as well as forbidden ones. The sin lies only in his having bent it so far that it became enclothed in a forbidden act, or so far that it drew him away from a positive commandment.
אבל מצד כח המתאוה בעצמו הרי יש בכח זה להפוך לבבו מן הקצה אל הקצה מאהבה רעה לאהבת ה׳ וכמ״ש ואהבת בכל לבבך2 בשני יצריך34 שגם היצה״ר [היצר הרע] ישוב לאהבת ה׳.
But as regards the faculty of desire in itself, this faculty has the power to turn his heart from one extreme to the other, from an evil love to the love of G‑d, as it is written, “And you shall love with all your heart (levavecha)”: with both your inclinations, so that the evil inclination too will turn to the love of G‑d.
In itself, then, the power of desire can be turned completely around, from an evil love to the love of G‑d. The Mishnah reads “with all your heart (levavecha),” with its doubled letter beis, as “with both your inclinations,” so that the evil inclination too comes to love G‑d.
The Talmud’s two views, “bears” and “suppresses,” are both true, because a sin has two parts: the act, which is complete evil, and the faculty of desire behind it, which is neutral in itself and can be turned to the love of G‑d.
Kehot points to Tanya ch. 1, which teaches that at the time a person sins he is called “a complete rasha,” and that even one who transgresses a minor rabbinic prohibition is called a rasha, and to the Mishnah (Berachos 9:5): “with all your heart: with both your inclinations, the good inclination and the evil inclination.”
Marei mekomos
- 1הוא רע גמור · ראה תניא פרק א.
- 2ואהבת בכל לבבך · Deuteronomy 6:5
- 3ואהבת בכל לבבך בשני יצריך · ברכות פ״ט, מ״ה.
- 4ואהבת בכל לבבך בשני יצריך · Mishnah Berakhot 9:5
18והטעם כי באמת כח המתאוה מצד עצמו שרשו ויסודתו בהררי קדש1 בקדושה עליונה אלא שבירידת המדרגות ונפילתן בשבה״כ [בשבירת הכלים] נמשך שיהיה כח המתאוה גם לדבר עבירה.
The reason is that in truth the faculty of desire, in itself, has its root and “its foundation in the holy mountains,” in supernal holiness; only that through the descent of the levels and their fall in the shattering of the vessels (sheviras hakeilim), it came about that the faculty of desire is also [drawn] to a matter of transgression.
The reason the power of desire can be transformed is that its true root is “in the holy mountains,” in supernal holiness. Only through the descent of the levels and their fall in the shattering of the vessels, the Kabbalistic account of how holy sparks fell into the lower realms, did it come to desire sin as well.
ולזאת כשישוב אל ה׳ יוכל להפוך לבו מן הקצה אל הקצה שגם כח המתאוה שהיה מלובש בתאוה רעה ישוב לאהבת ה׳
Therefore, when he returns to G‑d, he can turn his heart from one extreme to the other, so that even the faculty of desire, which was enclothed in an evil desire, will turn to the love of G‑d
So when a person does teshuvah, he can turn his heart completely around, and even the desire that was enclothed in evil turns to the love of G‑d.
(ועמ״ש מזה ע״פ זאת חקת התורה2 בענין אפר הפרה ועמ״ש סד״ה ויאבק איש3 בענין שהעלו אבק עד כסה״כ [כסא הכבוד])4
(and see what is written about this on the verse “This is the statute of the Torah,” on the subject of the ashes of the [red] heifer; and see what is written at the end of the discourse beginning “And a man wrestled,” on the subject of their raising dust up to the Throne of Glory).
A parenthesis refers to the discourse on the red heifer, “This is the statute of the Torah,” and to the end of the discourse on Yaakov’s struggle with the angel, “And a man wrestled,” where the Sages say that they “raised dust up to the Throne of Glory.”
אבל המעשה רע אשר יעשה האדם לחטוא בהנה5 מחמת שהוא באמת רע גמור מצד עצמו א״א לו להתכלל בקדושה כי אין עבירה נעשית מצוה ואין לה תקנה
But the evil deed that a person commits in sinning by them, since it is truly complete evil in itself, cannot be included in holiness, for a transgression does not become a mitzvah, and it has no remedy
The sinful act itself, however, is complete evil in its essence and cannot be absorbed into holiness: a transgression never becomes a mitzvah. There is no repairing it.
אלא ביטולה והעברתה מן העולם כמ״ש לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] ואת רוח הטומאה אעביר6 וגו׳ וזהו נושא עון789 וכובש עון נושא עון היינו הכח המתאוה לתאוה רעה
except its nullification and removal from the world, as it is written of the Time to Come, “And I will remove the spirit of impurity,” etc. And this is [the meaning of] “bears iniquity” and “suppresses iniquity.” “Bears iniquity” refers to the faculty that desires an evil desire,
Its only remedy is to be nullified and removed from the world, as the prophet promises for the Time to Come, “And I will remove the spirit of impurity.” This explains the two views in the Talmud: “bears iniquity” refers to the faculty that desires evil.
וכן המחשבה המלובשת בתאוה זו שזהו נושא עון שמגביהו לעלות לשרשו להתכלל בקדושה עליונה להפוך לבו ומחשבותיו מן הקצה אל הקצה שגם כח המתאוה ישוב לאהבת ה׳.
and likewise the thought enclothed in this desire: this is “bears iniquity,” for He lifts it to rise to its root, to be included in supernal holiness, to turn his heart and his thoughts from one extreme to the other, so that the faculty of desire too will turn to the love of G‑d.
It also includes the thoughts enclothed in that desire. G‑d “bears” them: He lifts them back to their root so that they are absorbed into supernal holiness, and the person’s heart and thoughts turn completely around to the love of G‑d.
וכובש עון היינו המעשה בפו״מ [בפועל ממש] שאין לה עלייה והתכללות בקדושה כ״א ביטול והעברה לע״ל [לעתיד לבוא] מ״מ גם עתה כובשה ומפילה בבחי׳ מצולות ים101112 (ע׳ [עיין] בזח״ג [בזהר חלק ג] פ׳ אחרי דס״ג סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב] ובפ׳ אמור דק״א ע״ב ובמק״מ [ובמקדש מלך] ובהרמ״ז [ובהרב משה זכות] שם)
And “suppresses iniquity” refers to the deed in actual fact, which has no ascent or inclusion in holiness, only nullification and removal in the Time to Come; nevertheless, even now He suppresses it and casts it down to the level of “the depths of the sea” (see the Zohar, Part III, Parshas Acharei, end of 63b, and Parshas Emor, 101b, and in the Mikdash Melech and the Ramaz there),
“Suppresses iniquity” refers to the act itself, which cannot rise and will be removed only in the Time to Come. Until then G‑d suppresses it and casts it into “the depths of the sea” (Micah); the Zohar on Acharei and Emor, with its commentators the Mikdash Melech and the Ramaz, explains this phrase.
מקום הקליפות שלא תשוטט באויר העוה״ז להחטיא את האדם ולא ישוב לכסלה13 עד עת קץ שיבולע המות לנצח14 ואת רוח הטומאה אעביר כו׳
the place of the kelipos (husks), so that it will not roam in the air of this world to cause man to sin, and will not “return to folly,” until the time of the end, when “death will be swallowed up forever,” and “I will remove the spirit of impurity,” etc.
“The depths of the sea” is the realm of the kelipos, where the sin can no longer hover in the air of this world and lead a person to sin, nor “return to folly.” There it remains until the end of days, when “death will be swallowed up forever” and the spirit of impurity is removed.
וזהו נושא עון ועובר על פשע15 כי פשע היא בחינת המעשה בפו״מ [בפועל ממש] הוא עובר ודורך עליה וכובשה במצולות ים.
And this is [the meaning of] “He bears iniquity and passes over transgression”: for transgression (pesha) is the level of the deed in actual fact; He passes over and treads upon it, and suppresses it in the depths of the sea.
This is the meaning of “He bears iniquity and passes over transgression”: pesha (transgression) is the act itself, which G‑d passes over, treads down and suppresses in the depths of the sea.
משא״כ בחי׳ עון הוא נושא דהיינו בחי׳ כח המתאוה ומחשבות האדם ותחבולותיו (וע׳ עוד מענין נושא עון בזח״ג [בזהר חלק ג] קל״ב ב׳ קל״ג א׳ ק״מ ע״ב קמ״א א׳.
Whereas the level of iniquity (avon) He bears: that is, the level of the faculty of desire, and a person’s thoughts and schemes (and see further on the subject of “bears iniquity” in the Zohar, Part III, 132b, 133a, 140b, 141a;
Avon (iniquity) is the faculty of desire, together with a person’s thoughts and schemes, and this G‑d “bears,” lifting it up. A parenthesis lists places in the Zohar’s Idra where “bears iniquity” is explained.
ובפ׳ ויגש דר״ו ע״ב ע״פ עברו יחדיו1617 ובפי׳ הרמ״ז [הרב משה זכות] שם בע״א [באופן אחר] קצת). והנה על ידי שנושא עון ועובר על פשע הוא מסיר המסכים המבדילים.
and in Parshas Vayigash, 206b, on the verse “They passed over together,” and in the Ramaz’s commentary there, somewhat differently). Now, through His bearing iniquity and passing over transgression, He removes the separating screens.
The list ends with the Zohar on Vayigash, on “they passed over together,” and the Ramaz’s commentary, which explains it somewhat differently. By bearing iniquity and passing over transgression, G‑d removes the screens that separate the person from Him.
ואזי נמשך ממילא ומאליו חסד עליון להיות גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה ממש שלפני ההשתלשות ולמעלה מן הזמן על נפש האדם כי אני ה׳ לא שניתי18 כתיב ואתה הוא קודם שנברא כו׳ בלי שום שינוי
And then the supernal kindness is drawn down as a matter of course, of itself, so that there is a revelation of the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, itself — which is before the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus) and above time — upon the person’s soul. For it is written, “I, Havayah, have not changed,” and “You are He before [the world] was created,” etc., without any change;
Once they are gone, the supernal kindness flows of itself, and the Infinite Light that is beyond the chain of worlds and above time is revealed upon the person’s soul. This is possible because G‑d has not changed: as He was before creation, so He is now.
אך מה שאין זה בגילוי בנפש האדם הוא מחמת כי עונותיכם מבדילים19 והם המונעים ומעכבים גילוי זה
but the reason this is not revealed in a person’s soul is that “your iniquities separate,” and they are what prevent and hold back this revelation.
The only reason this light is not revealed in a person’s soul is that, in Isaiah’s words, “your iniquities separate”: they are what holds the revelation back.
אבל בהסיר המונע ממילא אין שום דבר חוצץ ונגלה כבוד20 ה׳ א״ס ב״ה ממש על נפשו.
But when the obstacle is removed, then as a matter of course nothing at all intervenes, and “the glory of Havayah is revealed,” the Infinite One, blessed be He, Himself, upon his soul.
Once the obstacle is removed, nothing stands in between, and “the glory of Havayah is revealed,” the Infinite One Himself, upon his soul.
ה אך הנה כתיב לשארית נחלתו וארז״ל [ואמרו רבותינו זכרונם לברכה] למי נושא עון21 ועובר על פשע למי שמשים א״ע [את עצמו] כשירים.22
5. However, it is written, “for the remnant (she’eris) of His inheritance,” and our Sages, of blessed memory, said: “For whom does He bear iniquity and pass over transgression? For one who makes himself like leftovers (shirayim).”
A new section adds a condition. The verse says “for the remnant (she’eris) of His inheritance,” which the Sages explain as “one who makes himself like leftovers (shirayim)”: G‑d bears iniquity and passes over transgression only for such a person.
Both Talmudic views are true: G‑d “bears” the desire and thoughts behind the sin, lifting them to their holy root, and “suppresses” the act, casting it into the depths of the sea until it is removed in the Time to Come. With these screens removed, the Infinite Light, which never changed, is revealed upon the soul; but this is only for one who makes himself like “leftovers.”
In the Zohar (3:63b, 3:101b) “the depths of the sea” is the place where sins are cast so that they are covered and never found again. In the Idra (3:132b, 3:140b) “bears iniquity” is one of the tikkunim of the supernal beard, and on Vayigash (1:206b) the Zohar reads “they passed over together” as the joining of the upper and lower worlds, without which the sins of the world are not passed over.
Marei mekomos
- 1ויסודתו בהררי קדש · Psalms 87:1
- 2זאת חקת התורה · Numbers 19:2
- 3ויאבק איש · Genesis 32:25
- 4שהעלו אבק עד כסה״כ · Chullin 91a:18
- 5אשר יעשה האדם לחטוא בהנה · Leviticus 5:22
- 6ואת רוח הטומאה אעביר · Zechariah 13:2
- 7נושא עון · Zohar, Idra Rabba 11:112–13:123
- 8נושא עון · Zohar, Idra Rabba 33:278–35:289
- 9נושא עון · Zohar, Idra Rabba 35:289–41:297
- 10מצולות ים · Micah 7:19
- 11מצולות ים · Zohar, Achrei Mot 20:124–21:130
- 12מצולות ים · Zohar, Emor 40:234–244
- 13ולא ישוב לכסלה · Psalms 85:9
- 14שיבולע המות לנצח · Isaiah 25:8
- 15נושא עון ועובר על פשע · Micah 7:18
- 16עברו יחדיו · Psalms 48:5
- 17עברו יחדיו · Zohar, Vayigash 3:26–5:36
- 18אני ה׳ לא שניתי · Malachi 3:6
- 19עונותיכם מבדילים · Isaiah 59:2
- 20ונגלה כבוד ה׳ · Isaiah 40:5
- 21וארז״ל למי נושא עון · Rosh Hashanah 17a:14–15
- 22למי שמשים א״ע כשירים · Rosh Hashanah 17b:1
Why the soul does not expire ¶19–21
The explanation is this. It is written, “I, Havayah, have not changed, and you, children of Yaakov, have not expired.” That is, the prophet complains about the children of Yaakov:
The Alter Rebbe explains the condition through Malachi’s verse, “I, Havayah, have not changed, and you, children of Yaakov, have not expired.” He reads it as the prophet’s complaint against the children of Yaakov.
כי הלא אני ה׳ לא שניתי שאתה הוא לאחר שנברא העולם כמו קודם שנברא שהוא למעלה מגדר הזמן והמקום ואין הזמן והמקום תופסים לפניו כלום
for surely “I, Havayah, have not changed” — “You are He” after the world was created just as before it was created, for He is above the bounds of time and space, and time and space are of no account at all before Him.
G‑d is unchanged by creation: He is the same after it as before, for He is above the bounds of time and space, and before Him they count for nothing.
ואי לזאת הוא לבדו הוא יחיד ומיוחד אחר שנברא העולם כמו קודם ואין עוד מלבדו2 ואפס זולתו ולמה אתם בני יעקב לא כליתם.
Therefore He alone is single and unique after the world was created just as before, and “there is nothing else besides Him,” and there is nothing apart from Him. So why have you, children of Yaakov, not expired?
Therefore He alone is single and unique after creation as before, and “there is nothing else besides Him.” So why, asks the prophet, have the children of Yaakov not come to kelos hanefesh?
פי׳ שאין לכם כלות הנפש לצאת ממאסר הגוף ומנרתקו שלא למשוך אחר צרכי גופו רק לדבקה בו ית׳ בא״ס ב״ה ובמדותיו כל היום
That is, you do not have the soul’s expiry (kelos hanefesh), to go out of the prison of the body and its sheath — not to be drawn after the needs of one’s body, but only to cleave to Him, may He be blessed, to the Infinite One (Ein Sof), blessed be He, and to His attributes, all day long.
That is, why do they not long to leave the prison of the body and its sheath, to stop pursuing the body’s needs and to cleave only to the Infinite One and His attributes all day long?
כי גם אם לבבו יבין שהאמת כן הוא דכולא קמיה כלא חשיב3 מ״מ לא יתפעל בנפשו שיהא נוגע לו אל עצמיו׳ [עצמיות] הנפש מקרב איש ולב עמוק4 שתכלה אליו ית׳ הנפש בתשוקה וצמאון כו׳
For even if his heart understands that this is the truth, that “all before Him is considered as nothing,” nevertheless he will not be moved in his soul so that it touches the very essence of the soul, “the inner part of a man and a deep heart,” that the soul should expire toward Him, may He be blessed, in longing and thirst, etc.
A person may understand with his mind that “all before Him is considered as nothing,” and yet not be moved in the essence of his soul, “the inner part of a man and a deep heart,” so that his soul would expire toward G‑d in longing and thirst.
[ועמ״ש מזה בד״ה בחודש השלישי לצאת]5 והסיבה לזה ביאר הנביא באמרו בני יעקב כי יעקב הוא יו״ד עקב6 בחי׳ חכמה שירדה בעקביים וסוף המעשה במדרגות
[And see what is written about this in the discourse beginning “In the third month after the going out.”] The reason for this the prophet explained in saying “children of Yaakov”: for Yaakov is yud-akev (yud–heel), the level of Chochmah (wisdom) that descended into the heels and the final act, in the levels
A bracket refers to the discourse “In the third month.” The prophet gives the reason in the words “children of Yaakov”: the name Yaakov (יעקב) is read as yud-akev, the yud, Chochmah, that descended into the heel (akev), down to the final act in the lowest levels.
תחתונות דעשי׳ [דעשיה] גשמי׳ [גשמיים / גשמיות / גשמית] ובני יעקב הם המקבלים מבחי׳ עקביים7 שהנפש נלקחה משם ולפיכך אין הנפש מתפעלת מדברים דקים ורוחניים ואינה בטלה כ״כ [כל כך] באור א״ס ב״ה שלמעלה מההשתלשלות שאינו מאיר לה
that are lowest, of the physical World of Asiyah (Action). And the children of Yaakov are those who receive from the level of the heels, for the soul was taken from there. Therefore the soul is not moved by subtle and spiritual matters, and is not so nullified before the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, which is above the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus), for it does not shine to it
This is the level of physical Asiyah. The “children of Yaakov” are souls taken from this level of the heels, and so they are not moved by subtle, spiritual matters and are not wholly nullified before the Infinite Light, which is above the chain of worlds.
אלא בריחוק מקום וכמציץ מן החרכים8 בבחי׳ מקיף ואינו נכנס בפנימית הלב להיות תוכו רצוף אהבה9 בכלות הנפש ממש.
except from a distance, and “as one peering through the lattices,” in the manner of an encompassing [light] (makif); and it does not enter the inner heart, so that “its inside is inlaid with love,” with the soul’s actual expiry.
That light shines to such a soul only from afar, as one “peering through the lattices” (Song of Songs), as an encompassing light (makif). It does not enter the inner heart so that, in the words of the Song, “its inside is inlaid with love” in true kelos hanefesh.
Malachi’s complaint, “I have not changed, and you have not expired,” explains why kelos hanefesh is lacking: the souls called “children of Yaakov” come from the “heel,” the lowest level, so the Infinite Light reaches them only as an encompassing light from afar and does not enter the heart.
Kehot lists many places where Yaakov is read as yud-akev: in Torah Ohr, the discourses “And I will return in peace,” “And Yaakov dwelt,” “Those who come shall take root, Yaakov,” “And a man wrestled” and the discourse for the twenty-fifth of Kislev, which speaks of the yud that grasps the heel of Esav; in Likkutei Torah, “He has not beheld iniquity in Yaakov”; and the Kabbalistic lexicon Kehilas Yaakov.
Marei mekomos
- 1אני הוי׳ לא שניתי ואתם בני יעקב לא כליתם · Malachi 3:6
- 2ואין עוד מלבדו · Deuteronomy 4:35
- 3דכולא קמיה כלא חשיב · Zohar, Introduction 20:188–22:199
- 4מקרב איש ולב עמוק · Psalms 64:7
- 5בחודש השלישי לצאת · Exodus 19:1
- 6יעקב הוא יו״ד עקב · Zohar I, 196a
- 7ובני יעקב הם המקבלים מבחי׳ עקביים · ראה המשך בששה״ק ח״ב ע׳ תתקצב.
- 8וכמציץ מן החרכים · Song of Songs 2:9
- 9תוכו רצוף אהבה · Song of Songs 3:10
20והגם שמצד עצמיות הנפש אפי׳ [אפילו] היא ממדרגה התחתונה מאד הרי היא מ״מ נפש אלקית והיתה בטלה באוא״ס [באור אין סוף] ב״ה ממש כנר בפני האבוקה.
And although, as regards the essence of the soul, even if it is from a very low level, it is nevertheless a G‑dly soul and would be nullified before the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, itself, like a candle before a torch,
Even a soul from a very low level is, in its essence, a G‑dly soul, and in itself it would be nullified before the Infinite Light as a candle’s flame is lost before a torch.
אמנם מצד התלבשותה בנפש הבהמית הנה הנפש אשר היא ממדרגה התחתונה הרי היא מלובשת מאד ומושרשת בטבע הנפש הבהמית ומשוך אחר צרכי גופו וקשה לה ליפרד ממנו
nevertheless, as regards its being enclothed in the animal soul, the soul that is from the lowest level is deeply enclothed and rooted in the nature of the animal soul, and drawn after the needs of his body, and it is hard for it to separate from it
But as it is enclothed in the animal soul, a soul from the lowest level is deeply clothed and rooted in the animal soul’s nature, drawn after the body’s needs, and finds it hard to separate from them.
(ועמ״ש מזה סד״ה כי אתה נרי)1 מחמת שהיא בבחי׳ ישות וגסות רוח דהיינו שהרוחניות היא בבחי׳ גסות ועביות.2
(and see what is written about this at the end of the discourse beginning “For You are my lamp”), because it is in a state of selfhood (yeshus) and coarseness of spirit; that is, its spirituality is in a state of coarseness and density.
A parenthesis refers to the end of the discourse “For You are my lamp.” The reason is that such a soul is in a state of yeshus, selfhood, and “coarseness of spirit”: even its spirituality is coarse and dense.
ולזאת נמשכת אחר דברים גסים ועבים ואינה מתפעלת מדברים דקים ורוחנים כי גסות וחומריות הגוף הם המלבישים את הנפש מראשה ועד רגלה ובפרט
Therefore it is drawn after coarse and dense things and is not moved by subtle and spiritual things, for the coarseness and materiality of the body are what clothe the soul from its head to its foot. And especially
So it is drawn to coarse things and is not moved by subtle, spiritual ones, for the body’s coarseness and materiality clothe the soul entirely, from head to foot.
בבע״ת [בבעלי תשובה] שמתחלה נמשך אחר צרכי גופו וקשה לו ליפרד ממנו מחמת שהוא מלובש ומושרש בטבע גסות וחומריות הגוף ונפש הב המית המלבישים אותו.
in a penitent (baal teshuvah), who at first was drawn after the needs of his body, and it is hard for him to separate from it, because he is enclothed and rooted in the nature of the coarseness and materiality of the body and the animal soul, which clothe him.
This is especially so for a penitent, who was at first drawn after the needs of his body. Being clothed and rooted in the coarse nature of the body and the animal soul, he finds it hard to separate from them.
והתלבשות זו נקרא בר״מ [ברעיא מהימנא] בשם סרכות הריאה3 (וע׳ מזה ג״כ ברע״מ [ברעיא מהימנא] פ׳ פנחס דרכ״ז סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב]4 ודרכ״ח ע״א)8
This enclothing is called in the Raaya Mehemna “adhesions of the lung” (sirchos hare’ah) (and see on this also in the Raaya Mehemna, Parshas Pinchas, end of 227b and 228a),
The Raaya Mehemna, a section of the Zohar, calls this enclothing “adhesions of the lung” (sirchos), the term used in the laws of kashrus for a lung that is stuck to the chest. The Alter Rebbe cites passages in the Raaya Mehemna on Pinchas.
שהריאה נסרכת ודבוקה ומושרשת עד שאינה יכולה להניף על הלב (ע׳ [עיין] ברע״מ [ברעיא מהימנא] שם דרל״א סע״א [סוף עמוד א] ודרל״ד א׳ ודרל״ה)
for the lung becomes adhered, stuck and rooted, until it cannot fan the heart (see the Raaya Mehemna there, end of 231a, and 234a, and 235).
Such a lung is stuck and rooted in place, so that it cannot fan the heart, as the lung’s “wings” do in the Zohar’s picture of the body.
כי אין לה כח להעלות כנפיה לפרחא ולסלקא קדם מלכא ולכך היא דבוק ומושרש בצרכי גופו.
For it has no strength to raise its wings “to fly and to rise before the King,” and so it is stuck and rooted in the needs of his body.
It lacks the strength to raise its wings and, in the Zohar’s words, “to fly and to rise before the King.” So too the soul is stuck in the needs of the body.
ואינו מרגיש רק עצמו ורצונו ולזאת אף אם לבבו יבין האמת שהעולם שהוא תחת הזמן ומקום הוא כאין ואפס ובטל באוא״ס [באור אין סוף] ב״ה שלמעלה מן ההשתלשלות שאינו בגדר זמן ומקום כלל.
And he feels only himself and his own will. Therefore, even if his heart understands the truth — that the world, which is subject to time and space, is as naught and nothing, and nullified within the Infinite Light, blessed be He, which is above the chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus) and not within the bounds of time and space at all —
Such a person feels only himself and his own will. He may understand that the world, bound by time and space, is as nothing and nullified before the Infinite Light, which is not within time and space at all.
מ״מצ [מ״מ] קשה לו לצאת ממאסר הגוף ואומר מה אעשה שכך נוצרתי. והעצה היעוצה לזה5 בזוהר פ׳ שלח (דקס״ח6 א׳)
nevertheless it is hard for him to go out of the prison of the body, and he says, “What can I do? This is how I was created.” And the counsel given for this in the Zohar, Parshas Shelach (168a), [is:]
Even so, it is hard for him to leave the prison of the body, and he excuses himself: “What can I do? This is how I was created.” The Zohar on Shelach gives the counsel for this (the printed מ״מצ is evidently מ״מ, “nevertheless”).
אעא דלא סליק בי׳ [ביה] נהורא מבטשין לי׳ גופא דלא סליק בי׳ [ביה] נהורא דנשמתא מבטשין לי׳7
“A log in which the light does not rise is struck; a body in which the light of the soul does not rise is struck.”
“A log in which the light does not rise is struck”: wood that will not catch fire is struck until it lights up. So too a body in which the soul’s light does not shine must be struck, that is, humbled, until the light rises in it.
דהיינו להשפיל א״ע [את עצמו] מזה עצמו שיהא רע בעיניו המעשה שקשה עליו פרידתו מן הגוף וישים אל לבו שגם פושעי ישראל פורקי עול העובר כמה עבירות רק למלאות תאותו.
That is, to humble himself on account of this very thing — that it be bad in his eyes that his parting from the body is hard for him — and to take to heart that even the transgressors of Israel who throw off the yoke — one who commits many transgressions only to satisfy his desire —
The “striking” is humbling oneself over this very failing: being pained that parting from the body is so hard for him. He should consider the transgressors of Israel who throw off the yoke and sin only to satisfy their desires; the next paragraph shows that his excuse is theirs.
Though every soul in its essence would be nullified before G‑d, the soul enclothed in the animal soul, especially a penitent’s, is stuck in the body’s needs like a lung adhering to the chest, and he excuses himself: “This is how I was created.” The Zohar’s counsel is to “strike” the body, that is, to humble oneself precisely over this difficulty.
Tanya ch. 29 brings the same counsel of the Zohar for one whose heart is closed like stone. Kehot quotes the Rebbe Rashab (Sefer HaMaamarim 5678), who refers to this maamar on “coarseness of spirit” and suggests that a divine glimmer that has passed through many contractions may be lower than the soul’s coarseness of spirit, since one is inward and the other outward, though he leaves the matter for further study.
Marei mekomos
- 1כי אתה נרי · II Samuel 22:29
- 2שהרוחניות היא בבחי׳ גסות ועביות · ראה בסה״מ תרע״ח בד״ה למען ידעו ע׳ לא: . . ואפי׳ הארה קטנה ביותר הבאה ע״י ריבוי צמצומים מאד, ה״ז מ״מ אלקות. ועמ״ש בד״ה להבין ענין מי א-ל כמוך בענין גסות הרוח כו׳, ואפשר י״ל דבחי׳ הארה אלקית שבאה בריבוי צמצומים ה״ז למטה במדרי׳ מבחי׳ גסות הרוח דנשמה להיות שזה בחי׳ פנימיות וזה בחי׳ חיצוניות כו׳. ומ״מ צ״ע שהרי הנשמה נעשה בבחי׳ יש כו׳, ע״ש. וע״ע המשך בששה״ק תער״ב ח״א ע׳ שפז וע׳ תקנג. ח״ג ע׳ א׳תסט וע׳ א׳שנה.
- 3סרכות הריאה · Zohar, Pinchas 46:266–48:278
- 4ברע״מ . . דרכ״ז סע״ב · באוה״ת נ״ך כרך א ע׳ קסד מציין ”בענין כנפי ריאה צ״ל בלא סירכא” ע״ש שכתב שמכאן ”י״ל דכנפי הריאה המניפי׳ על הלב הלב הוא מל׳ וששה כנפי הריאה הם ששה כנפי השרפים שהם המעלים את המל׳”.
- 5והעצה היעוצה לזה · ראה סה״מ תרס״ט ע׳ קיח ואילך.
- 6בזוהר פ׳ שלח (דקס״ח א׳) · ראה תניא פ׳ כט. וראה באוה״ת פ׳ חקת ע׳ תתל.
- 7אעא דלא סליק בי׳ נהורא מבטשין לי׳ גופא דלא סליק בי׳ נהורא דנשמתא מבטשין לי׳ · Zohar, Sh'lach 25:202–26:210
- 8נקרא ברע״מ בשם סרכות הריאה · בבוך 269 רעו, א בד״ה ענין תשובה קדמה לעולם (הנדפס במאמרי אדה״ז הקצרים ע׳ שכט-של), נמצא הגהת הרה״ח וכו׳ מוהרא״י ריבלין על התיבות ”ובר״מ נק׳ בחי׳ זו בשם סרכות הריאה”: פ׳ צו דכ״ח וע׳ כ״י [כתב-יד] ד״ה למען תזכרו ע״ז.
21והגם שיודע שאין בהם ממש אעפ״כ [אף על פי כן] לא יציל את נפשו מלילך בדרכים כאלו. לפי שאינו רוצה לסבול שפלות ודחקות ולזאת הוא מתברך בלבבו לאמר שלום1 יהיה לי
although he knows that there is nothing real in them, nevertheless does not save his soul from going in such ways, because he does not want to endure lowliness and hardship; and therefore “he blesses himself in his heart, saying, ‘I will have peace,
Such a transgressor knows that his pursuits have no substance, yet he does not save himself from them, because he does not want to suffer lowliness and hardship. So, in the Torah’s words, “he blesses himself in his heart, saying, ‘I will have peace.’”
כי בשרירות לבי אלך כי טבעי גרמה לי ובאמת אין זו טענה כי צריך לשנות את טבעו ולשבור תאותו ולסבול חיי צער נגד כחשו בה׳.
for I will go in the stubbornness of my heart’” — for my nature caused it. But in truth this is no argument, for he must change his nature, break his desire, and endure a life of pain corresponding to his having denied G‑d.
The verse continues, “for I will go in the stubbornness of my heart,” and he adds that his nature made him so. But this is no excuse: a person must change his nature, break his desire and accept a life of hardship to make up for having denied G‑d by his sins.
וכך ישים האדם אל לבו לשבור תאות הגוף וחומריותו שלא יהא מונע ומעכב גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה וקדושתו ליבטל וליכלל כו׳
And so a person should set his heart on breaking the desire of the body and its materiality, so that it will not prevent and hold back the revelation of the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, and His holiness, [so as] to be nullified and included, etc.
So too every person must resolve to break the desires and materiality of the body, so that they do not block the revelation of the Infinite Light and its holiness, in which he would be nullified and included.
ואם אינו משבר תאותו ורוצה בטבעו כתולדתו שקשה לו ליפרד מטבעו הרי טענתו טענת פושעי ישראל ממש:
And if he does not break his desire, and wants [to remain] in his nature as he was born, since it is hard for him to part from his nature, then his argument is exactly the argument of the transgressors of Israel.
If he does not break his desire, preferring to stay as he was born because change is hard for him, his excuse is exactly that of the transgressors of Israel.
The excuse “this is how I was made” is the very excuse of the transgressors of Israel, who know their pursuits are empty but will not suffer in order to change. A person must break his nature so that it does not block the revelation of the Infinite Light.
Marei mekomos
- 1מתברך בלבבו לאמר שלום יהי׳ לי · Deuteronomy 29:18
A broken and crushed heart ¶22–23
22והנה כשיעמיק ויתבונן בדברים האלה ויראה עד היכן מגיע רעת ישותו וגסותו יבטש א״ע [את עצמו] וישפיל נפשו כעפר והגם שביטוש והשפלה זאת אינה מעצמות הנפש בטבעה
Now, when he contemplates these things deeply and sees how far the evil of his selfhood and coarseness reaches, he will strike himself and humble his soul like dust. And although this striking and humbling does not come from the essence of the soul by its nature,
When he contemplates this deeply and sees how far the evil of his selfhood and coarseness reaches, he will “strike” himself and humble his soul like dust. This humbling, however, does not come naturally from the soul’s essence.
אלא ע״י יגיעה בהעמקת ההתבוננות. הנה ע״ז אמר דוד המע״ה [המלך עליו השלום] לב נשבר ונדכה1 אלהים לא תבזה.
but through toil in deepening contemplation — of this King David, peace be upon him, said, “A broken and crushed (nidkeh) heart, O G‑d, You will not despise.”
It comes only through toil in deep contemplation. Of this King David said, “A broken and crushed heart, O G‑d, You will not despise.”
דלכאורה אינו מובן וכי ס״ד שהלב נשבר ונדכה2 יחשב לבזיון עד שאמר דוד המע״ה [המלך עליו השלום] לא תבזה.
For at first glance this is not understood: would one have thought that a broken and crushed heart would be considered contemptible, that King David, peace be upon him, had to say, “You will not despise”?
The verse is puzzling: who would have thought that a broken and crushed heart could be contemptible, so that David had to say that G‑d will not despise it?
Deep contemplation of one’s own coarseness brings a person to humble himself like dust, though this humbling comes through effort rather than from the soul’s own nature. David’s “A broken and crushed heart, O G‑d, You will not despise” raises the question of why such a heart would ever be despised.
Marei mekomos
- 1לב נשבר ונדכה אלקים לא תבזה · Psalms 51:19
- 2וכי ס״ד שהלב נשבר ונדכה · באוה״ת פ׳ חוקת ע׳ תתלו מציין לכאן. וראה שם גם ע׳ תתנח.
23והלא אדרבה שבח הוא ללב שיהא נשבר ונדכה וכמ״ש זבחי אלקים רוח נשברה1234 וכתיב מרום וקדוש אשכון5 ואת דכא67 כו׳.
On the contrary, surely it is praiseworthy for the heart to be broken and crushed, as it is written, “The sacrifices of G‑d are a broken spirit,” and it is written, “I dwell on high and in holiness, and with the crushed (daka),” etc.
On the contrary, a broken heart is praiseworthy: “The sacrifices of G‑d are a broken spirit,” and Isaiah says that G‑d dwells “on high and in holiness, and with the crushed (daka).”
אך הענין יובן בביאור מלת ונדכה שהוא לשון נפעל משא״כ מלת דכא הוא שם דבר כי מי שהוא דכא באמת ודאי שבח הוא לו אשכון ואת דכא
But the matter will be understood by explaining the word venidkeh, which is a passive (nif’al) form, whereas the word daka is a noun. For one who is truly daka, crushed, it is certainly praise for him: “I dwell, and with the crushed”
The answer lies in the grammar. Nidkeh, in “broken and crushed,” is a passive verb (nif’al), “made crushed,” while daka is a noun describing what a person is; one who is truly daka is certainly praised, for G‑d dwells with him.
(וע׳ בזהר פ׳ אמור ד״צ סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב] ובמק״מ [ובמקדש מלך] שם ועמ״ש בפ׳ עקב סד״ה ארץ הרים ובקעות8 וע׳ בזח״ב [בזהר חלק ב׳] פקודי דרל״ג א׳. עוד נזכר ענין ואת דכא בזהר ח״א [חלק א׳] קפ״א א׳. ח״ב [חלק ב׳] פ״ו ב׳. ח״ג [חלק ג׳] ט׳ א׳)
(and see the Zohar, Parshas Emor, end of 90b, and the Mikdash Melech there; and see what is written in Parshas Eikev, at the end of the discourse beginning “A land of mountains and valleys”; and see the Zohar, Part II, Pekudei, 233a. The subject of “and with the crushed” is mentioned further in the Zohar, Part I, 181a; Part II, 86b; Part III, 9a).
A parenthesis lists places that discuss “and with the crushed”: the Zohar on Emor with the Mikdash Melech, the discourse “A land of mountains and valleys” in Eikev, and further passages in all three parts of the Zohar.
אבל נדכה היינו שע״י יגיעה בהעמקת ההתבוננות הוא משפיל א״ע [את עצמו] ונעשה נדכה ע״י פעולה שעושה בנפשו או ע״י שהקב״ה שולח עליו יסורין מלמעלה להכניע ולהשפילו וסד״א [וסלקא דעתך אמינא] מאחר שאינו דכא באמת לאמיתו מצד עצמו אין זה כלום.
But nidkeh means that through toil in deepening contemplation he humbles himself and becomes crushed through an action that he performs on his soul, or because the Holy One, blessed be He, sends him sufferings from above to subdue and humble him. And one might have thought that since he is not truly, genuinely daka of himself, this is worth nothing.
Nidkeh describes one who has been made crushed: either he humbled himself by toil in contemplation, an action done upon his soul, or G‑d sent him sufferings to humble him. One might think that since he is not crushed by his own nature, his brokenness is worth nothing.
לזה התפלל עליו דוד המע״ה [המלך עליו השלום] שגם לב נשבר ונדכה9 ע״י פעולה לא תבזה עכ״פ [על כל פנים] שגם בפעולת הנדכה יהא גילוי אור א״ס ב״ה
For this King David, peace be upon him, prayed on his behalf: that even a heart broken and crushed through action, “You will not despise” — at any rate, that even in the action of being crushed there will be a revelation of the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He;
So David prayed that even a heart broken and crushed through such action should not be despised, and that at least in this acquired brokenness the Infinite Light should be revealed.
דהיינו שיהא בטל לאוא״ס [לאור אין סוף] ב״ה המקיף עליו מלמעלה הגם שאינו נכנס בפנימית לבו וכנ״ל (וגדולה מזו איתא בגמרא בפרק יש בערכין) (די״ו ב׳)
that is, that he be nullified before the Infinite Light, blessed be He, that encompasses him from above, even though it does not enter the inner part of his heart, as mentioned above. (And greater than this is stated in the Gemara, in the chapter Yesh BaArachin) (16b),
That is, he should be nullified before the Infinite Light that encompasses him from above as a makif, even though it does not enter his inner heart, as explained in paragraph 19. The Talmud in Arachin says something greater still.
בענין ענוה שלא לשמה10 כו׳ עוד עיין מענין רוח נשברה לב נשבר ונדכה בגמרא פ״ק [פרק קמא] דסוטה (דף ה׳ ע״ב)
regarding humility not for its own sake, etc. See further on the subject of “a broken spirit” and “a broken and crushed heart” in the Gemara, the first chapter of Sotah (5b);
There the Talmud rules that humility even not for its own sake is greater than rebuke for its own sake, for through “not for its own sake” one comes to “for its own sake.” The Alter Rebbe then lists places on “a broken spirit” and “a broken and crushed heart,” beginning with Sotah 5b.
פ״ו דסנהדרין (דמ״ג ע״ב) וברבות ר״פ צו את אהרן ובפ׳ נשא פי״ג בפסוק ביום הרביעי נשיא לבני ראובן.11
the sixth chapter of Sanhedrin (43b); and in the Midrash Rabbah, at the beginning of “Command Aharon,” and in Parshas Nasso, chapter 13, on the verse “On the fourth day, the prince of the children of Reuven”;
The list continues with Sanhedrin 43b, where one whose spirit is humble is regarded as though he offered all the sacrifices, and with the Midrash Rabbah on Tzav and on Nasso, on the offering of the prince of Reuven.
ובזח״ג [ובזהר חלק ג] בפ׳ פינחס (דר״מ [דרעיא מהימנא] ע״א ודרמ״ז א׳) ברע״מ [ברעיא מהימנא] ובפ׳ ויקרא (דף ה׳ ע״א) ובפי׳ הרמ״ז [הרב משה זכות] שם שהאריך בזה.
and in the Zohar, Part III, Parshas Pinchas (240a and 247a), in the Raaya Mehemna; and in Parshas Vayikra (5a), and in the commentary of the Ramaz there, who discusses this at length;
It goes on to the Zohar on Pinchas, in the Raaya Mehemna, and on Vayikra, with the Ramaz’s long discussion there.
ובסבא דשמפטים (דק״ח א׳) וברע״מ [וברעיא מהימנא] פ׳ בהעלותך (דקנ״ג א׳) ועוד נזכר מזה בזח״א [בזהר חלק א] (קצ״ח א׳) ח״ב [חלק ב׳] (ס״א סע״א [סוף עמוד א] פ״ו ב׳) ח״ג [חלק ג׳] (ט׳ א׳ מ״ט סע״א [סוף עמוד א] דרכ״ד סע״ב [סוף עמוד ב]) ובמק״מ [ובמקדש מלך] שם:
and in the Sava of Mishpatim (108a), and in the Raaya Mehemna, Parshas Beha’aloscha (153a). It is mentioned further in the Zohar, Part I (198a); Part II (end of 61a, 86b); Part III (9a, end of 49a, end of 224b); and in the Mikdash Melech there.
It ends with the Sava of Mishpatim, the Raaya Mehemna on Beha’aloscha, and further passages in all three parts of the Zohar, with the Mikdash Melech.
The difference between daka, one who is crushed by nature, and nidkeh, one made crushed by effort or suffering, answers the question: David prayed that even an acquired brokenness should not be despised, but should bring at least an encompassing revelation of the Infinite Light.
The Talmud (Sotah 5b; Sanhedrin 43b) teaches that one whose mind is humble is regarded as though he offered all the sacrifices, and his prayer is not despised, citing the two halves of this verse. The Zohar on Emor (3:90b) explains why G‑d, who rests only in a whole place, dwells “with the crushed and lowly of spirit”: one who lowers himself is the most whole place of all, for the supernal majesty rests on him.
Marei mekomos
- 1
- 2
- 3זבחי אלקים רוח נשברה · Psalms 51:19
- 4רוח נשברה · Zohar, Tazria 24:123–25:134
- 5מרום וקדוש אשכון · Isaiah 57:15
- 6ואת דכא · Zohar, Emor 11:36–13:46
- 7ואת דכא · Zohar, Pekudei 25:234–26:246
- 8בפ׳ עקב סד״ה ארץ הרים ובקעות · לעיל יח, ב.
- 9לב נשבר ונדכה · Zohar, Beshalach 27:358–28:368
- 10
- 11ביום הרביעי נשיא לבני ראובן · Numbers 7:30
Like leftovers ¶24–25
24ו וזהו לשארית נחלתו12 למי שמשים א״ע [את עצמו] כשיריים.3 דהיינו שמשים עצמו בהיותו מלובש בגוף בהשתלשלות המדרגות בבחי׳ זמן ומקום.
6. And this is [the meaning of] “for the remnant (she’eris) of His inheritance”: for one who makes himself like leftovers (shirayim). That is, he makes himself — being enclothed in a body, in the chain of descending levels (hishtalshelus), in the dimension of time and space —
A new section returns to “for the remnant of His inheritance,” which the Sages read as “one who makes himself like leftovers.” The Alter Rebbe explains what this means for a person who is enclothed in a body, within the chain of levels and within time and space.
כשיריים שמלמעלה מן ההשתלשלות הנמשך לו בבחינת מקיף והיינו כשיעמיק ויתבונן בשפלותיו איך שהוא מוטבע ומלובש מאד בנפשו הטבעית אשר עי״ז רחוק הוא מאוד מאור א״ס ב״ה שאינו נמשך אליו
like the leftovers of what is above hishtalshelus, which is drawn to him in the manner of an encompassing [light] (makif). That is, when he deeply contemplates his lowliness — how he is deeply sunk and enclothed in his natural soul, through which he is very far from the Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof), blessed be He, which is drawn to him
He regards himself as receiving only the “leftovers” of the light that is above the chain of worlds, a light that reaches him only as an encompassing light (makif). He comes to this by contemplating how deeply he is sunk in his natural, animal soul, which keeps him far from the Infinite Light.
אלא בבחי׳ מקיף שעי״ז נעשה בחי׳ נדכה כנ״ל מזה נמשך שיהא הוא בטל לבחי׳ המקיף שעליו.
only as a makif, so that through this he becomes nidkeh (crushed), as mentioned above — from this it follows that he is nullified to the makif that is over him.
Because the Infinite Light reaches him only as a makif, he becomes nidkeh, crushed, as explained above, and through this he becomes nullified before that encompassing light.
וזהו לשארית נחלתו שהשיריים שהם למעלה מבחי׳ ההשתלשלות הם בחי׳ נחלתו נחלת יעקב4 נחל מלשון המשכה
And this is “for the remnant of His inheritance”: the leftovers, which are above hishtalshelus, are the level of “His inheritance” (nachalaso), “the inheritance of Yaakov” — nachal being an expression of drawing forth,
So the verse reads: the “leftovers,” the light from above the chain of worlds, are “His inheritance” (nachalaso), “the inheritance of Yaakov.” The word nachalah is related to nachal, a stream: something drawn forth.
דהיינו ההמשכה וההארה שמאור א״ס ב״ה ויעקב חבל נחלתו5 (ועד״ז שנתבאר כאן בפי׳ לשארית מבואר ג״כ בזהר ס״פ ויצא)
that is, the drawing forth and radiance from the Infinite Light, blessed be He; and “Yaakov is the lot (chevel) of His inheritance.” (And along the lines of what is explained here on the meaning of “remnant,” it is also explained in the Zohar, at the end of Parshas Vayeitzei)
The inheritance is the flow and radiance from the Infinite Light, and “Yaakov is the lot of His inheritance.” A parenthesis notes that the Zohar explains “remnant” in the same way.
(146b), on the meaning of “A remnant shall return, the remnant of Yaakov”: “These are the other blessings that remained.” And it is written, “And the remnant of Yaakov shall be,” etc., “like dew,” etc.
There (146b) the Zohar reads “A remnant shall return, the remnant of Yaakov” as “the other blessings that remained,” and cites “And the remnant of Yaakov shall be… like dew.” These are blessings Yaakov received but set aside for a later time.
ופי׳ דאשתארו היינו שאינן מאירים עכשיו בבחי׳ גילוי וזהו ע״ד מש״כ [מה שכתוב] בפי׳ לשארית כשיריים כו׳
The meaning of “that remained” is that they do not shine now in a revealed way; and this is along the lines of what is written on the meaning of “remnant” as “leftovers,” etc.
“That remained” means that they do not shine openly now. This matches the reading of “remnant” as “leftovers”: a light that is present but not revealed.
אך הנחלה וההמשכה היא באה בבחי׳ מקיף בלבד וזהו נחלה עבר על נפשנו9 שאינה נכנסה בפנימיות הלב להיות תוכו רצוף אהבה10 לה׳ בכלות הנפש ממש מעומקא דלבא.
But the inheritance and the drawing forth come only as a makif. And this is [the meaning of] “the stream (nachlah) passed over our soul”: it does not enter the inner dimension of the heart, so that “its inside is inlaid with love” for G‑d, with the soul’s actual expiry (kelos hanefesh), from the depth of the heart.
This inheritance comes only as a makif. That is the meaning of “the stream passed over our soul”: it passes over the soul without entering the inner heart, so that the heart is not yet “inlaid with love” in true kelos hanefesh.
“One who makes himself like leftovers” is one who recognizes that the Infinite Light reaches him only as an encompassing “remnant,” and through this recognition becomes crushed and nullified before it. That remnant is “His inheritance,” a flow from the Infinite Light that passes over the soul as a makif.
In the Zohar (1:146b) Yaakov tells Esav that the blessings he already has are enough for now, and sets aside the others for the time when his children will need them against the kings of the world; these are “the remnant of Yaakov.” Kehot also points to Or HaTorah on Bereshis (90a) on “for the remnant of His inheritance.”
Marei mekomos
- 1לשארית נחלתו · ראה גם אוה״ת בראשית צ, א.
- 2לשארית נחלתו · Micah 7:18
- 3למי שמשים א״ע כשיריים · Rosh Hashanah 17b:1
- 4נחלת יעקב · Isaiah 58:14
- 5ויעקב חבל נחלתו · Deuteronomy 32:9
- 6שאר ישוב שאר יעקב · Isaiah 10:21
- 7שאר ישוב שאר יעקב אלין ברכאן אחרנין דאשתארו · Zohar, Toldot 19:202–208
- 8והי׳ שארית יעקב · Micah 5:6
- 9נחלה עבר על נפשנו · Psalms 124:4
- 10תוכו רצוף אהבה · Song of Songs 3:10
25ומ״מ מאחר שנעשה עי״ז בחי׳ נדכה יצר לו מאד מה שגופו ונפשו הבהמית מלבישים את הנפש ונעשה שפל בעיניו הרי הוא בטל לבחי׳ המקיף שעליו ומשים עצתמו כשיריים ונמשך עליו חסד עליון להיות נושא עון
Nevertheless, since through this he becomes nidkeh — it pains him greatly that his body and his animal soul clothe the soul, and he becomes lowly in his own eyes — he is nullified to the makif over him and makes himself like leftovers, and the supernal kindness is drawn upon him, to be “bearing iniquity
Even though the light reaches him only as a makif, he has become nidkeh: it pains him that his body and animal soul clothe his G‑dly soul, and he is lowly in his own eyes. So he is nullified before the makif and makes himself like “leftovers,” and the supernal kindness comes to him as “bearing iniquity.”
ועובר על פשע1 שהחסד עליון מתפשט במקום נמוך יותר כנ״ל ועי״ז יכול להעלות נפשו ולקשרה באור ה׳ א״ס ב״ה וקדושתו ולצאת ממאסר ונרתק הגוף והנפש הבהמית המלבישים את נפשו האלקית שלא יהא מושרש ומודבק בהן
and passing over transgression,” for the supernal kindness spreads the more in a lower place, as mentioned above. Through this he can raise his soul and bind it to the light of G‑d, the Infinite One (Ein Sof), blessed be He, and His holiness, and go out of the prison and sheath of the body and the animal soul that clothe his G‑dly soul, so that he will not be rooted and stuck in them.
It also “passes over transgression,” for supernal kindness spreads most in the lowest place, as explained at the start. Through it he can raise his soul, bind it to the Infinite Light, and leave the prison of the body and the animal soul, no longer rooted and stuck in them.
כי החסד נמשל למים2 ומים מנתקין סרכות הריאה3 כשמשקין את הבהמה.4 וכך החסד גובר ומפריד הנפש האלקית מהתלבשותה והתקשרותה במאסר הגוף ליבטל וליכלל אליו ית׳:
For kindness (chesed) is likened to water, and water loosens the adhesions of the lung when the animal is given to drink. So too the kindness prevails and separates the G‑dly soul from its enclothing and its bond in the prison of the body, to be nullified and included in Him, may He be blessed.
Kindness is likened to water, and water loosens the adhesions of the lung when an animal is given to drink, the very image of paragraph 20. So too the supernal kindness loosens the G‑dly soul from the prison of the body, so that it can be nullified and included in G‑d.
The maamar closes the circle: one who is crushed by his distance from G‑d and makes himself like “leftovers” draws the supernal kindness, which, like water loosening the adhesions of the lung, frees the G‑dly soul from the body so that it can cleave to G‑d. This is “Who is a G‑d like You, who bears iniquity and passes over transgression for the remnant of His inheritance.”
Kehot refers to Me’orei Or (letter mem, §16) for kindness as water, and to Beitzah 40a, where the Talmud teaches that one should give an animal water before slaughtering it “because of the adhesion of the hide.”
Marei mekomos
- 1נושא עון ועובר על פשע · Micah 7:18
- 2החסד נמשל למים · ראה מא״א אות מ, סט״ז.
- 3ומים מנתקין סרכות הריאה · ביצה מ, סע״א.
- 4כשמשקין את הבהמה · Beitzah 40a:14–15
Finished the maamar?
Mark it as learned; it counts toward the week and the year’s siyum.
Each Rosh Chodesh the names of those learning here are brought to the Ohel. Add your name, and mark what you learn so it is counted.
In one’s avodah
Contemplate that the world and all of time are as a moment before G‑d, who is unchanged by creation, until the heart burns with longing to cleave to Him. One who cannot reach this should reflect deeply on how far his selfhood and coarseness have taken him, refuse the excuse “this is how I was made,” and humble himself until he becomes crushed and sees himself as receiving only G‑d’s “leftovers.” Such brokenness, even when it is acquired through effort, is not despised: it draws the supernal kindness that lifts his desires back to holiness and frees his soul from the body’s hold.
Questions for discussion
- Why does the maamar insist that teshuvah is for those who study Torah too, and how do the upper and lower hei correspond to thought and speech?
- How does contemplating that time is created anew each hour, and is a mere moment before G‑d, lead to kelos hanefesh?
- What is the difference between “bearing” iniquity and “suppressing” it, and why can the desire behind a sin be raised while the act cannot?
- What distinguishes daka from nidkeh, and why might an acquired brokenness have been thought worthless?
- In what sense does the penitent receive only “leftovers,” and why is recognizing this the condition for G‑d’s kindness?
Key terms in this maamar
- Chesed (kindness)חסד
- Expansive giving. ×32
- The Infinite Light (Or Ein Sof)אור אין סוף
- G‑d's light as it is, beyond all limits, before any contraction.
- Teshuvah (return)תשובה
- Returning to G‑d; not only repentance. ×16
- The Name Havayahהוי׳
- The Tetragrammaton: G‑d as transcending time and bringing all into being.
- Life-forceחיות
- The divine vitality that sustains every creation. ×13
- A dwelling place among the lower realmsדירה בתחתונים
- The purpose of creation: that G‑d be at home in this world. ×2
- The World of Atzilus (Emanation)אצילות
- The highest world, still one with G‑d. ×1
- The Holy One, blessed be Heקב״ה
- Tzimtzum (contraction)צמצום
- The self-concealment of the Infinite Light that makes room for finite worlds. ×3
- The chain of descending worlds (hishtalshelus)השתלשלות
- The step-by-step descent of divine light from the highest level down to this world. ×11
- The Infinite One (Ein Sof)אין סוף
- G‑d's own boundless essence. ×1
- Love and aweאהבה ויראה
- The two 'wings' of divine service. ×1
- The G‑dly soulנפש האלקית
- The soul that is 'a part of G‑d above'. ×1
- The animal soulנפש הבהמית
- The soul that animates the body and its drives. ×4
- The World of Asiyah (Action)עשיה
- The lowest world, including our physical one.
- The light that encompasses all worlds (sovev kol almin)סובב כל עלמין
- Divine light too great to enter the worlds; it 'surrounds' them and affects them from beyond.
- Chochmah (wisdom)חכמה
- The first flash of insight. ×1
- Self-nullification (bittul)ביטול
- Setting aside one's own sense of self before G‑d. ×2
- The Name Elokimאלקים
- G‑d as concealed within nature, measuring and limiting. ×2
- Netzach (victory)נצח
- Perseverance, the drive to overcome. ×1
- Hod (splendor)הוד
- Acknowledgment and yielding. ×1